I enjoyed the Sonic games more when I was younger. Now I find most of them... a little overly simplistic.
Also isn't the whole superhero genre something that isn't meant to be taken dead seriously yet contains high stakes and revolves around those with superpowers saving the world from evil smarties? A lot of them are cocky too. Spiderman fighting the evil scientists, Deadpool fighting the evil scientists, Iron Man fighting the evil scientists... that other guy who runs really fast fighting the evil scientists. Most don't involve hedgehogs, but the archetypes aren't really breaking new ground.
I agree with that last paragraph though.
I don't know if the brunt of criticism towards Sonic games is centered around the sense of general realism...I enjoy Sonic, even the modern games that people tend to fault for existing. I certainly don't see any reason to change what it is, I just think that it needs to be handled with a little more care.
It's a cocky blue hedgehog with superpowers that saves the world from an egg obsessed mad scientist. It's not meant to be taken dead seriously, and it (usually) isn't. But just because something isn't meant to be taken dead seriously doesn't mean it can't have high stakes either. That's the beauty of it, it's a kind of jutaxposition not every game will touch. It's no fun to segregate certain tropes off, it's much more interesting to mix them together and see what happens.
It's fun to just play a game and have the wind in your face while fighting rather fast paced enemies as you come across them. Combine that with a setting that has the right balance of funny, cute, and awesome, and you've got my kind of game.
Also isn't the whole superhero genre something that isn't meant to be taken dead seriously yet contains high stakes and revolves around those with superpowers saving the world from evil smarties? A lot of them are cocky too. Spiderman fighting the evil scientists, Deadpool fighting the evil scientists, Iron Man fighting the evil scientists... that other guy who runs really fast fighting the evil scientists. Most don't involve hedgehogs, but the archetypes aren't really breaking new ground.
I agree with that last paragraph though.