Nickelodeon All-Stars Brawl General Thread - All Star Brawl 2 Available Today!

[Guynamednelson]

You would think given any company would want to capsize on Smash's success that Nick would give GameMills better marketing. If that's the case, why even attempt a Smash clone to begin with?

Kids' TV networks are out of touch with the video game industry to begin with. They still are iffy about advertising E10+ rated games despite having commercials for PG-13 movies.

 

[CapitaineCrash]

Looks like we're going to wait for next week.

 

[Guynamednelson]

i am THIS close to

apologizing to GameMill for accusing their marketing department of being the terrible one

 

[Alicorn]

At least we don't have to wonder if its coming this week. I now feel like I can relax.

 

[Quick Gaming (QG)]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

 

[DrifloonEmpire]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

Just 25? Oh, that's a toughie!

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Squidward
4. Sandy
5. Lincoln
6. Lucy
7. Luna or Clyde
8. Aang
9. Zuko or Sokka
10. Katara or Toph
11. Leonardo
12. Michaelangelo
13. Raphael
14. Donatello
15. Arnold or Helga
16. Danny Phantom
17. Vlad Plasmius
18. Nigel or Eliza Thornberry
19. Jimmy Neutron
20. Garfield
21. Jenny
22. Tommy or Reptar
23. Otis
24. Timmy Turner
25. Catscratch Trio

 

[Mamboo07]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

Sounds interesting!

Alright, here's mine...
Roster

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Sandy
4. Squidward
5. Krabs
6. Lincoln
7. Lucy
8. Luan
9. Aang
10. Zuko
11. Toph
12. Leo
13. Mikey
14. Ralph
15. Donatello
16. Danny
17. Vlad
18. Nigel Thornberry
19. Jimmy Neutron
20. Reptar
21. Timmy (if copyright issues weren't in the way)
22. CatDog
23. Norbet & Daggett
24. Otis
25. Bessie Higgenbottom

 

[darkvortex]

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Squidward
4. Mr. Krabs
5. Danny Phantom
6. Jimmy Neutron
7. Zim
8. Aang
9. Korra
10. Zuko
11. Michaelangelo
12. Raphael
13. Shredder
14. Tigre
15. Helga
16. Jenny
17. Cat-Dog
18. Nigel Thornberry
19. Fanboy
20. Garfield
21. Reptar
22. Angelica
23. Stimpy
24. Timmy Turner
25. Rocko

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

1. SpongeBob
2. Patrick
3. Mr. Krabs
4. Squidward
5. Luna Loud
6. Michelangelo
7. Shredder
8. Garfield
9. Odie
10. Aang
11. Tommy (Baby)
12. Reptar
13. Ren
14. Stimpy
15. Powdered Toast Man
16. Gerald
17. Ed Bighead
18. Dr. Hutch
19. CatDog
20. Jenny
21. Zim
22. Fanboy and Chum Chum
23. Swiper
24. Ebeneezer T. Squint
25. Rattlesnake Jake

funny cassette tape decade bias go brrr

HM to Jimmy, Korra, a second turtle, Helga, and a FOP rep - who were low priority - Rocko - who I didn't want to overrep and thought Hutch and Bighead were higher priorities - and Nigel, Lucy, Hugh, Oblina, duo R&S, and Grandma, who I would likely not have considered if NASB didn't exist

ok, admittedly most of these ideas i wouldn't have if nasb didn't exist, since it did basically open my eyes to a different style of roster design, but still

 

[BluePikmin11]

Me rn to the Nick staff.

 

[Opossum]

1. Spongebob Squarepants
2. Patrick Star
3. Sandy Cheeks
4. Squidward Tentacles
5. Plankton
6. CatDog
7. Jimmy Neutron
8. Hugh Neutron
9. Arnold
10. Gerald
11. Helga
12. Grandma Gertie
13. Aang
14. Katara
15. Toph
16. Zuko
17. Sokka
18. Timmy Turner
19. Rocko
20. Reptar
21. Rudy Tabootie
22. Garfield
23. Nigel Thornberry
24. Danny Phantom
25. Jenny Wakeman


Sticking to just 25 is tough.

