Platinum End Free-for-All-Mafia GAME OVER: The Big Reveal

[Deleted member]

Sorry I got upset there.
I will admit my defeat, @Opossum .
Since I did not read it, it made your trick even better.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Shiny I would have more respect if you had just taken the bait.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Shiny I would have more respect if you had just taken the bait.

I don't think this is the kind of sentence that you should say to someone with depression...

 

[Deleted member]

Shiny I would have more respect if you had just taken the bait.

Um....
"Taking the bait" is just as not good as "not reading".

 

[Deleted member]

Shiny I would have more respect if you had just taken the bait.

OOoh, I get what you mean.
Instead of getting in a fit, I just should of accepted my defeat.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

I don't think this is the kind of sentence that you should say to someone with depression...

Phrased it bad.

Will edit.

OOoh, I get what you mean.
Instead of getting in a fit, I just should of accepted my defeat.

Basically.

Or at least admit salt like Me and Shish do.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Actually... I can't edit cause mafia.

heck

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Actually... I can't edit cause mafia.

heck

Just write the betterly-phrased version in another post.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

And if someone gets on my case about "betterly-phrased" not being an actual word, I don't care at all.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Shiny got what I meant.

I mean no insult Shiny.

 

[Deleted member]

It is all good guys.
No more worries and tears here.

Only tears I will be getting is if FEH does not give me a Male Fallen Robin.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Only tears I will be getting is if FEH does not give me a Male Fallen Robin.

Considering you tend to summon the second you have 5 orbs, prepare to cry a lot.

 

[Deleted member]

And if someone gets on my case about "betterly-phrased" not being an actual word, I don't care at all.

Salt ghost says it's not an actual word.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Salt ghost says it's not an actual word.

I don't care.

Now go back to being a salt ghost.

 

[Deleted member]

I don't care.

Now go back to being a salt ghost.

Salt ghost says you should care.
Salt ghost is being salt ghost.
Salt ghost demands tomatoes so salt ghost can put all this salt somewhere.
Salt ghost says tomatoes are good.
Salt ghost says eat tomatoes.
Salt ghost is confused as to what salt ghost wanted to initally convey wuth this message.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Salt ghost says you should care.
Salt ghost is being salt ghost.
Salt ghost demands tomatoes so salt ghost can put all this salt somewhere.
Salt ghost says tomatoes are good.
Salt ghost says eat tomatoes.
Salt ghost is confused as to what salt ghost wanted to initally convey wuth this message.

7.8/10 too much salt

 

[Natz~]

Salt ghost says you should care.
Salt ghost is being salt ghost.
Salt ghost demands tomatoes so salt ghost can put all this salt somewhere.
Salt ghost says tomatoes are good.
Salt ghost says eat tomatoes.
Salt ghost is confused as to what salt ghost wanted to initally convey wuth this message.

if ya wanna e cooked with tomatos and stuff go find my brother :V

 

[Gunla]

Swamp Sensei
Not a killer.

 

[redfeatherraven]

Salt ghost says you should care.
Salt ghost is being salt ghost.
Salt ghost demands tomatoes so salt ghost can put all this salt somewhere.
Salt ghost says tomatoes are good.
Salt ghost says eat tomatoes.
Salt ghost is confused as to what salt ghost wanted to initally convey wuth this message.

G E T B A C K I N Y O U R G R A V E

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Swamp Sensei
Not a killer.

Why do you not think Shiny is a killer?

He flat out admitted it.

 

[AlphaSSB]

Why do you not think Shiny is a killer?

He flat out admitted it.

Well, technically, being capable of killing doesn't make one a killer.

The way I look at it, three people have White Arrows, and across three nights, only one has used it. Two are being passive, and one is taking action. Shiny admitted to having not used the arrow yet, making him passive.

If we keep Shiny alive, there's no guarantee if he'll even use the arrow. We lynch Shiny, someone else gets the White Arrow, and the real killer has a free pass into night phase to kill again. It's a dangerous play.

You originally suspected Apollo to be the killer, not Shiny. Why?

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Well, technically, being capable of killing doesn't make one a killer.

The way I look at it, three people have White Arrows, and across three nights, only one has used it. Two are being passive, and one is taking action. Shiny admitted to having not used the arrow yet, making him passive.

If we keep Shiny alive, there's no guarantee if he'll even use the arrow. We lynch Shiny, someone else gets the White Arrow, and the real killer has a free pass into night phase to kill again. It's a dangerous play.

You originally suspected Apollo to be the killer, not Shiny. Why?

Except we have evidence that he lied with how he tried to delete a vote for praline.

It's like he didn't read any of the flavor and just assumed praline was still alive.

But whether he killed her or not, the fact that we know he can kill makes him a big threat.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

It's much safer to go for someone with a confirmed role than a shot in the dark.

 

[AlphaSSB]

Except we have evidence that he lied with how he tried to delete a vote for praline.

It's like he didn't read any of the flavor and just assumed praline was still alive.

But whether he killed her or not, the fact that we know he can kill makes him a big threat.

Shiny wouldn't have voted for Praline if he was the one that killed her. Of course, he also wouldn't have voted for Praline if he read the flavor text. Honestly surprised he wasn't hostkilled for deleting the post.

I still don't think we should just vote for Shiny and call it a day. That solves nothing, just gets a potential threat out of the way while there is a greater one still among us. We need to be trying and figure out who killed Praline.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Shiny wouldn't have voted for Praline if he was the one that killed her.

Yeah, if he read the flavor.

