Roster Prediction Discussion Thread

[FlareHabanero]

Also, yes, we get, Chrom is a lousy choice. Also water is wet and the sun is hot. Let's try to avoid beating a dead horse.

 

[MargnetMan23]

I am butt hurt about that goku should won.

Have fun being wrong =P
but here's a breakdown of my roster

Spoiler

• I thought Jigglypuff was an important addition I mean, he's nintendo's MASCOT after all
• I was concerned about Jigglypuff being a clone of jigglypuff but hey, original 12 *******
• Now Jigglypuff was a very hard choice for me, but when melee came around it just felt like it was time.
• You can't have jigglypuff without the antagonist!
• I thought Bowser Jr. cuz' I liek turtles
• Bubble Monkey iz the best monkey
• Cranky Kong threatened to cane me if I didn't put him on
• We needz our antagonist so Alligator just felt like a shoe in.
• I don't need to justify egg.
• WAAAAAAA
• The groose is loose
• Screw you diddy kong
• We needed a quicker version of Groose
• We seriously programmed and modeled this guy in 3 days
• Omastar is the second most important pokemon rep.
• Jigglypuff is the ****ing mascot of pokemon!
• Omastar is A SHOE IN!
• OK I may be a little biased on this one but hear me out...
• I think Trubbish is a lame addition, he's kind of overrated... But the fan demand was overwhelming
• MUH VETERAN
• Well Metroid IS the mascot of the Metroid series!
• We need our villain >.>
• Hey, need our main character guys...
• His final smash is landmaster so I decided he could be an easy clone.
• I had to cut Fox for Jigglypuff, she's just too important.
• Chandelure is god
• Dee needs an anti-hero rep
• Chandelure is satan
• Well we need a pikmin rep >.>
• TASTE THE RAINBOW MUTHA****A
• Shoe in.
• Shoe in.
• ANNA'S OUR MANA
• He's from Earthbound, he's simply our most deserving mother rep!
• Mr. Saturn's cool too though...
• He kind of turned out to be a clone, but I think he deserves his spot.
• SaturnGamer is god
• Mr. AR is underrated
• We had to cut villager at the last minute...
• Omastar seemed more important then R.O.B :/
• Glassy glassy
• I don't need to justify this.
• PREPARE FOR WOOD! MAKE IT GOOD!
• Big is just too big to not include on the roster.
• Muh recency

 

[OcarinaOfDoom]

How would you react if Chrom actually made it in the game? Just out of curiosity.

 

[Hotfeet444]

Also, yes, we get, Chrom is a lousy choice. Also water is wet and the sun is hot. Let's try to avoid beating a dead horse.

I'm starting to forget the main reason you hate Chrom in the first place...

...this...

Can we please move on from people wanting to beat on my kitten?

 

[kikaru]

Have fun being wrong =P
but here's a breakdown of my roster

Spoiler

• I thought Jigglypuff was an important addition I mean, he's nintendo's MASCOT after all
• I was concerned about Jigglypuff being a clone of jigglypuff but hey, original 12 *****es
• Now Jigglypuff was a very hard choice for me, but when melee came around it just felt like it was time.
• You can't have jigglypuff without the antagonist!
• I thought Bowser Jr. cuz' I liek turtles
• Bubble Monkey iz the best monkey
• Cranky Kong threatened to cane me if I didn't put him on
• We needz our antagonist so Alligator just felt like a shoe in.
• I don't need to justify egg.
• WAAAAAAA
• The groose is loose
• Screw you diddy kong
• We needed a quicker version of Groose
• We seriously programmed and modeled this guy in 3 days
• Omastar is the second most important pokemon rep.
• Jigglypuff is the ****ing mascot of pokemon!
• Omastar is A SHOE IN!
• OK I may be a little biased on this one but hear me out...
• I think Trubbish is a lame addition, he's kind of overrated... But the fan demand was overwhelming
• MUH VETERAN
• Well Metroid IS the mascot of the Metroid series!
• We need our villain >.>
• Hey, need our main character guys...
• His final smash is landmaster so I decided he could be an easy clone.
• I had to cut Fox for Jigglypuff, she's just too important.
• Chandelure is god
• Dee needs an anti-hero rep
• Chandelure is satan
• Well we need a pikmin rep >.>
• TASTE THE RAINBOW MUTHA****A
• Shoe in.
• Shoe in.
• ANNA'S OUR MANA
• He's from Earthbound, he's simply our most deserving mother rep!
• Mr. Saturn's cool too though...
• He kind of turned out to be a clone, but I think he deserves his spot.
• SaturnGamer is god
• Mr. AR is underrated
• We had to cut villager at the last minute...
• Omastar seemed more important then R.O.B :/
• Glassy glassy
• I don't need to justify this.
• PREPARE FOR WOOD! MAKE IT GOOD!
• Big is just too big to not include on the roster.
• Muh recency

