Kotastic
Smash Ace
I hope it's Brawl
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
watdo you call I WANT ****ING 2 STOCKS WELL I WANT 3
FD SHOULD BE BANNED BECAUSE OF BLINDING LIGHTS
BATTLE FIELD LEDGES ARE GAY
DIDDY KONG IS THE BEST
NO GRENIJA
NO DIDDY
a good community
The majority of the FGC will never take us seriously and a game being competitive only relies on how big a scene is not on the skill ceiling nor the techs so that said Melee is more competitive due to the bigger competitive player base. Nintendo is sponsoring the event so Smash 4 will most likely to be the one to take center stage which would make the most sense to do.It better be Melee tbh. Melee is faster, less campy, more competitive, more impressive, and most importantly, more entertaining to watch. If we want the FGC to take us seriously, it's best we play Melee.
i agree fully when saying that people jump on other people if they say one game is better than melee and no game really is better than the other it all goes down to people opinions and my opinion on the smash 4 is that its a fair 50/50 between the people that just wanna play the game with a ruleset without arguing and the people that always want to argue about tier lists and rules and the leffen incident was years ago when the internet wasn't as mature as it is nowBoth community has their fair share of good and bad. I agree the 2 stock vs 3 stock, Diddy controversies and some crazed fans are a harm in our community.
But you can't deny, that you do have some bad apples here and there. May I remind you Leffen incident.
Also, some of the vocal minority take it personally(and by personally, I mean insults you) if you say another Smash game is better than Melee. I mean, it comes in opinions, but... you shall be damned if you think that Smash 64/Brawl/Sm4sh is a better game then Melee.
Internet? Mature? I don't think so. Unless it became 20XX when I wasn't looking.the leffen incident was years ago when the internet wasn't as mature as it is now
I like all of the Smash games (even Brawl), but I still think it should be Melee on the big stage.Meanwhile PM, 64, and Brawl fans are all just sitting on the sidelines reading this debate.
Not true at all. Melee the last 2 years has had one of the quickest run Top 8's. 2 years ago it finished about half an hour earlier than the slot it was allotted, and last year Melee finished 40 minutes late even though it started 60 minutes late. That's 20 minutes of gained time.From the perspective of someone who mostly plays non smash fighters, this is a good thing. Whether this community can admit it or not, ALL Smash games take longer to run in tournament than other fighters.
Like within 2 months of the EVO announcement most everyone expected that lol. Melee interest just kept growing, and after that January and February Melee had, Melee drawing over 50k viewers six times after EVO (which the only traditional FGC game was able to do that was Ultra), and Melee having less than 20% crossover with Smash 4 at APEX, it was impossible to say "no" to Melee if you want maximum revenue.No one was expecting both Melee and Smash 4 to both be at EVO at all
What fightng games?Can't believe we lost good fighting games just to host 2 smash games and persona.
Totally disagree. Melee takes more skill, it will be taken more seriously.The FGC didn't take Melee seriously, over the 14 years of its existence and plenty of time on main stage.
What makes you think that Melee getting main stage this year will change anything?
In my observations, Sm4sh shares more sensibilities with FGC games. The neutral game, footsies, transitions, mind-games, etc. are very reminiscent of SF4.
Melee is more comparable to SF3, which had been easily phased out by SF4, which will be phased out by SF5. (The natural progression of fighting game communities) Meanwhile Melee has been kicking and screaming in defiance to the advancement of time, tech, and subsequent entries)
If the FGC will acknowledge any Smash, it's more likely going to be Sm4sh. The tendency to hold on to a 14 great old entry with childish, bitterness towards Sakurai and the new titles, selfishly wanting a Melee style Smash when that clearly won't happen again, is one reason why the FGC won't take Smash seriously, and views us Smash players as immature children.
Is logical for EVO to NOT push Sm4sh to the back burner. It would please Nintendo (sponsor and all), it would help Sm4sh grow (being the newer game while Melee is so old and established that it doesn't need any more biased publicity), and would solidify the Sm4sh ruleset worldwide.
In the long run, there are more benefits to Smash, as a franchise, to help Sm4sh along by giving it the spotlight this year and seeing how it does. Especially since Melee lacks the accessibility to bring in half as many new players as Sm4sh does. Players who will become fans of the franchise, ensuring that the Smash franchise will keep going.