Heck, his mistake of thinking everyone had a white arrow also means he pretty much didn't read a single post since the game began because there's been lots of talk about different ranks and what they do.

Besides, it's much safer to kill Shiny now than wait. I mean, what if another Special Rank goes for him tonight and he dies? We'd never know who got him with a Red Arrow, which could make this game even scarier...

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

I agree it solves nothing like you said, especially is Shiny isn't the one who used the White Arrow, but at the same time, it'd be much better to get him killed ASAP so that we know who gets his White Arrow, if anyone.

 

[Holder of the Heel]

Honestly surprised he wasn't hostkilled for deleting the post.

I'm kill happy as a player, but as a host I need to be at least somewhat prudent with power. Effectively speaking, so far he hasn't done anything more than be mildly annoying.

 

[AlphaSSB]

Yeah, if he read the flavor.

Heck, his mistake of thinking everyone had a white arrow also means he pretty much didn't read a single post since the game began because there's been lots of talk about different ranks and what they do.

Believe me, if we didn't have a larger issue at hand, I'd be okay with lynching him on this premise alone.

Besides, it's much safer to kill Shiny now than wait. I mean, what if another Special Rank goes for him tonight and he dies? We'd never know who got him with a Red Arrow, which could make this game even scarier...

Use of wings would prevent that.

I agree it solves nothing like you said, especially is Shiny isn't the one who used the White Arrow, but at the same time, it'd be much better to get him killed ASAP so that we know who gets his White Arrow, if anyone.

The problem there is that whoever gets the White Arrow is going to be killed off next. Then, if someone gets the arrow after that, they'll be next. Eventually, we just start lynching and forget about Praline's murderer. It makes for a potential slippery slope.

I'm kill happy as a player, but as a host I need to be at least somewhat prudent with power. Effectively speaking, so far he hasn't done anything more than be mildly annoying.

Fair enough.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Believe me, if we didn't have a larger issue at hand, I'd be okay with lynching him on this premise alone.

And how do you know there's a larger issue?

We have no idea who killed praline. Could be Shiny, could be anyone.

I'd rather play it safe.

Use of wings would prevent that.

Fair enough.

The problem there is that whoever gets the White Arrow is going to be killed off next. Then, if someone gets the arrow after that, they'll be next. Eventually, we just start lynching and forget about Praline's murderer. It makes for a potential slippery slope.

Fair enough, but it still means we have a killer on the loose.

 

[AlphaSSB]

And how do you know there's a larger issue?

we have a killer on the loose.

You answered that yourself. Shiny dies, and we still have a killer on the loose.

We have reason to believe that Shiny wasn't the killer. Yes, he wouldn't have voted for Praline if he read the flavor text, but I also don't believe that he would've voted if he was the killer. It just doesn't make sense to me. Plus, he admitted to having shot Opo with a Red Arrow on that night. That's why I don't believe Shiny did it, and why I think we're wasting our time with him.

Look, I don't care if the kid lives or dies, I just think we've got a bigger issue.

 

[Natz~]

alpha got a point....i rather kill the one who killed praline then go for a possible white arrow if its just gonna transfer to someone :/

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Plus, he admitted to having shot Opo with a Red Arrow on that night.

He poorly worded that though; he actually did it on the first night.

You answered that yourself. Shiny dies, and we still have a killer on the loose.

We have reason to believe that Shiny wasn't the killer. Yes, he wouldn't have voted for Praline if he read the flavor text, but I also don't believe that he would've voted if he was the killer. It just doesn't make sense to me. Plus, he admitted to having shot Opo with a Red Arrow on that night. That's why I don't believe Shiny did it, and why I think we're wasting our time with him.

Look, I don't care if the kid lives or dies, I just think we've got a bigger issue.

alpha got a point....i rather kill the one who killed praline then go for a possible white arrow if its just gonna transfer to someone :/

Alright, those are fair point.

But then... who do we go for?

Not to mention we only have two hours to thinlk of someone. Not saying that makes it impossible, just that our time is very limited.

 

[Holder of the Heel]

Two hours left in the Day.

There is a chance I might be preoccupied at that time, so if I don't drop in with the results/flavor when the Day is up, just know that any votes beyond that point will not be counted.

 

[AlphaSSB]

He poorly worded that though; he actually did it on the first night.

Damn, you're not wrong.

Alright, those are fair point.

But then... who do we go for?

Not to mention we only have two hours to thinlk of someone. Not saying that makes it impossible, just that our time is very limited.

That's why I asked Swamp why he thought Apollo did it.

So, I'll ask again.

Swamp Sensei why did you originally believe for Apollo to be the killer?

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Damn, you're not wrong.

Exactly.

That means we have no idea what he did on the second night.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

But still, I'm also curious on why he thinks Pollo is a Special Rank.

 

[Natz~]

He poorly worded that though; he actually did it on the first night.



Alright, those are fair point.

But then... who do we go for?

Not to mention we only have two hours to thinlk of someone. Not saying that makes it impossible, just that our time is very limited.

theres....three of us right here right now?
both me and you got votes on shiny, whos got about 5 on him...

we probs won't save shiny but we can kill someone alongside him

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

theres....three of us right here right now?
both me and you got votes on shiny, whos got about 5 on him...

we probs won't save shiny but we can kill someone alongside him

But who?

Pollo?

 

[Natz~]

But who?

Pollo?

-shrugs-
lets think things out....

who do we know is first and second class angels?

if we can decide that we can give ourselves some room of leniency of who could be third classes

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

who do we know is first and second class angels?

Red claimed Second Rank, iirc.