 

[Capybara Gaming]

I like that everyone here sort of universally agrees that TLA is infitely better than Korra.

 

[LimeTH]

If we're talking like a definitive Nickelodeon roster with no shows taken out but I can put in whoever I want to fill in the remainders, then...

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Aang
4. Korra
5. Lincoln
6. Lucy
7. Leonardo
8. Raphael
9. Ren and Stimpy
10. Reptar
11. Danny Phantom
12. Jimmy Neutron
13. Timmy Turner/Cosmo and Wanda
14. Helga
15. CatDog
16. Invader ZIM
17. GIR
18. Nigel Thornberry
19. Rocko
20. Jenny
21. Daggett
22. Norbert
23. Oblina
24. Garfield
25. El Tigre

Narrowing it down IS hard, not gonna lie. If I were allowed like five extra slots, I'd throw in Stick Stickly, the Flesh, Otis, Snap and Ed from Good Burger.

 

[dlewis53]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

In no particular order:

1. SpongeBob
2. Patrick
3. Squidward
4. Danny Phantom
5. Vlad Plasmius
6. Aang
7. Zuko
8. Katara
9. Sokka
10. Zim
11. Jenny
12. El Tigre
13. Timmy Turner
14. Jimmy Neutron
15. Hugh Neutron
16. CatDog
17. Po
18. Skipper
19. Helga
20. Snap
21. Nigel Thornberry
22. Lincoln Loud
23. Lucy Loud
24. Luna Loud
25. Otis

 

[Michael the Spikester]

Spongebob
Patrick
Squidward
Danny Phantom
Aang
Zuko
Korra
Zim
Jenny
El Tigre
Jimmy Neutron
Reptar
Ren & Stimpy
Powdered Toastman
Oblina
Daggett & Norbert
CatDog
Garfield
Otis
Lincoln Loud
Lucy Loud
Leonardo
Donatello
Raphael
Michelangelo

 

[CapitaineCrash]

Spoiler: Roster big image

Here's mine. Like others said, it's actually pretty hard to choose 25 characters. I wanted as many different series as possible so only SpongeBob, TMNT, Loud house and Avatar is getting multiple characters. I went back and forth with a lot of choices. Only 2 turtles might be controversial but they just take way too much spot imo even if the franchise is huge. At first I also had solo Ren but since Stimpy wouldn't get in either way I figured you might as well keep the duo formula.

And you can see there's 5 empty slot. This is because if this roster would get 5 dlc I would add those:

Spoiler: Roster with dlc big image

So again with dlc, Spongebob is the only one getting another rep because I wanted mostly new franchises. Also Doug is the final dlc because every platform fighters must end their dlc cycle with a big Disney character reveal now.

 

[Ze Diglett]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

1. SpongeBob
2. Patrick
3. Squidward
4. Mr. Krabs
5. Patchy the Pirate
6. Garfield
7. Dirk Dinkum (the "Go Away" guy from The Garfield Show)
8. Leonardo
9. Raphael
10. Michelangelo
11. Donatello
12. Jimmy Neutron
13. Hugh Neutron
14. Carl Wheezer
15. Aang
16. Ren & Stimpy
17. POWDERED, TOAST, MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN
18. Zim
19. Professor Membrane
20. Nigel Thornberry
21. CatDog
22. Otis
23. Po
24. Skipper
25. Albert, the Small Tree With Big Dreams

I recognize that this roster would appeal to exactly no one besides me, but hey, you did say "no stipulations"

 

[RileyXY1]

So basically what would the roster of NASB1 be like if we got to pick? This is nice.