MorbidAltruism might be insulted by the lack of Jigglypuff.

 

[Gune]

I hate to admit this but a little part of me wants chrom to replace ike so that I can compare the rage and demand for him to comeback with mewtwo's.....Im such a bad person....

 

[FlareHabanero]

I'm starting to forget the main reason you hate Chrom in the first place...

No gameplay diversity and causing redundancies leaving a bad impression for everyone, and yet some people are under the fallacy assumption that Chrom will be completely original and be a fantastic addition and will cram it down our throats.

 

[Robert of Normandy]

Would you kindly never mention that horrible online show from a horrible website around me again?

Death Battle is the best show on the internet

 

[Gune]

Have fun being wrong =P
but here's a breakdown of my roster

Spoiler

• I thought Jigglypuff was an important addition I mean, he's nintendo's MASCOT after all
• I was concerned about Jigglypuff being a clone of jigglypuff but hey, original 12 *****es
• Now Jigglypuff was a very hard choice for me, but when melee came around it just felt like it was time.
• You can't have jigglypuff without the antagonist!
• I thought Bowser Jr. cuz' I liek turtles
• Bubble Monkey iz the best monkey
• Cranky Kong threatened to cane me if I didn't put him on
• We needz our antagonist so Alligator just felt like a shoe in.
• I don't need to justify egg.
• WAAAAAAA
• The groose is loose
• Screw you diddy kong
• We needed a quicker version of Groose
• We seriously programmed and modeled this guy in 3 days
• Omastar is the second most important pokemon rep.
• Jigglypuff is the ****ing mascot of pokemon!
• Omastar is A SHOE IN!
• OK I may be a little biased on this one but hear me out...
• I think Trubbish is a lame addition, he's kind of overrated... But the fan demand was overwhelming
• MUH VETERAN
• Well Metroid IS the mascot of the Metroid series!
• We need our villain >.>
• Hey, need our main character guys...
• His final smash is landmaster so I decided he could be an easy clone.
• I had to cut Fox for Jigglypuff, she's just too important.
• Chandelure is god
• Dee needs an anti-hero rep
• Chandelure is satan
• Well we need a pikmin rep >.>
• TASTE THE RAINBOW MUTHA****A
• Shoe in.
• Shoe in.
• ANNA'S OUR MANA
• He's from Earthbound, he's simply our most deserving mother rep!
• Mr. Saturn's cool too though...
• He kind of turned out to be a clone, but I think he deserves his spot.
• SaturnGamer is god
• Mr. AR is underrated
• We had to cut villager at the last minute...
• Omastar seemed more important then R.O.B :/
• Glassy glassy
• I don't need to justify this.
• PREPARE FOR WOOD! MAKE IT GOOD!
• Big is just too big to not include on the roster.
• Muh recency

Wrong my ass kryptonite was there goku should have won but I don't care about it because I have vegeta.

 

[MargnetMan23]

Wrong my *** kryptonite was there goku should have won but I don't care about it because I have vegeta.

Muh item that shouldn't of even appeared in the battle in the first place!

