Actually, what am I waiting for? I'm going to be LA for a few days, so let me get something out.
Listen while you read.
I believe Vinyl is scum.
Here's why:
Here’s the post where I initially started questioning Vinyl.
Start at this post and read along until I say stop, it’ll help the case make more sense.
Here, I called him out on what I thought seemed to be a low level of activity and jumping on a weak link.
Let me start with the point about the weakest link. I thought it was pretty suspicious that Vinyl decided to start pressuring Toaster (who was already under hardcore pressure from Soup), but I became even more suspicious when he asked questions like this:
Vinyl said:
Toaster, are you town?
Really now? So you're saying that you're scum?
infact, you don't want to answer the question at all, because you think it's a trick question and proves nothing.
People, do you agree with what's he saying?
I didn’t see any point to these questions aside from making Toaster look even more scummy. The last point is interesting: it’s basically fishing for our attention. Vinyl has jumped onto a weaker player and prodded him to look even more scummy, then fished for our opinions. Again, aside from a case on soup before this, his activity had been relatively low.
Now let’s keep going. You’ll notice
here that Vinyl claims that he has confirmed Toaster for town for Day 1. His reasoning is that Toaster said so… (don’t get me started on how he figured this, but notice who comments on this:
Joker)
Now he makes a quad post, after I just commented on his activity. Isn’t he seeming a little jumpy? Maybe it’s just me.
Next, he says
this…I don’t really know what to make of it, but it doesn’t help his case in my eyes at least.
His next post is trying to change the subject again. He begins trying to start a wagon on Loli, taking attention away from Toaster.
Now just look. Again, I think he’s pretty jumpy all of a sudden.
Badwolf comments on his jumpiness too
You can stop reading along here and jump to
this. Nothing of interest really happens in the gap, as far as this case goes.
So that post I just pointed you to. He’s willing to miss walls? That’s not good. You can miss important info.
Next, jump to
this
Let me quote this since it’s important:
Vinyl said:
The scum night kills whoever. But I probably expect that they kill townies that are gaining a lot of suspicion towards the scum player.
Remember this.
(
Look Here.)
Jumpy and rushing us a bit, don’t you think? Notice how his next vote is on the other weakest player (or at least, weakest from my little lynch wagon).
Again, Badwolf acknowledges Vinyl’s relatively low scum hunting (
here) and (
here)
Ori_Bro has just joined the game, and thinks Vinyl is scum (
saying this) and (
and this).
(
Next, look here.)
I’m thinking all of that jumping around was a back door in case we started looking into this.
Once again, here,
Vinyl claims Toaster is Town.
Take a good look at what he says at the bottom of that list.
Vinyl said:
Toaster lynch wagon is something I wouldn't consider doing, I'd actually rather check on him toMorrow and lynch anyone else but him. If he cant't stay Til' tomorrow and get's lynched, ton will be my scum choice.
So Vinyl doesn’t want Toaster lynched…but who hammers Toaster? Also, if he didn’t want the lynch wagon, why did he pressure toaster and fish for our votes right after? Notice who his next vote choice is: the other vulnerable player from my lynch wagon.
And then
this incident.
Read every post between Joker and Vinyl until you get to what I've quoted below.
Now look at what Joker says
Joker said:
Vinyl, in one fell swoop you have gone from being my strongest Town read to being very questionable. That was not a smart play. I can't think of any logical reason for why you'd say something like that if you were a townie.
Hey, you guys remember this?
Vinyl said:
The scum night kills whoever. But I probably expect that they kill townies that are gaining a lot of suspicion towards the scum player.
Who died night 1? Who had made the most reads so far into the game up until that point? Who had just started to suspect Vinyl? Detectives can't believe in coincidence (TDKR quote lol)
Alright, let’s keep going.
Look Here
Once again, he says he doesn’t want toaster dead. Also, Sold2 calls him out on his lack of reads. You would expect him to have more at this point wouldn’t you?
Ok, one last point.
Look here
I accidentally Hammer toaster. Look at Vinyl’s response. He has a “blank face”. I’m going to guess he didn’t want him dead, and you would too right? He’s said it a million times.
So….why does
this happen then?
He hammers Toaster after claiming he’s positive he’s town at least 3 times, and leaves a blatant back door open. And notice that his next choice for vote is, once again, someone who made a mistake on my lynch wagon.
Vote Vinyl
