New Characters for Project M Discussion Thread (Voting Closed)

[QQQQQQQ7777777]

Pretty much this. And it was a Nintendo exclusive game at that. In fact, any cameo he has made was only within the realm of Nintendo Sonic games.

Sonic X......

 

[Solbliminal]

Sonic X......

Do we count the Legend of Zelda and Mario cartoons against those series?

 

[QQQQQQQ7777777]

Do we count the Legend of Zelda and Mario cartoons against those series?

we should, but I was really aiming that towards the "only seen in Nintendo exclusives" thing.

 

[Saito]

Sonic X......

That did Emerl no justice.

The fact that CREAM beat him, when in the game he could decimate shadow pretty easily?

BULL****

 

[QQQQQQQ7777777]

That did Emerl no justice.

The fact that CREAM beat him, when in the game he could decimate shadow pretty easily?

BULL****

Chao OP bro

 

[Saito]

Chao OP bro

I've got an all S rank Chao on Sonic adventure 2 battle.

Level 99 in everything but stamina.
Level 50 or so in stamina.

Force feeding chao is hard.

I have run city escape so many times to afford Chao fruit it's ridiculous.

 

[QQQQQQQ7777777]

I've got an all S rank Chao on Sonic adventure 2 battle.

Level 99 in everything but stamina.
Level 50 or so in stamina.

Force feeding chao is hard.

I have run city escape so many times to afford Chao fruit it's ridiculous.

Why does he keep going back into the city he is trying to escape from?

 

[Solbliminal]

we should, but I was really aiming that towards the "only seen in Nintendo exclusives" thing.

It is a cartoon. I'm speaking of game appearances. It should be self explanatory.

Edit: After a bit of thinking, I remembered All-stars Racing Transformed and Sonic Rivals 2 both have an Emerl collectable of some sort. So his appearance isn't Nintendo limited like I initially thought. My bad.

 

[Saito]

So I read over the last two pages.....

 

[Anti Guy]

So I read over the last two pages.....

Yeah, I don't even recognize this thread anymore

 

[Solbliminal]

Getting off topic is pretty easy to do when you've pretty much discussed all the interesting characters on the list. All the remaining characters are usually ones that are:

A) Unfeasible
B) Disliked
C) Not on the list
D) Likely for Smash 4
E) Sonic tier and below

 

[QQQQQQQ7777777]

Getting off topic is pretty easy to do when you've pretty much discussed all the interesting characters on the list. All the remaining characters are usually ones that are:

A) Unfeasible
B) Disliked
C) Not on the list
D) Likely for Smash 4
E) Sonic tier and below

We still have some great options to choose from like............... um.......... Sandbag..........

 

[Solbliminal]

We still have some great options to choose from like............... um.......... Sandbag..........

We discussed that already.

 

[Anti Guy]

Getting off topic is pretty easy to do when you've pretty much discussed all the interesting characters on the list. All the remaining characters are usually ones that are:

A) Unfeasible
B) Disliked
C) Not on the list
D) Likely for Smash 4
E) Sonic tier and below

Yeah, no kidding. Well at least since the last tally (168 votes), we've gotten 40 more (206 now), so if the stagnation continues, I'll release the next tally sometime soon.

 

[Solbliminal]

Yeah, no kidding. Well at least since the last tally (168 votes), we've gotten 40 more (206 now), so if the stagnation continues, I'll release the next tally sometime soon.

Speaking of updates, do you think you can add Ray MK III to the op? He has gotten a noticeable amount of votes, so I think he is at least worth mentioning.

 

[Xaranid]

Random question. So is it confirmed that Brawl Ex does NOT work with Project M? In a perfect world I could have the gameplay and balance of PM while throwing in a few other character PSAs for fun, even if they're not balanced for PM. (Geno, Ridley, Wisp, Waluigi...)

 

[GunBlaze]

Random question. So is it confirmed that Brawl Ex does NOT work with Project M? In a perfect world I could have the gameplay and balance of PM while throwing in a few other character PSAs for fun, even if they're not balanced for PM. (Geno, Ridley, Wisp, Waluigi...)