 

[Robert of Normandy]

People still butthurt over Goku vs. Superman?

 

[Hotfeet444]

Death Battle is the best show on the internet

Would you kindly rephrase that....?

No gameplay diversity and causing redundancies leaving a bad impression for everyone, and yet some people are under the fallacy assumption that Chrom will be completely original and be a fantastic addition and will cram it down our throats.

And you don't at least have the optimism to think that he can be made differently?

 

[TheDivineDeity]

Well, that was a long break wasn't it? Anyways now that I put that you-know-who-who-shall-not-be-named on ignore (my brain cells will thank me later) I feel much much better, much more clean and not dirty, you know refreshed, brand new. Like washing yourself with soap and taking a shower after bathing in dirt. It feels real good.


So anyways, let me just get this over with. I am an honest and open person, I tell it like it is. I don't bull**** around what i feel about anything, I just say it and be done with it. Being straight-forward and all that. You know, that said maybe I'm just too honest. maybe I'm too honest in what I say about anything. Which is why maybe I should tone down my rhetoric. I should like take into account people have feelings, and maybe I hurt some of them. Well then, I guess we should all just learn to agree and disagree sometimes. We ain't going to agree on everything, but I guess if we aren't going to agree on anything, then we should do it in a nicer peaceful way. So yeah, I should have been nicer to everybody. So am I apologizing? Yes and no. Yeah I'm sorry that some of the stuff I said should have been toned down, like I should have been less harsh, but I'm not sorry for speaking out what i believe is true, like what I feel about some things. So yeah there you have it. My apology. Love it or hate it. I dont care. I've said what I said.

and now my updated roster predictions:

What does everybody think?

 

[FlareHabanero]

And you don't at least have the optimism to think that he can be made differently?

His fate is already sealed to be unoriginal, so it's really not worth bothering with.

 

[Hotfeet444]

His fate is already sealed to be unoriginal, so it's really not worth bothering with.

Then I guess it's the same for Roy?

 

[Conviction]

Oh god, October came too quickly.

 

[Robert of Normandy]

Would you kindly rephrase that....?

Death Battle is highly entertaining, as is most of the other stuff Screwattack makes.

And Felicia isn't even the best Darkstalker

 

[MargnetMan23]

Well, that was a long break wasn't it? Anyways now that I put that you-know-who-who-shall-not-be-named on ignore (my brain cells will thank me later) I feel much much better, much more clean and not dirty, you know refreshed, brand new. Like washing yourself with soap and taking a shower after bathing in dirt. It feels real good.


So anyways, let me just get this over with. I am an honest and open person, I tell it like it is. I don't bull**** around what i feel about anything, I just say it and be done with it. Being straight-forward and all that. You know, that said maybe I'm just too honest. maybe I'm too honest in what I say about anything. Which is why maybe I should tone down my rhetoric. I should like take into account people have feelings, and maybe I hurt some of them. Well then, I guess we should all just learn to agree and disagree sometimes. We ain't going to agree on everything, but I guess if we aren't going to agree on anything, then we should do it in a nicer peaceful way. So yeah, I should have been nicer to everybody. So am I apologizing? Yes and no. Yeah I'm sorry that some of the stuff I said should have been toned down, like I should have been less harsh, but I'm not sorry for speaking out what i believe is true, like what I feel about some things. So yeah there you have it. My apology. Love it or hate it. I dont care. I've said what I said.

and now my updated roster predictions:

View attachment 3066

What does everybody think?

Needs more Diskun

 

[Frostwraith]

His fate is already sealed to be unoriginal, so it's really not worth bothering with.

B-but... ANYTHING CAN CHANGE!

Then I guess it's the same for Roy?

He has t3h ph1r3. Your argument is invalid.

 

[FlareHabanero]

Then I guess it's the same for Roy?

He's also doomed to the same fate.

Bah, mediocre choices all around.

 

[Louie G.]

