Glad to see some people having disagreements with the music finally. I was starting to really feel left out. Yeah it isn't bad (does sound a tad too MIDI-ish to me), but it just loses that power it had that brought out the majesty of the Halberd, a massive flying hunk of technology you would have never expected in the Kirby series.
I don't even mind that jazz was used. It's the arrangement itself that leaves a lot to be desired. The remix starts out decently, but when it gets to the fast-paced part of the song, it gets all uppity and seriously breaks the mood. I keep picturing myself battling as the massive Halberd rockets through the omninous red skies, then comes to the front to fire its twin cannons at everything while people duke it out.....and I hear uppity music that makes me think disco dancin'.... It doesn't do it for me, not after hearing and loving the original for so long. The whole stage's theme is dark, moody, and intense. The music is upbeat and light-hearted.
The actual beginning of the remix isn't so bad. Had it kept that flow I think I would have liked it more. It's fine many people are enjoying it, but the remix could of been even better.
I do find it very interesting though - I think Sakurai would actually
agree with me, as his doubts about the song perfectly describe what I thought, right down to the use of the word "incongruous". Indeed, the music fails to create a harmony between itself and the stage it plays on.
Finally, this is probably subjective, but it seemed like a lot of people were praising this remix just because it's "Meta Knight's Revenge" and they really liked the original...and not necessarily based on the merits of the song itself and what it's supposed to accomplish. In terms of pure nostalgia - reminding people of past music - it does that just fine. But to me it breaks away too much from the original.
Okay I think I said enough. I just wanted to share my opinion where more than just 1 other person among a sea of opposites would agree.
Seriously, no qualms with those who enjoyed it!
BTW, I have no issues with the lackluster updates. It has to happen thanks to E for All. Otherwise the "3 Taunts" update would of been great.