Ok, so SMT is the current "mainline" of MegaTen. Persona is MegaTen. Persona is not SMT. Not even Atlus considers it part of the SMT franchise, it was originally called Megami Ibunroku: Persona, thus it's a spinoff of MegaTen. In fact, I think not even DDS is considered part of SMT, it's still only MegaTen, and a stand-alone spinoff(despite the Demi-Fiend boss battle). You can't say SMT is pandering to a different audience when the SMT games still possess the same general tone and themes that they always have. Persona is the poster child of Atlus because it sells the best for them. If you don't like Persona, then it sucks, but SMT is still SMT.
I felt that S. Links were some of the best part of P3 and P4, when their actual gameplay was boring and insanely easy. The social sim aspects helped to flesh out otherwise bland characters(although I'd argue a few characters were bland anyway), and a couple packed some very emotional moments into them.
Pandering I think is just part of natural evolution of media, it's just called pandering when the focused demographics shifts from what it was normally to another. There's always going to be a shift back, whether it be by the original series, or a new one coming in and taking the focus of the original demographic. It's bad for the original audience, but the shift wouldn't be happening if the original audience made it worth the developer's time to keep focusing on them. FE was failing, and Awakening worked. The new audience is enough for IntSys to keep making games.
I mean technicalities considered, Megaten and SMT are seperate.
But brand wise, that's not really the case. They all fall under a single "SMT" umbrella, espeically in the west. Generally speaking when people speak as SMT as a whole, they're going to talk about all the frachises because SMT an MT have had odd naming schemes since the get go. I mean like the 3rd "SMT" game was a spin off iirc, which was the original SMT or some ****.
Megaten itself hasnt been relavent ever since it never got a release past MT2.
DDS is a spin off of SMT, and Persona has always been marketed as SMT westside.
For all intents and purposes, Megaten is defunct and trying to seperate the sub-series (Devil Summoner, Devil Survivor, DDS, Persona, SMT) as if its a SMT or MT spinoff is seriously pointless and one could argue grasping at straws.
Even then, MT 1 and 2 have had the same themes and formulas as SMT, so if you set aside naming, MT and SMT are pretty much the same ****. It's like trying to argue NSMB vs 3D Marios.
As for the social link, they were okay in P3, but I think in P4 in combination with P4's story in cast was where I was mostly disappointed.
They werent interesting and felt forced. The minor characters that you had to social link with imo were generally pointless and the dating sim aspect of it (until P4G) was without punishment. It just wasnt my cup of tea.
I really dont have much else to say in regards to pandering. It has its place and I generally am okay with it, as long as its kept reasonable and doesnt go too far off the handle to the point where it feels out of place and now you're pandering just for pandering's sake. I guess moderation is the key?
If it sells it sells, and I just have to accept it; doesnt mean I have to like it or be okay with it. I understand why pandering occurs but I wont stop complaining about it if i dont like it lol.