This is coming from logic and business seems, not bias.
Yo share some of that.I'm just on the PM side, eating popcorn
You really aren't doing yourself favors by pulling a stunt like this.do you call I WANT ****ING 2 STOCKS WELL I WANT 3
FD SHOULD BE BANNED BECAUSE OF BLINDING LIGHTS
BATTLE FIELD LEDGES ARE GAY
DIDDY KONG IS THE BEST
NO GRENIJA
NO DIDDY
a good community
I'm hit or miss with this.Sorry man but there are TONS of inconsistencies in your post. Lets first talk about your comparisons to Street Fighter. First, you say Smash 4 is more like Street Fighter 4 than Melee because "neutral game, footsies, transitions, mind games". I'm sorry, but what are you even rambling about? Smash 4 does not have a more interesting or varied neutral game than Melee. In Melee, you have more safe options in neutral than you do in Smash 4. You can do more things. In Street Fighter IV, you have more options. In Smash 4, you are actually pretty severely limited on what you can or can't do in the neutral game. For some characters they literally have an amount of moves that you can count on one hand that are fit for playing footsies with. Smash 4 is nothing like other fighting games in this regard.
Second, you say Melee is more like Street Fighter 3. I also think that this isn't necessarily correct. First of all, it depends on what version of SF3 (or SF4 for that matter) that you're talking about, but I'm going to go ahead and assume you mean Third Strike. Third Strike is a more precise game in general than Street Fighter IV, and it supports somewhat more aggressive play in the parry system, in that you can be aggressive in your defense. But Street Fighter IV has an abundance of more frame tight links than Third Strike, and some matchups are even more punishing than common matchups in Third Strike were. Melee is no more similar to one than the other, in fact, Melee is a lot more comparable to games like Blazblue, where the goal is to try to get your opponent stuck on the defensive, and in the corner, where you can exploit them with long block strings and whittle down their defenses and convert into long combos from it.
I promise you, Smash 4 is no more relatable than Melee to most other fighting game fanbases. In fact, it's highly arguable that it's even less so because there isn't nearly as much execution skill needed, which is itself a somewhat contentious part of fighting games in general, with the majority supporting input skill being a major facet of the game. At the very bare minimum, people who play games like BB, UNIEL, Street Fighter, etc can respect the precision and input speed needed in a game like Melee. It's harder to appreciate it in Smash 4 because the precision comes more from timing and not necessarily speed for the most part.
Also, lol, Smash 4 being at Evo has nothing to do with the Super Smash Bros. franchise's ability to continue. Smash Bros has existed without tournament support well over a decade. It is established.
EDIT: Also, SFIV has NOT replaced SF3. There are still Third Strike tournaments. There are still SF2 Turbo tournaments. It was on the main stage at Evo last year. You don't know much about these communities.
It really isn't that simple or obvious.How is this even a debate? It's so obvious which game get's which day.
Smash 4 takes longer and is still a new tourney format so they need more time to run it, so it gets Sunday. Also, Nintendo supports sm4sh and Mr wizard wants money sooo..... Yeah. melee saturday, sm4sh sunday
Hah, easy for Smashers to say! Many other amazing fighting games aren't getting in this year despite having HUGE followings at recent regionals. Just look at UNIEL. Bigger than Persona by a MASSIVE margin and it still didn't get in. We could have used that spot. Don't say it was an easy decision; Mr Wizard himself has already said it's not easy picking games for Evo as it's not purely about maximum amount of players; there is a LOT more to consider.Add in that BBCP died out due to awful patches, and KOF13 just died, and it was an easy decision.
Of course it's easy for Smashers to say, lol. If it wasn't for EVO trying to diversify their game roster and instead focus 100% purely on maximizing each game's attendance (and legal issues in regard to IP ownership weren't a thing we had to worry about), Project M would probably be there in over Persona.Hah, easy for Smashers to say! Many other amazing fighting games aren't getting in this year despite having HUGE followings at recent regionals. Just look at UNIEL. Bigger than Persona by a MASSIVE margin and it still didn't get in. We could have used that spot. Don't say it was an easy decision; Mr Wizard himself has already said it's not easy picking games for Evo as it's not purely about maximum amount of players; there is a LOT more to consider.