View attachment 3066

I can't really tell if this is a serious roster. It's all scrambled and stuff. Plus you have Dark Link and Dark Pit, in addition to Knuckles (who I would love actually) ICE CLIMBERS AND FALCO as DLC.
And you have Tails? THREE Sonic reps?
No Vaati, Krystal, Waddle Dee, Tom Nook, or Black Shadow in my opinion, but whatever. They're okay I guess.
3 KI reps is kinda ridiculous, especially if you want to bash MOTHER for being a small series (which is the same size as Kid Icarus).
Cutting Jiggs is a no-no.
Zelda and Impa is kind of dumb.
Chrom instead of Roy is really likely to happen. ( )
Kalos Trainer over Kanto is a no.
I'm okay with Toad actually.
So is this a joke or no, because you winked.

 

[Hotfeet444]

And Felicia isn't even the best Darkstalker

Your trolling is lost on me...I learned to not take opinions people have on Darkstalkers characters seriously in years of dealing with dribbling, idiotic fangirls and mindless drones.

He's also doomed to the same fate.

Bah, mediocre choices all around.

What about if a character like Tiki was possible?

 

[SuperBrawler]

He's also doomed to the same fate.

Bah, mediocre choices all around.

Roy's MAH BOI!

 

[TheDivineDeity]

Then I guess it's the same for Roy?

Roy - exciting fire-sword wielder with red-hair, can shoot projectiles of fire, extremley popular, veteran status, and can be a semi-clone of Marth but also unique
Chrom - boring sword-weilder with blue hair, can't shoot projectiles, extremely unpopular, never been in the game, and may be a Marth clone/semi-clone

Hmmmmmm..... what should I choose???

 

[FlareHabanero]

B-but... ANYTHING CAN CHANGE!

Nope, nothing is going to change. What you see is what you get, an unoriginal character that provides nothing. Don't care if he's supposedly a fan favorite for some people and he's apparently the best Lord ever (protip: he's not). A mediocre character is still a mediocre character.

 

[SuperBrawler]

I can't really tell if this is a serious roster. It's all scrambled and stuff. Plus you have Dark Link and Dark Pit, in addition to Knuckles (who I would love actually) ICE CLIMBERS AND FALCO as DLC.
And you have Tails? THREE Sonic reps?
No Vaati, Krystal, Waddle Dee, Tom Nook, or Black Shadow in my opinion, but whatever. They're okay I guess.
3 KI reps is kinda ridiculous, especially if you want to bash MOTHER for being a small series (which is the same size as Kid Icarus).
Cutting Jiggs is a no-no.
Zelda and Impa is kind of dumb.
Chrom instead of Roy is really likely to happen. ( )
Kalos Trainer over Kanto is a no.
I'm okay with Toad actually.
So is this a joke or no, because you winked.

Some were DLC and costumes. Like Tails and Dark Link, etc.

 

[TheLastJinjo]

He's also doomed to the same fate.

Bah, mediocre choices all around.

Full disagreement on both those statements.

 

[Louie G.]

Roy - exciting fire-sword wielder with red-hair, can shoot projectiles of fire, extremley popular, veteran status, and can be a semi-clone of Marth but also unique
Chrom - boring sword-weilder with blue hair, can't shoot projectiles, extremely unpopular, never been in the game, and may be a Marth clone/semi-clone
Hmmmmmm..... what should I choose???

I'm not even a big Chrom supporter, but your reasoning is bias.
Who are you to say Chrom can't have projectiles? He can have whatever Sakurai wants him to!
Roy has a CUT veteran status, which doesn't help. And Chrom CAN become a Marth semi-clone, while Roy already IS.
And actually Chrom is fairly popular out of his hate-base.
Just another piece of anti-Chrom propaganda.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Nope, nothing is going to change. What you see is what you get, an unoriginal character that provides nothing. Don't care if he's supposedly a fan favorite for some people and he's apparently the best Lord ever (protip: he's not). A mediocre character is still a mediocre character.

