Melee-related Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, and Magic: The Gathering Cards

[Marth307]

Lol everyones all serious about smash Mtg lmao i just made the cards to what i thought the caharcter was in there universe like ness is smart/psychis so i made him blue kirby i couldngt really pick a color so i made him colorless but if i HAD to make him a color it would be green

@ strong bad green is my 2nd favorite color to play as so if im helping make this im not making all the bad cards green

 

[Wenbobular]

I think there's a little more thought than that when it comes to Magic flavor and mechanics haha

 

[Pogogo]

Shield poke could also give the creature trample. Just saying

 

[Marth307]

hmmmmmm ^^ maybe not shield poke but dashdance?

 

[Divinokage]

Dashdance would be like an instant +0/+2 or something lol.

 

[unknown522]

Kirbykaze: I was just using colours based off which colour the players pick.

 

[4 Aces]

I think there's a little more thought than that when it comes to Magic flavor and mechanics haha

^this 10char

 

[Marth307]

Ok well lets get a group of smashers together to collaberate on these MTG cards

 

[Kuro Neko]

Haha I like the Isai one.

 

[Laudandus]

Lmao. Marth307's cards look way imba compared to what KK was making.

I'm not sure about that. GG for a 3/3 haste vigilance first strike is really good. The only ones Marth307 made that are comparably good are Isai's sheik, puff and pichu if they were at common for limited, and 3's roy (that thing is really, really overpowered). Most of the other cards are a lot worse than your fox.

And designing a smash set to draft is the best idea.

 

[Roneblaster]

marth307 just....holy ****. good work man.

woah, i had only seen until the 2nd page when i posted that. ^

i used to play magic as a young lad, was never any good. i forgot the rules too.


scar needs a card. something that ***** them but hurts you too. (**** combos and SD's alot)

 

[Cactuar]

Lol. I'm all about that efficiency (cheap card cost).

 

[Strong Badam]

How about:

Aggression/recklessness is Red, analytical styles are blue, defensive styles are White, ???? is Black, and intuitive/natural styles are Green.

I'm not opposed to "controlling space" for black, but what's the idea behind it?

sorin/creeping tar pit/lilliana/mind sludge/duress etc. outside of Vampires most of Black is based on control.

mew2king's marth is perfect for Black, haha.

 

[Winston]

sorin/creeping tar pit/lilliana/mind sludge/duress etc.

completely random haha

but sure, I can buy it, maybe.

I hope Hbox doesn't take it the wrong way when we make him a Black card

The best thing to do is probably just ignore flavor rules for some people. Like give Darkrain black and Cactuar green etc.

mew2king's marth is perfect for Black, haha.

From a flavor point of view I think his primary color should be Blue

 

[Marth307]

Lol i made m2ks marth blue XP i think what im going to do is make player characters (mrk etc) legendary and just the normal characters (fox,kirby,etc) basic creatures Smash attacks will be sorcery Wavedashing Powershielding and stuff of that nature will be instants Stages will be lands with the exceptions of the basic land ive already provided and enchantments will be things like taunts tournement pressure... we need to converge in the us somewhere and draft this ****!!!!Does anyone want to help me make the smash set?I plan o a goal of 100-120 cards,only help if you plan on making cards similar to the normal set(not OP) Im going to revise the ones Ive already made
and when im done ill post a thread in melee disscusion with my revisons

 

[4 Aces]

I'm not sure about that. GG for a 3/3 haste vigilance first strike is really good. The only ones Marth307 made that are comparably good are Isai's sheik, puff and pichu if they were at common for limited, and 3's roy (that thing is really, really overpowered). Most of the other cards are a lot worse than your fox.

And designing a smash set to draft is the best idea.

See, my issue is that most posted are imbalanced as in, towards near unplayable. A lot of them have stupid high casting costs and as if that wasn't enough it costs about just as much to activate the abilities. Turn 7 to play a card is waaaayyy higher than it ought to be.

 

[Divinokage]

Lol i made m2ks marth blue XP i think what im going to do is make player characters (mrk etc) legendary and just the normal characters (fox,kirby,etc) basic creatures Smash attacks will be sorcery Wavedashing Powershielding and stuff of that nature will be instants Stages will be lands with the exceptions of the basic land ive already provided and enchantments will be things like taunts tournement pressure... we need to converge in the us somewhere and draft this ****!!!!Does anyone want to help me make the smash set?I plan o a goal of 100-120 cards,only help if you plan on making cards similar to the normal set(not OP) Im going to revise the ones Ive already made
and when im done ill post a thread in melee disscusion with my revisons

Ya but even legendary creatures in Magic aren't that OP anyway since it's pretty hard to put them out in the first place unless you have help with spells and stuff. Like creatures with 8 or more mana cost usually have a major drawback to them.. Idk like Leviathan lol. Phyraxian Dreadnaught is insane too lol.

