There's nothing weird about it.
Until there's some evidence presented, there's nothing worth raising a fuss over. Innocent until proven guilty. And even then, it should be handled by the proper authorities, rather than a mob with pitchforks. I'm just relishing the fact that the propagators of all the witch hunts through all their virtue signalling are getting their just deserts. And one of the places most responsible for entwining videogames with politics is finally dead.
I'd say that's plenty to be celebrating over.
I care not for what may or may have not happened between two people privately, that, again, should be handled by the proper authorities.
The only thing I care about is the dramatic irony of it all, and fact that the biggest safe space on the web is dead.
It should be fine to have places on the web curated so that people don't have to be subjected to bullying on the basis of meaningless differences.
NeoGAF wasn't really that though, because people still had impunity to be vile towards each other over literally everything except specific issues that happened to create a community full of exactly the kind of people that would most be bothered by a guy walking naked and uninvited into the shower behind a colleague. To agree with at least one minor point of your argument and as I said before, EviLore created his own worst enemy with NeoGAF. A community full of people ranging from mildly irritable to downright vitriolic with their one common thread being that they were still well intentioned on the subject of respecting oppressed groups, often to the already highly visible degree of boycotting any game or company that had their dirty laundry aired.
Honestly I'm the opposite. This was one of the few major gaming communities out there, and a treasure trove of information and history spanning back decades, and now it's all gone. But watching an authority figure burn right off of his pedestal is pretty darn cathartic. People are passing around evidence that he's had quite the history of being an awful person, I see no reason why he should be given a free pass just because he has a reputation.
My only hope is that maybe part of the community can redistribute into a better natured group able to include new members without gating it so that only college students can join and foster an environment a bit less geared towards being spiteful towards everything in existence. There's people out there that deserve better, and the fact that an entire community had the conscience to back off when their leader had his true colors displayed says that maybe some of them could be capable of that with a different crowd to hang out with.