1. SpongeBob
2. Patrick
3. Sandy
4. Leo
5. Mikey
6. Raph
7. Donnie
8. Aang
9. Toph
10. Korra
11. Lincoln
12. Lana
13. Arnold
14. Helga
15. Ren and Stimpy
16. Oblina
17. Danny Phantom
18. Nigel Thornberry
19. CatDog
20. Reptar
21. Rocko
22. Zim
23. Jimmy Neutron
24. Garfield
25. Jenny

 

[Guynamednelson]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

1. SpongeBob
2. Patrick
3. Sandy
4. Plankton
5. Leonardo
6. Michelangelo
7. Raphael
8. Donatello
9. Aang
10. Toph
11. Zuko
12. Stimpy
13. PTM
14. Reptar
15. Angelica
16. Daggett
17. Rocko
18. Oblina
19. Arnold/Gerald/Helga honestly they could probably pull a Hero with these three because Helga's NASB moveset was supposed to be focused on sports anyway and it's not like they're strangers to sports
20. CatDog
21. Nigel
22. Otto
23. Timmy
24. Jimmy
25. Danny Phantom

it's hard for me to hide that I'm part of the problem making the characters NASBcord wants less likely than Goku

but it was also hard for me to find a spot for a rep from a certain variety show in a 25 character roster so there's that too

 

[Master Hero Sock-on-Rye]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

25 characters and no rules? Count me in!

1. Spongebob Squarepants
2. Tommy Pickles (Rugrats / All Grown Up!)
3. Lincoln Loud
4. Aang
5. Michaelangelo (TMNT)
6. Jimmy Neutron
7. Stimpy
8. Timmy Turner
9. CatDog
10. Jenny Wakeman
11. Daggett Beaver
12. Arnold
13. Zim
14. The Flesh (KaBlam! / Action League Now!)
15. Otis
16. Miko (Glitch Techs)
17. Harvey Beaks
18. Rocko
19. Eliza Thornberry
20. Danny Phantom
21. Dora (2019 Movie)
22. Kappa Mikey
23. Danger Mouse
24. Daria
25. Son Goku

First off, no one franchise gets a second character, due to the amount of series to choose from. Not even Patrick Star is allowed entry.

Second, I picked Stimpy over Ren and Daggett over Norbert because they're the ones on more merch.

Third, I specifically chose the AGU! version of Tommy Pickles because, whatever form he takes, it's Nick's first animated mascot.

Fourth, only one Ninja Turtle was picked, and it's the one who acts most like a Nicktoon. You may send any complaints to 134 Get Dunk'd Lane.

Fifth, I tried to go for as much era variety as possible, which is why Eliza and Danny barely made it in.

Finally, the final five are what make it truly bizarre. Dora the Explorer, Kappa Mikey, Danger Mouse, Daria, and Goku. Actually, Daria aired on Teennick in 2010, Danger Mouse was one of Nick's first ever animated offerings, and DBZ Kai aired on Nicktoons Network.

I await your replies...

 

[fogbadge]

Well I’ll have a go

1. Garfield
2. Odie
3. Jon
4. Aang
5. Korra
6. Sokka
7. Zuko
8. Nigel
9. Eliza
10. Reptar
11. Tommy
12. Danny phantom
13. Jimmy
14. Timmy
15. Hugh
16. Norbert
17. Daggett
18. PTM
19. Helga
20. Zim
21. Jenny

And then round it off with the turtles

 

[Capybara Gaming]

Without cutting any shows, this would be my picks. If I had another 5, Sandy, Squidward, PTM, Lucy, and Gertie would be there.

1. SpongeBob
2. Patrick
3. Leonardo
4. Raphael
5. Donatello
6. Michelangelo
7. Aang
8. Toph
9. Zuko
10. Korra
11. Garfield
12. Danny Phantom
13. Lincoln Loud
14. Jimmy Neutron
15. Ren & Stimpy
16. Helga
17. Reptar
18. Oblina
19. El Tigre
20. Jenny
21. Nigel
22. Zim
23. Daggett
24. Rocko
25. CatDog

 

[PK-remling Fire]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Squidward
4. Sandy
5. Aang
6. Zuko
7. Toph
8. Azula
9. Jimmy Neutron
10. Timmy Turner
11. Danny Phantom
12. Vlad Plasmeus
13. Angelica Pickles
14. Reptar
15. Reggie Rocket
16. Zim
17. Dib
18. El Tigre
19. Jenny Wakeman
20. CatDog
21. Helga
22. Ren/Stimpy
23. Garfield
24. Oblina/Ickis/Krumm (as a trio)
25. Nigel Thornberry

I kinda leaned my roster to be more Nicktoons themed with fewer 3rd parties (Garfield as the exception because I genuinely like the idea of him among the cast). If there were more slots, I'd put in the Turtles and Splinter.

