There's a number of pokemon fans that left the fandom altogether in favour of Yokai Watch...you yourself are an example are you not?
Yes I am.
Yokai Watch already borrows a lot from what makes Pokemon, as well as Digimon did before it...
Heck YKW2 is implementing different versions....WITH version exclusives AND trading being added...
You can't complain about Pokemon borrowing things from Yokai Watch when Yokai Watch has done the same to pokemon...
I mean, to be fair, depending on your outlook, trading and version exclusives are arguably basic elements for the monster collecting genre. And I don't have a problem YW taking those basic ideas.
What I do have a problem with is that Pokemon seems to be adding a few
specific things and changing its pace with the anime that makes it closer to YW's structure:
-Adding a
ghostly side-kick who helps you gather data for monsters, having a similar premise to Whisper.
-Suddenly changing the pace of the Pokemon anime to hit closer to a slice-of-life school anime similar to YW and putting Ash back to school. (Which is theorized according the CoroCoro leak)
-Directly making Z-Rings
a watch toy like the Yo-kai Watch watch toy to summon powerful attacks, in addition to trainers dancing being part of a phase, somewhat like when Yo-kai dance with their specific tribe song to get summoned.
I can understand Pokemon wanting to change after seeing YW2 dominated ORAS in sales in Japan, but as someone who bears knowledge of both franchises, you can't help but feel suspicious and think that Game Freak took direct specific ideas from Yo-kai Watch to implement in their franchise. Some of the additions/changes do not feel really necessary and feel added for the sake of being competitive to other monster collecting games.
That's where I base my opinion from. And I feel the need to share this long opinion because it personally concerns me to where the Pokemon franchise will go to in the future, with a path of being similar or having its own identity again in the next generation.
Is it a bad idea to take some general ideas to help improve your franchise? No. But when you transition and take very s
pecific cues that made YW great into the games/anime to make Pokemon better, I can't help but feel personally upset at Game Freak.