I didn't compare Smash to them though?
No, not directly.
My understanding is that you were attempting to use a certain point I'm familiar with, anecdotally, as "one white blackbird." That is, "All it takes is one white blackbird to prove that not all blackbirds are black." When examples are available and verifiable, it's an effective argument against absolutes.
And it's fair to say it was used accurately. Yellow's statement was blanket, this was a fair counter to the blanket statement.
But there's some pretty serious tacit implications in the context of the current discussion. One could point out, for example, that you used a series of below-standards games to illustrate a point related to a debate about a game that, were it comprised of nothing more than the current information presented, falls below your standards.
Now you've acknowledged, and I concur, that there's more to be seen. Therefore we can't
really make a solid debate over the game's deserved price point yet, as only one of the two of us has a solidified stance.
What I would like to know is why you believe a game with five games' worth of fighters, at least 7 of which are new to this installment and 2 of which are new to the series as a whole, crammed into a shell with a host of mechanical changes and a who's-who of the best stages the series has offered thus far, is not worth its price of entry.
Because that is my argument, in full, why it is. That is more than sufficient content for me, especially this fast - we haven't gotten a Smash title this early into a console cycle since Melee. If Sakurai did nothing else - literally nothing else, no adventure mode, no SSE, no Smash Run, no equivalents,
no kidding - I'd have sixty dollars in his hand on launch day.
It isn't about standards at that point. It's about being a man who knows what he's here for.
And what I am here for is beating the **** out of the widest possible array of Nintendo characters with a yellow lightning rat on a system that can go nearly anywhere and has a half-decent not-3DS control scheme
and that is what they are letting me do.