- Joined
- Aug 13, 2001
- Messages
- 34,385
- Location
- Cull Hazard
- NNID
- Irene4
- 3DS FC
- 1203-9265-8784
- Switch FC
- SW-7567-8572-3791
They aren't unrealistic, but we don't know if they were the actual RH character Sakurai worked on. We only got one leaker to imply it's that one, and now that we know Chrom was given a lot of attention before Robin, it's pretty likely it was the case. Just not confirmed the case.Is Chorus Kids still considered a realistic possibility? Were they really in development in Smash U? How far did they get?
If they were partially completed last time and dropped due to 3DS limitations, it does make sense for Sakurai to finish them rather than cut the concept entirely.
You do know that Sakurai also said that he'll put Takamaru in when he gets a new game, right? That's an important note, because he never got one. Besides that, he could've just been lower priority to begin with. His "retro" choice could be someone else. He's not 3rd party, so we don't know why he's still an AT.Geno is requested a lot here, but he isn't a popular character in the context of literally anything else and it's why he's such a terrible pick. People don't care about Geno, they only care about the idea of him being in Smash and having Mario RPG representation. So what if Sakurai said he wanted him playable since Brawl? This is meaningless. Stop pretending as if Geno is the only character he wants. He also wanted Takamaru and yet he's still an Assist Trophy character.
Geno fans are actually insane if they think their one-off character from a two-decade-old Mario spin-off that's co-owned by Square Enix is going to take any priority over characters from currently relevant IPs, new games that came out, or Nintendo classical IPs that helped build whatever system they came out on.
What's the attraction behind Geno really? What could he do that no other character could do? He doesn't even look anything unique if you prop him up against the rest of the roster.
King K. Rool himself is not even relevant. His franchise is active, but he is not. Geno isn't either, but yes, the fact Sakurai wants him does matter. The reason Geno got a costume is that Sakurai tried to get him playable in 4 but that's the best he was able to do(Cloud being higher priority at that time makes sense, of course). K. Rool, frankly, is not in competition with Geno and never was. Geno is a severely popular character that Sakurai wants playable. He has been trying to do since Brawl. He has not said anything similar about K. Rool and at best the character's Mii costume is just a nod to the popularity of the ballot. Sakurai might not know of his far bigger popularity outside of it. Geno's popularity before the ballot is why Sakurai wants him playable to begin with. It's big. And what's with this "fans only care about this" stuff? Geno is popular because of his own merits, not "lol we need Super Mario RPG representation". Some might think that, of course, but his popularity came from his own, you know, personality and role. Besides being actually pretty cool within the game. Despite Mallow being more important to the story, he's the breakout character from it.
Lastly, K. Rool is not less relevant than Geno. If you want to talk about relevant DKC characters, look at Dixie Kong. K. Rool is long and forgotten, and while still obviously an awesome and popular character, is literally in the same boat as Geno, just with the creator only wanting one playable and has been trying to do so. When has Sakurai tried to make K. Rool playable, or care enough to do so? We don't know. In fact, he might have never tried. That means Geno was higher priority anyway. Higher priority isn't about finished product alone. If negotiations didn't fall through, he'd have been playable in Brawl. K. Rool? Who knows. He hasn't released any statements on the croc being possibly playable. 4? They both got Mii costumes, but Sakurai gave Geno a Mii costume because he was still trying to make him playable. He needed to license it first, of course, which means he gave priority to Geno too. We didn't even get a FFVII-related costume either, just a Chocobo Hat based upon a spin-off FF game that's not really related to 7, and Geno, from SMRPG. That means he went out of his way for that obscure character. Because he wanted him playable, and the costume was as close as he could get at that time. You're saying K. Rool somehow is in the same position here? Back this up, because there's seriously no reason to believe this is applicable to the croc. He's in a similar position to Geno, but also is on a lower scale right now due to any knowledge Sakurai is interested in him being playable. Until we know of that, Geno has a natural leg up.