It is still being worked upon IIRC

 

[Jade_Rock55]

We still have some great options to choose from like............... um.......... Sandbag..........

Sandbag for top tier! Wait deos that mean we would have sandbag hit sandbag in HRC?

 

[Shin F.]

Speaking of updates, do you think you can add Ray MK III to the op? He has gotten a noticeable amount of votes, so I think he is at least worth mentioning.

I think he's only including people with at least 10 votes.

 

[Solbliminal]

Sandbag for top tier! Wait deos that mean we would have sandbag hit sandbag in HRC?

No. Sandbag in HRC gets replaced with a series of self-damaging items if you play as him to see how far he can launch himself.

 

[Anti Guy]

I think he's only including people with at least 10 votes.

He actually just made the cut, but he's one of those characters whose results you should take with a grain of salt because he hasn't been on the OP.

 

[Solbliminal]

He actually just made the cut, but he's one of those characters whose results you should take with a grain of salt because he hasn't been on the OP.

Which is why I suggested him to be on the OP. His discussion keeps getting overlapped with Pichu, Sonic, and off-topic discussions. He gained a handfull of half-votes more recently from the regulars here since they used their full votes. Most users stopping by have been voting on what is in the OP. It wouldn't hurt to throw him up because he is one of the last supported characters who is an "Issac" case who isn't likely for Smash 4. I just feel that the character was overlooked.

 

[QQQQQQQ7777777]

Which is why I suggested him to be on the OP. His discussion keeps getting overlapped with Pichu, Sonic, and off-topic discussions. He gained a handfull of votes more recently from the regulars here since they used their full votes. Most users stopping by have been voting on what is in the OP. It wouldn't hurt to throw him up because he is one of the last supported characters who is an "Issac" case who isn't likely for Smash 4.

did someone say off-topic discussions?

 

[Anti Guy]

Which is why I suggested him to be on the OP. His discussion keeps getting overlapped with Pichu, Sonic, and off-topic discussions. He gained a handfull of half-votes more recently from the regulars here since they used their full votes. Most users stopping by have been voting on what is in the OP. It wouldn't hurt to throw him up because he is one of the last supported characters who is an "Issac" case who isn't likely for Smash 4. I just feel that the character was overlooked.

He'll be added to the OP

 

[Solbliminal]

He'll be added to the OP

Thank you. I'll get working on some moveset ideas that can be discussed.

Also, a thought occurred to me that hasn't been considered for him. Mega Man's playstyle is very projectile and weapon heavy to the same extent as Ray. I imagine Ray to play in a similar fashion, though with his own traits obviously. This would be a good place to start the discussion on the character.

 

[Banjodorf]

So...I remember this Sandbag moveset I saw where he moved by rolling around on a red shell and swinging a bat at people, complete with other items for specials etc.

It seemed like a fun idea to me. Have we did used it before?

 

[andalsoandy]

So...I remember this Sandbag moveset I saw where he moved by rolling around on a red shell and swinging a bat at people, complete with other items for specials etc.

It seemed like a fun idea to me. Have we did used it before?

Riding around on a red shell as SANDBAG just sounds like so much fun right there. The shell would probably have to do damage though and that seems OP if it was just his running animation.

It should be his Side-B, and it could act just like Yoshi's side-B.

 

[Banjodorf]

Riding around on a red shell as SANDBAG just sounds like so much fun right there. The shell would probably have to do damage though and that seems OP if it was just his running animation.

It should be his Side-B, and it could act just like Yoshi's side-B.

I don't think it would have to do damage. At least not from just the running animation. It could obviously be used in a few attacks, and his dash attack could then be a sped up running version that does damage, but I don't think it needs to do damage inherently. That just unnecessarily complicates it.

 

[andalsoandy]

I don't think it would have to do damage. At least not from just the running animation. It could obviously be used in a few attacks, and his dash attack could then be a sped up running version that does damage, but I don't think it needs to do damage inherently. That just unnecessarily complicates it.

