Let's play a game. The "Arms Fighters can share a moveset" game.
Your most wanted gets in BUT
- They share the slot with 3 other characters from their game (NOT series)
- Your favorite character is not top billed, and whenever the moveset has to be compromised to work they always end up worse off than the others.
- They must use the same moves
- If one of them can't feasibly pull off a move then it's not allowed in their moveset,
- They only have different voice lines and victory animations; their idle animations are slightly tweaked at best
- None of them can have any gameplay elements that the others don't have
- Additionally, because there's already 4 models in one slot, none of the characters can have alternate palettes that include model changes. Strictly recolours only.
With these in mind;
- How much does your most wanted lose in the process?
- What do you pick for their -ONE- alternate palette?
- Are you happy that they're in even if it means this is the best they'll ever get (ie they'll never be split off into clones, they might miss out on amiibo, etc)
My most wanted loses the potential for the
best alt
costumes in the game but I guess they get to share with their game's 15th (out of 18)
most forgettable party member and the
avatar in both male and female versions? There aren't any other dual gun/dual sword users so they have to double up the avatars who can use any weapon type. Ghost Factory and Shadowstrike are lost but they have equivalents in Ghost Walker and Back Slash, and Sliding Slinger gets to live as well. Alternate palette is the
Ultra Regal version of her default since it's the closest to what her alternate costume would be.
It's a good day to be a fan of Arle-- wait. Well, I have a good idea of the one palette, it'd be Doppelganger Arle.
Define game. She's in several other games that feature the characters I'm thinking of.
Like, Amitie/Ringo/Ally is already a somewhat popular idea, and if Amitie's the lead character the abilities are close enough that it'd be more or less fine. But if we're going by debut, she has... got it way worse. Uh... Satan, Schezo, and... uh... um... well... er... eh... hm... Draco? And basically everything that makes her unique would be gone, replaced by somebody who not only isn't the protagonist but also has no business being the focus over Arle, and it doesn't get anywhere near working out because of proportions, the wings of Satan/Draco, the sword of Schezo and whatnot. Plus, because we switched from Puyo Puyo to Madou Monogatari (2: Episode Carbuncle), Arle would not only not have her Puyo Puyo design but not even feature anything from Puyo Puyo. And while I think it'd be beyond insane that Arle wasn't even the star even though people have been asking for her for years (especially in Japan), and she basically got an even bigger middle finger than Sonic, I think this is a case where beggars shouldn't be choosers.
...except me. I'd probably be really upset that Arle got ****ed over. Beggars can't be choosers, but I defy that logic and am a choosing beggar and I recognize missed potential and shoehorned nonsense for what it's worth.
I don't really think we're gonna get more than one ARMS character as our upcoming Fighter, anyway. I don't think it's IMPOSSIBLE, but I quite heavily doubt it because it'd either be giving powers to people who shouldn't have it, or take away what makes them
them in favor of shoehorning in extra characters. And this thought experiment is pretty evocative of that. If these "compromises to fit more characters in because, well, they have the same gimmick so it's fine right?" don't fly for your most wanted's series, how could it for ARMS?
And just to be on the safe side, with Crash I can't even think of a fourth character who could fit. Fake Crash, Coco, and... we get stuck. With Lloyd, the same issue happens, where he always has one sword put away and fights like Kratos or Zelos. And Frisk only has one character they could work with, Chara. Paper Mario might outright have 0 characters: Luigi is the closest thing, and he doesn't use hammers or partners. Peach and Bowser would be atrocities in a Paper Mario moveset.