Sheik falling from shine

[MikeHaggarTHAKJB]

On a few rare occassions I've seen sheik fall from the shine.
Here is a video example:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_X5TfXA2xg&feature=related#t=0m21s

Does anyone know why this happens?

 

[MikeHaggarTHAKJB]

actually after watching that vid carefully and doing some testing i figured it out:
sheik becomes lighter when she charges her forward smash, by a lot aswell. i dont know why she does, but this makes her fall from the shine.
i wonder if other charged smashes do this?

 

[Fortress | Sveet]

All charged smashes make you fall from shine always.

 

[RaynEX]

All charged smashes make you fall from shine always.

This ^

Happens when Sheik tries to ftilt and gets an fsmash, or when she tries to dsmash.

 

[unknown522]

there were a few threads like this before (kind of recently).

 

[MikeHaggarTHAKJB]

All charged smashes make you fall from shine always.

now bowser =P that beast is to heavy
but well i guess all smashes just make you lighter when you charge them. i tested with KO percents and sheik died from upsmash @ like 75%....in PAL (usmash is way weaker here). in NTSC shed prolly die @ like 60%:\

 

[mastermoo420]

It kinda makes sense, though, logically speaking. You see someone charging up a BIG MOVE WITH CRAZY CONCENTRATION and then someone comes up to you and shines you. I mean, if that happened IRL, I would think they'd fall over.

 

[FoxLisk]

It kinda makes sense, though, logically speaking. You see someone charging up a BIG MOVE WITH CRAZY CONCENTRATION and then someone comes up to you and shines you. I mean, if that happened IRL, I would think they'd fall over.

yeah that's probably why they programmed it that way. to keep with the realism of the game.

it sure is handy that every time someone tries to punch me, i can just erect an impenetrable shield around myself, too, speaking of that.

 

[mastermoo420]

If Melee was real life, that'd be ridiculous. Fox u-smash? Wow, nice flash kick. DOUBLE JUMPS? And Captain Falcon's n-air's?!?! But the most ridiculous is his u-throw; he grabs with his hand and then somehow throws with it, lol.

 

[KirbyKaze]

ignore this

/edit

 

[RaynEX]

If you want to talk about smash keeping within the "realism of the game", we're going to need to address:

Talking woodland creatures with pants, lasers, and spaceships

Hermaphrodite ninjas that can disappear at will

Gorillas that rival the size of humans and wear ties

2 dimensional beings? lol

Floating balloons with amazing voices and appendages for limbs.

A swordsman with the power of fire that cannot defeat any of the aforementioned.

*shakes head*

 

[Lovage]

god mikehaggars such a noob

 

[MikeHaggarTHAKJB]

lovage if youre gonna troll be less obvious<3 i could give you lessons

 

[Rappster]

If you want to talk about smash keeping within the "realism of the game", we're going to need to address:

Talking woodland creatures with pants, lasers, and spaceships

Hermaphrodite ninjas that can disappear at will

Monkeys that rival the size of humans and wear ties

2 dimensional beings? lol

Floating balloons with amazing voices and appendages for limbs.

A swordsman with the power of fire that cannot defeat any of the aforementioned.

*shakes head*

Gorillas are apes, fool

 

[RaynEX]

Gorillas are apes, fool

Fixed just for you.

Relax with the insults though.

 

[mastermoo420]

The biggest flaw in your post is that you have not learned to ph34r teh f1re. P:

 

[Da Shuffla]

Lol. . ."appendages for limbs"

Say if I shine someone who is airborne. . . .

Does the stun end upon hitting the ground for all characters, or just those who fall from the shine?

 

[FoxLisk]

all

/10alls

 

[RaynEX]

Technically speaking, it only really matters for characters that don't fall from the shine. If you hit Marth / Peach / DK / Sheik etc. while in airborne, they'll land be able to move freely. If you hit Fox / Jiggs / Roy etc. while airborne, they'll be knocked down so stun isn't an issue anymore.

Every character in the game has a landing animation when they touch any surface after being in the air. When a character that doesn't fall from the shine is hit by the shine and lands on a surface, the stun that propelled them is now canceled by their landing animation. Think of it like that, so it never confuses you again.

 

[4 Aces]

So charging smashes make you lighter. Lol I never knew that.

If you want to talk about smash keeping within the "realism of the game", we're going to need to address:

Talking woodland creatures with pants, lasers, and spaceships

Hermaphrodite ninjas that can disappear at will

Gorillas that rival the size of humans and wear ties

2 dimensional beings? lol

Floating balloons with amazing voices and appendages for limbs.

A swordsman with the power of fire that cannot defeat any of the aforementioned.

*shakes head*

That last part is gold.

 

[krazyzyko]

If Melee was real life, that'd be ridiculous. Fox u-smash? Wow, nice flash kick. DOUBLE JUMPS? And Captain Falcon's n-air's?!?! But the most ridiculous is his u-throw; he grabs with his hand and then somehow throws with it, lol.

Don't forget teching if you get shot or on a car crash. Maybe you can travel for free with high damage%.

 

[omgwtfToph]

If Melee was real life, that'd be ridiculous. Fox u-smash? Wow, nice flash kick. DOUBLE JUMPS? And Captain Falcon's n-air's?!?! But the most ridiculous is his u-throw; he grabs with his hand and then somehow throws with it, lol.

if melee was real life thatd be gay

just pick marth and do one fair. tight your opponent just got cut in half. D:

 

[Dart!]

if melee was real life i would be ganondorf, do you see that package?!

 

[4 Aces]

if melee was real life i would be ganondorf, do you see that package?!

Erm, which package are you talking about? (no seriously)