 

[MargnetMan23]

Roy - exciting fire-sword wielder with red-hair, can shoot projectiles of fire, extremley popular, veteran status, and can be a semi-clone of Marth but also unique
Chrom - boring sword-weilder with blue hair, can't shoot projectiles, extremely unpopular, never been in the game, and may be a Marth clone/semi-clone

Hmmmmmm..... what should I choose???

Choose neither

And no, fire does not make you unique. Sorry bud.

 

[TheDivineDeity]

I can't really tell if this is a serious roster. It's all scrambled and stuff. Plus you have Dark Link and Dark Pit, in addition to Knuckles (who I would love actually) ICE CLIMBERS AND FALCO as DLC. I forgot to add some cuts to DLC
And you have Tails? THREE Sonic reps? Knuckle is DLC
No Vaati, Krystal, Waddle Dee, Tom Nook, or Black Shadow in my opinion, but whatever. They're okay I guess. whatever
3 KI reps is kinda ridiculous, especially if you want to bash MOTHER for being a small series (which is the same size as Kid Icarus). One series is dead and the other isn't. Guess which one?
Cutting Jiggs is a no-no. Of course the "MUH Original 12" argument
Zelda and Impa is kind of dumb. No its not, Zelda and Sheik is kinda dumb. Whats more recent - OoT or SS? hmm?
Chrom instead of Roy is really likely to happen. ( ) Bull****ing****
Kalos Trainer over Kanto is a no. Why not? Kalos is more recent than Kanto anyways
I'm okay with Toad actually. He deserves it more than Bowser Jr. or Paper mario IMO
So is this a joke or no, because you winked.

I forgot to mention:

Red = DLC
Green = newcomer
Blue = veteran

 

[SuperBrawler]

Choose neither

And no, fire does not make you unique. Sorry bud.

Of course you choose the fire and explosions, u mad bro?

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Oh good a Chrom discussion, where's the popcorn.

 

[FlareHabanero]

View attachment 3068

Chrom is a mediocre character, both from the prospective of Fire Emblem and Super Smash Bros. Nobody would even care about him if Fire Emblem: Awakening wasn't recent.

 

[Louie G.]

Wait, you know what?
Why am I even involved in this?
It's a Chrom discussion, I hate these!

 

[TheLastJinjo]

^ TOO LATE!!!!!

Who are you to say Chrom can't have projectiles? He can have whatever Sakurai wants him to!

Falco can have whatever Sakurai wants him to. But, he's still a semi-clone.

Roy has a CUT veteran status, which doesn't help.

At least he was a veteran at all. A very well received one I might add.

And Chrom CAN become a Marth semi-clone, while Roy already IS.

At least he has Fire & Explosions and distinctive character.

 

[SuperBrawler]

Chrom is a mediocre character, both from the prospective of Fire Emblem and Super Smash Bros. Nobody would even care about him if Fire Emblem: Awakening wasn't recent.

 

[Frostwraith]

To be fair, most FE lords are usually seen as boring characters due to their similarities to Marth (who's already in): I mean, look at Chrom, Seliph, Sigurd or even Leif. All sword users with similar fighting styles and similar story roles. (By similar, I do NOT mean equal! Each character has his own quirks as well, but they fit the same archetype more or less.)

Ike is different and so are Lyn, Hector, Ephraim or Micaiah. Even Roy could be more different in Smash if he had fiery projectiles and some reworks to his moveset, but he was a last minute addition to Melee's roster...

And here we are on another Fire Emblem discussion. Yay.

 

[Rebellious Treecko]

Roy - exciting fire-sword wielder with red-hair, can shoot projectiles of fire, extremley popular, veteran status, and can be a semi-clone of Marth but also unique
Chrom - boring sword-weilder with blue hair, can't shoot projectiles, extremely unpopular, never been in the game, and may be a Marth clone/semi-clone

Hmmmmmm..... what should I choose???

LET'S HAVE BOTH, THEN. Everyone wins! (or loses, depending on your view of things)

-----

 

[SchAlternate]

GUIZE

BEST PURPLE ROSTER WOULD PLAY