 

[Laniv]

I guess while we wait

Say you guys were tasked with your own take on a Nickelodeon platform fighter. 25 playable characters and no stipulations (basically as long as it aired on a Nickelodeon brand channel it’s fair game), what would your guys rosters look like?

This was... extremely difficult to narrow down.

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Sandy
4. Squidward
5. Plankton
6. Aang
7. Katara
8. Zuko
9. Korra
10. Jimmy Neutron
11. CatDog
12. Jenny Wakeman
13. Rocko
14. Zim
15. Oblina
16. Manny Rivera
17. Leonardo
18. Raphael
19. Donatello
20. Michelangelo
21. Oblina
22. Gerald Johansen
23. Henry and June (think Ice Climbers)
24. Nigel Thornberry
25. Garfield

I apologize if I forgot your fave

Also, I think it's funny how discussion on Manny has all but ceased because everyone and their brother knows he's a lock at this point

 

[Ze Diglett]

This was... extremely difficult to narrow down.

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Sandy
4. Squidward
5. Plankton
6. Aang
7. Katara
8. Zuko
9. Korra
10. Jimmy Neutron
11. CatDog
12. Jenny Wakeman
13. Rocko
14. Zim
15. Oblina
16. Manny Rivera
17. Leonardo
18. Raphael
19. Donatello
20. Michelangelo
21. Oblina
22. Gerald Johansen
23. Henry and June (think Ice Climbers)
24. Nigel Thornberry
25. Garfield

I apologize if I forgot your fave

Also, I think it's funny how discussion on Manny has all but ceased because everyone and their brother knows he's a lock at this point

Bold move to include Oblina twice

 

[ivanlerma]

I like that everyone here sort of universally agrees that TLA is infitely better than Korra.

sometimes i always wondered if ATLAB is more memorable than Korra.

Also, here's my list
1. Spongebob Squarepants
2. Patrick Star
3. Plankton
4. Leonardo
5. Micheallengelo
6. Donatello
7. Raphael
8. Timmy Turner
9. Jimmy Neutron
10. Danny Phantom
11.Vlad Plasmius
12. Aang
13. Katara
14. Toph
15 . Zuko
16. Korra
17. Ren & Stimpy
18. Lincoln Loud
19. Lucy Loud
20. Reptar
21. Rocko
22. Jenny
23. Tak
24. Sanjay & Craig
25.. Team Timbers

Sorry if it looks half-assed i have been busy all day and i am currently set to go to bed, i tried basing my roster off of most recognizable, popular, or well known alongside some different choices from each era near the end.

 

[Laniv]

Bold move to include Oblina twice

Ah. So she is.

Pretend one of those Oblinas is Reptar

 

[Zzuxon]

1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Sandy
4. Squidward
5. Aang
6. Korra
7. Toph
8. Zuko
9. Leonardo (2012)
10. Michelangelo (2012)
11. Donatello (Rise)
12. Rapahel (Rise)
13. Lucy Loud
14. Reptar
15. Ren and Stimpy
16. Timmy Turner
17. Jimmy
18. Danny
19. Zim
20. Helga
21. Jenny
22. Catdog
23. Otis (Or Skipper, if he's an option)
24. Dora
25. Steve and Blue

And because such a restrictive roster was painful, here are the honorable mentions season pass characters! Huzzah.

26. Rocko
27. El Tigre
28. Nigel
29. Miko
30. iCarly Character

 

[Michael the Spikester]

I'm really sad at the mostly lacking of the beavers barring a few of these rosters.

Angry Beavers deserve more love.

