Schnee117
Too Majestic for Gender
They can do what they want because it's already been said that their games are non-canon to the actual continuity of the Tolkienverse.Monolith gave their reasoning on having a big *** spider becoming eye candy
Our approach to Shelob and a lot of these characters is that they're spirits. They're effectively angels or gods, and they take on different forms depending on what their needs are. Shelob and her mother are these elemental spirits, so she can take on the form of a great spider, because that's absolutely terrifying, but she can also take on other forms, ‘fair forms,’ if she's communicating with Talion or Sauron."
"Shelob goes into the giant spider form after Sauron lets her down, and leaves her for dead. A spider is a creature that is singular and alone, and she's not interested in dealing with humans. She's building up this great grief and resentment, and by the time Talion comes along, that's been her form for so long. Talion almost forces her to step into this lighter form, in order to guide him. You almost see a mothering aspect in their relationship, so some of that resentment is lessened by their relationship."
Any Tolkien fans ok with this?
Though they could have opted to make Shelob a half-Spider/half-woman thing instead.