I dunno. If it were his running animation I think it'd be weird to see Sandbag run into someone riding on a shell and not hurt them.

Then again, how else is he gonna run...

 

[UltimateWario]

+1 Ridley
"Ridley should've been in Smash since Melee" is practically my catchphrase at this point. He deserves to be in Smash more than literally anyone else on that list, because he is a huge character in a massively underrepped franchise, and would also give us an aerial heavy character, which we have none of. The only problem is his possible playability within SSB4 (hope to God).

+1 Skull Kid
Tons of potential, a popular character, and confirmed to not be playable in SSB4. A unique moveset is almost assured, which is always fun.

+1 Isaac
Pretty much the same points as Skull Kid, but from a popular, unrepped franchise. He could be in SSB4, but I'm not counting on it.

+1/2 Dark Samus
I'm curious about what you good folks can do with a Samus clone. Although Ridley is obviously the priority, I would be all over a super-fast, lighter Samus.

-1 Krystal
StarFox is at the perfect size for the size of the franchise, and I really don't see anything that Krystal could bring, beyond using a staff, to the series.

-1 Pichu
We already have EIGHT playable Pokemon. We don't need another one, especially a clone, and a completely uninteresting one at that.

 

[NWRL]

+1 Ridley

Metroid series needs reps and Dark Samus wouldn't add enough variety imo. Ridley would be awesome

+1 Waluigi
That PSA is perfect, the PMBR should just use that and add him in.

+1 Skull Kid
Majora's Mask could use some reps in Smash, it was a great game after all.

+1 Black Shadow/Ganondorf
I don't really care about playing Ganon but another F-Zero rep would be amazing.

-1 Pichu
Way too many reps for Pokemon and it wouldn't be that much different from Pikachu.

 

[andalsoandy]

-1 Pichu
We already have EIGHT playable Pokemon. We don't need another one, especially a clone, and a completely uninteresting one at that.

-1 Pichu
Way too many reps for Pokemon and it wouldn't be that much different from Pikachu.

 

[UltimateWario]

Let's just call it Project P and replace all the characters with Pokemon

 

[andalsoandy]

Let's just call it Project P and replace all the characters with Pokemon

http://forums.kc-mm.com/index.php?topic=47219.msg965339#msg965339

 

[UltimateWario]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/index.php?topic=47219.msg965339#msg965339

Hooooooly ****.

 

[Shin F.]

Lmao. I'm not even sure if Bloo is supposed to be Pichu's super vocal supporters (Lookin' at TopTierPichu, here) or his down-voters, but it was a hilarious clip either way!

Incidentally, for those saying Pichu wouldn't be unique - try to look in the thread for OrangeSodaGuy's idea of the Discharge mechanic they could give him. It's very, very interesting and would definitely make Pichu a worthy character.

 

[andalsoandy]

Lmao. I'm not even sure if Bloo is supposed to be Pichu's super vocal supporters (Lookin' at TopTierPichu, here) or his down-voters, but it was a hilarious clip either way!

Incidentally, for those saying Pichu wouldn't be unique - try to look in the thread for OrangeSodaGuy's idea of the Discharge mechanic they could give him. It's very, very interesting and would definitely make Pichu a worthy character.

I thought of Bloo as the supporter.

Then again, it makes us Pichu supporters look whiny.

 

[Anti Guy]

Then again, it makes us Pichu supporters look whiny.

I don't see what's wrong with that.

 

[Shin F.]

I thought of Bloo as the supporter.

Then again, it makes us Pichu supporters look whiny.

Most of you aren't that bad. You and Chzrm3 are very reasonable about wanting him, for instance. It's just the super vocal ones who bring him up at every turn that are kind of annoying.

 

[andalsoandy]

Most of you aren't that bad. You and Chzrm3 are very reasonable about wanting him, for instance. It's just the super vocal ones who bring him up at every turn that are kind of annoying.

It's kinda hard to call them out when they want the same character you do.

lol

Thanks though.