I'm not sure I agree with a 4 day Evo. Having it take place on a weekend and only a weekend makes the event MUCH easier for college students (especially this group) and people with jobs to make the event. Adding another day guarantees cutting out a lot of the traditional audience.Honestly the whole "Melee and Smash 4 are similar" thing kind of kills me.
They're as different as Marvel and Street Fighter in functionality. The end goal is the same, sure, but how you approach both games is so insanely different that it's almost like they're from different series. I've said this before, I'll say it again, but 64, Melee/PM, and Brawl/Smash 4 feel like 3 different series. I don't like the whole "lump them together at FGC games towards the same audience" deal, since they don't attract the same audiences.
If we honest to God looked at the gameplay first and foremost and not the first three names of the game, Melee and Smash 4 would both have separately earned a right to be "main event showcased games" on nearly an equal platform.
Of course it's easy for Smashers to say, lol. If it wasn't for EVO trying to diversify their game roster and instead focus 100% purely on maximizing each game's attendance (and legal issues in regard to IP ownership weren't a thing we had to worry about), Project M would probably be there in over Persona.
As for UNIEL, I think that was a Arc System Works call. Honestly though, I'm surprised Persona 4 even got a spot. I wasn't seeing that game at FGC events much at all (since like early 2014) until it was announced for EVO, lol.
Although speaking of which, the idea of a 4 day EVO for more games sounds good. I'd like to see the game roster increase by 2-4 games, especially since the FGC seems to be on the verge of blowing up as a big sub-scene of the greater eSports sphere. Of course, my bias to want Skullgirls at EVO, KOF13 coming back, and Xrd/Smash 4/Marvel 3 staying (as a viewer who loves watching fighting games as a stream monster) is influenced by that!![]()
Eventually something has gotta give. Whether we need 2 EVO's (or another EVO equivalent) with different game rosters. I think inevitably we'll get more big fighting game majors that have numbers that truly are large like EVO. Perhaps CEO is becoming one of them.I'm not sure I agree with a 4 day Evo. Having it take place on a weekend and only a weekend makes the event MUCH easier for college students (especially this group) and people with jobs to make the event. Adding another day guarantees cutting out a lot of the traditional audience.
You know, I don't see it much differently than territories or states of a country not wanting to be like one another but still being together.As for the whole esports and fighting games thing, I think that's actually a rather touchy subject for a lot of fighting game players. If you ask a lot of them, they really don't like the esports label. They don't like being tossed in with games likes League of Legends etc. The mentality between competitors in fighting games is very different. The scene in general is much less "professional", for lack of a better word. It's more rough as a whole. And a lot of players are very defensive about maintaining this culture, and I can't say I disagree with them on that.
Mine tells me that a platform like Twitch is only the beginning. As television becomes the internet, and is replaced by whatever the internet chooses to make it, we're gonna see Twitch and other gaming stream services become even huger and get huge ad revenue.My foresight is that it WILL get a little bigger but that it's going to cap off. There won't be massive multi-multi million dollar pots ever. I don't think that's gonna happen, but when Street Fighter V comes out there will probably be a really big resurgence.
You have to realize the irony here.1) the average Sm4sh player respects Melee more than the reverse
2) Melee is just generally the community that b!tches when it's slighted which it will feel it has been if it gives the stage up.
:/
Melee should be streamed on Sunday. Smash 4 hasn't done anything to deserve it. This is Melee's 3rd year in a row at EVO now. It deserves to be there. Smash 4 is only there because it's new. If it comes back for next year, then maybe it'll get streamed on Sunday. Until then, Melee should be on Sunday.
yeah, well, you see, the thing is, the "tournament champion" is usually the best in the world. no, some nobody from cambodia or whatever can beat melee's top 10. they CAN NOT. do they have the potential? yes, everyone does, but if they are as isolated as you make them out to be they can't be that good(currently). the reason the "tournament champion" is so, is because he has had years of experience, countless hours of practice and study, and the ability to play under immense pressure. I don't believe some nobody can attain all that in isolation.Tournaments can only decide the tournament champion, not the best player in the world.