 

[Ze Diglett]

I'm really sad at the mostly lacking of the beavers barring a few of these rosters.

Angry Beavers deserve more love.

Sorry, but 2000's kid DNA don't lie. GIVE ME THREE JIMMY NEUTRON CHARACTERS OR GIVE ME DEATH.

 

[Guynamednelson]

Sorry, but 2000's kid DNA don't lie. GIVE ME THREE JIMMY NEUTRON CHARACTERS OR GIVE ME DEATH.

When you were born just in time to grow up on both Aaahh!!! Real Monsters and Jimmy Neutron

 

[LimeTH]

When you were born just in time to grow up on both Aaahh!!! Real Monsters and Jimmy Neutron
View attachment 376751

We are few but proud.

 

[fogbadge]

Sorry, but 2000's kid DNA don't lie. GIVE ME THREE JIMMY NEUTRON CHARACTERS OR GIVE ME DEATH.

be glad you missed the 90s

 

[Mamboo07]

No updates for NASB2 this week... so I'll share something :) #nasb2 pic.twitter.com/GAeHfIBvr2

— Diego - NASB2 Art Director (@diegotzee) August 26, 2023

Nick All Star Brawl 2 logo concepts

 

[Master Hero Sock-on-Rye]

No updates for NASB2 this week... so I'll share something :) #nasb2 pic.twitter.com/GAeHfIBvr2

— Diego - NASB2 Art Director (@diegotzee) August 26, 2023

Nick All Star Brawl 2 logo concepts

I actually think the final logo is the best one of the lot. Maybe they can repurpose the jagged 2 for the third game.

 

[SuperSmashFan99]

I'm a bit late, but here is my 25-character roster:
1. Spongebob
2. Patrick
3. Reptar
4. Timmy Turner
5. Lincoln Loud
6. Lucy Loud
7. Michelangelo
8. Helga
9. Ren & Stimpy
10. Rocko
11. Oblina
12. Daggett
13. CatDog
13. Nigel
14. Zim
15. Jimmy Neutron
16. Jenny
17. Danny Phantom
18. Aang
19. El Tigre
20. Otis
21. Skipper
22. Fanboy & Chum Chum
23. Korra
24. Miko
25. Dora

Honorable Mentions: Parker (2020s rep and personal bias), Kappa Mikey (Represents the Nicktoons channel), Count Duckula (80s rep and technically the first Nicktoon)

 

[CapitaineCrash]

There's apparently a character reveal soon too.

I'm not 100% sure, but there's gonna be a character reveal soon :)

— Diego - NASB2 Art Director (@diegotzee) August 26, 2023

Spoiler: Leak

My guess is El Tigre. Wonder if some unseen veterans will be shown too.

 

[ivanlerma]

There's apparently a character reveal soon too.

I'm not 100% sure, but there's gonna be a character reveal soon :)

— Diego - NASB2 Art Director (@diegotzee) August 26, 2023

Spoiler: Leak

My guess is El Tigre. Wonder if some unseen veterans will be shown too.

Hmmm strokes chin

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Based NASB 2 playtesters.

In the case of the prior, he does like Ultimate as a whole though, and this comment predates NASB 2's reveal so he isn't talking about NASB, to give context. Moreso just saying this game's in the right hands - if they rework Aang to be faithful to his source, someone's keeping him in check so he won't be Sonic all over again. In the case of the latter, that means nothing for NASB at all, we all know this series is never getting a huge roster and this sort of thing is probably something a playtester has much less influence over than balancing but it's still very based and, again, shows me that NASB 2 is in the right hands. HDR is an Ultimate mod.

 

[Mr Hairyman]

There's apparently a character reveal soon too.

I'm not 100% sure, but there's gonna be a character reveal soon :)

— Diego - NASB2 Art Director (@diegotzee) August 26, 2023

Spoiler: Leak

My guess is El Tigre. Wonder if some unseen veterans will be shown too.

Spoiler: Leak

Whenever El Tigre is revealed, I hope some hero and villain veterans show up like Powdered Toastman or Shredder.