I've been playing Ike a lot and I really like his playstyle. One question I had, who are the best characters that you think Ike has a favorable matchup against? Because poking through this thread it seems like everyone is very pessimistic and doesn't think Ike matches up well with the top tier chars. Who are the best characters that Ike goes at least 55:45 on?
The pessimistic feeling is mostly because the match ups people have trouble with are where the most attention is applied currently. What I can say about Ike is that almost all the 'Top tier' character (there are no such thing yet) aren't that far ahead of him. With good fundamentals (Knowing how to DI, understanding Ike's spacing game, knowing how good zoning works, etc) and mind games, Ike can overcome them. The only real threat right now is Diddy Kong (all those options!), and since everyone is focusing on how to take him down right now it may not be for long.
Ike has plenty against most of the cast. Most light weights fear him since his ability to KO is near legendary. He may not be able to combo as well as other characters, but he hit's hard enough where after 2 or 3 hits (the length of most of his combos) Ike's opponents are already in a uncomfortable position. His heavier weight also makes it harder for them to secure the KO, as long as the Ike player keeps his head. I've never had problems against Kirby, barely against Jiggs and Meta knight, and only a slight issue against Pikachu, ZSS and Fox.
He's got some moves that both KO and have some surprising speed to beat out other heavy weights in kill power too.
He also outspaces most middle weights, which makes it so he can keep even with most of them. He's able to overpower Marth and Lucina, who only have speed on their side and have to contend with both your range and power. Ike isn't the fastest character, but he's one of the faster heavies which allows him to keep up with most of the middle weights as well. (Hell, I think he outruns some of them, like Robin, Lucario and Mega Man)
Ike's higher speed and ability to disrupt projectiles with his sword allow him to beat out most heavy weights. His range helps keep him safe during attacks (I think DeDeDe is the only heavy that out ranges him.) and his speed gets him out of the way of most attacks (And his counter can slip into their smashes that you don't think can be dodged easily!). Most heavies only really have a special grab to counter balance Ike's range and speed, as the few with zoning capabilities can easily be canceled by a well placed n-air or f-air. (Except maybe Samus's full charged Charge Shot, though that can be countered.)
All my points above are real broad generalizations, so these can change as we get to those specific characters and get everyone's experience into account. Currently there isn't a real 'Against these guys you have an advantage' list yet because different Ike players are having different issues with the many matchups, so it will take a while to compile compared to the 'These guys we have an uphill battle' list. (The former list will be bigger, with the size of the roster and all.)
Personally, I have a problem against Ganondorf currently with all those super armor frames he's got and Yoshi's smashes has some surprising speed and length that can easily catch an Ike off guard. (Though I do like back flip to Aerial QD to bait out Egg throws and then slide underneath them for a nice surprising punish. Helps scare them out of using those bloody things for zoning.) If I don't find ways around these on my own, then I know we'll eventually get to them here. I may even be able to contribute to their demise in the ring!
@
PyroTakun
I didn't mean to jump in line with my Cap recommendation. I more wanted to get him on the list. I couldn't remember who was next at the time of the posts writing and figured I'd get him recorded before I forgot.