I get how you feel, but making hard reads a lot isn't a bad thing at all. It makes mix-ups more interesting and exciting. Even Melee required hard reads if you want to kill early or go for a combo
Oh, trust me, I get what you mean.
The problem is that outside of those reads, I find the neutral really empty; I don't feel like there's much "substance", and it takes away from the game for me.
I mean, even in Brawl I had low enough recovery on my aerials (or at least one or two) and adequate reach to properly space myself along with tilts for pokes and occasionally attack string starters, but here, it doesn't feel like I'm given much to work with because there's so much recovery that it's best to just go for the guaranteed stuff since it's mostly simple and, well, guaranteed.
I don't want to ask for much since a lot of the changes I'd like would alter the game much too heavily, but I would really like to see almost nothing but buffs for the "lower" characters and others that need them (mainly in recovery from attacks in general; gordo can get reflected before I even launch it, not to mention it's a huge gamble altogether because there isn't much that doesn't reflect it); it's the easiest thing I can think of that would give the characters more versatility and the game itself more variety.
Despite being a Falco/Fox main in Melee, I absolutely love decent heavies (and grapplers in traditional fighters) because most of the fun does come from hard reads, but when your character has trouble keeping up with even the basics, it starts to wear on you and a lot of matches become way more tedious than they should be (from my perspective).
PM DK is probably my favorite heavy of all time because he's actually freaking good but he's not so good that he completely outshines his flaws; even so, he's given tools (projectile armor, decent range) to help him struggle against characters that can capitalize on his flaws to keep the game balanced, but the tools still require a decent level of skill to use because they're intentionally specific to certain windows during certain moves, coincidentally moves that are used rather often in normal play to better his chances of being able to get in and put up a decent fight.
Or I could just be really stupid and do well at a game without knowing what I'm talking about.
I dunno; I've seen it happen and had it happen to me before, so I wouldn't be surprised.