 

[Strong Badam]

See, my issue is that most posted are imbalanced as in, towards near unplayable. A lot of them have stupid high casting costs and as if that wasn't enough it costs about just as much to activate the abilities. Turn 7 to play a card is waaaayyy higher than it ought to be.

Not in Limited. Lol.

 

[Megachuk]

sweet! so all i need to do is cast lightning bolt on cactus and I win... hellz yeah 2 easy

 

[Stevo]

that's what you think

 

[Marth307]

Ya but even legendary creatures in Magic aren't that OP anyway since it's pretty hard to put them out in the first place unless you have help with spells and stuff. Like creatures with 8 or more mana cost usually have a major drawback to them.. Idk like Leviathan lol. Phyraxian Dreadnaught is insane too lol.

I know legendaries arnt op but some are really good i said revison what i meant was change costs abilities etc...So care to help me with these revisions?

 

[Stevo]

the best cards are those ones like

Quaglicker Slug UBRW4

swampwalk

Legendary - Quaglicker Slug

3/3

 

[N.A.G.A.C.E]

a couple years back at school a friend of mine had magic cards so we all started playing. eventually we got a program for the computer were we could make decks with any card (with a few rules). anyway i made a sliver deck and those things are for real, to good

 

[Marth307]

I ****ing hate slivers

 

[N.A.G.A.C.E]

how/why do u hate slivers? do u hate them b/c u had to face someone with a sliver deck or do u just not like the concept? I just dont see how u cant love them they are so ****ing good

 

[Bones0]

lol finally updated this shiz. Marth307 doin' mad work! X_X

 

[CableCho57]

oh man I died when I saw that roy yugioh card hahaha

 

[KirbyKaze]

Unless you're doing some kind of long combo, Slivers are kind of bleh to play because it's easy to be tempted into overextending.

 

[Marth307]

I got 8th out of 16th place at FNM with a deck i made with 24 dollars xD red/white FTW
i just hate slivers because there ****ing gay as hell just like the cards with infect

 

[KirbyKaze]

I remember RWB Slivers being fun when Time Spiral / Ravnica was T2.

 

[Marth307]

ravinca is the best magic block ever!!!!!!!!!!

 

[KirbyKaze]

Ravnica was really fun.

Bob was really good. And made a lot of aggressive decks possible.

 

[Marth307]

Lol what Guild(s) did you play throughout the block?
I did boros and rakdos X)
-Edit-
Revised roy

Spoiler

Is this better or worse for a revison? I based Roy on hellkite igniter

 

[KirbyKaze]

I didn't really play block. I mostly just helped my friend playtest. That meant me playing stuff like BW Aggro-Control variants for a while against whatever control deck was winning at the time. Fifty games of WB Aggro-Control vs. Ghazi-Glare gets really boring. Then you get fifty more games of WB Aggro-Control vs. Izzettron or whatever UR had at the moment. And so forth and so on.

Eventually he wound up playing Heartbeat Combo.

I think the deck I played most was probably BW Aggro-Control. At some point I got a kick out of Zoo (WRG aggro) but I didn't like being without Dark Confidant. If you could somehow get Dark Confidant to stick then a lot of matches became easy.

 

[Marth307]

Have you played any new Mirrodin?

 

[KirbyKaze]

Sadly, no. I haven't played MtG seriously in years. Much less the new stuff.

Infect looks really gay, though. I hope they don't make it a tier 1 deck type.

 

[Marth307]

I dont play infect i play warcall i have an angel/dragon deck X)
Infect is hard to beat unless you play hardcore burn deck

 

[Winston]

Lol what Guild(s) did you play throughout the block?
I did boros and rakdos X)
-Edit-
Revised roy

Spoiler

Is this better or worse for a revison? I based Roy on hellkite igniter

It's not better or worse really. You're moving sideways ><

Okay, look at your card, now look at this:

Spoiler

In short, yes.

Longer: it's mostly to do with his idiosyncrasies regarding how he approaches combos. He's said (numerous times) his favourite kinds of combos are the ones where the opponent is not completely locked in stun or limited to tech options. He likes it when the opponent is given the impression of having options but they get hit anyway.

I'd find the post(s) but I'm far too lazy to dredge through everything.

Untapping their creature during the combat step always gives them at least 1 option. Which I felt captured this (very unique) aspect of his play.

I don't think Cactuar's Fox is perfect or anything, but there's a clear effort to make the card's mechanics convey the idea of how Cactuar's Fox plays in actual smash.

Your new Roy is "based off Hellkite Igniter", which is some dragon with a jetpack. It should be based off Roy.

 

[KirbyKaze]

A creature based off Roy would be so depressing.

It would be something that hits a lot yet does no damage and dies easily.

 

[Winston]

Attempts to make a non-useless Roy (in limited):

1R

2RR, tap: the next time a creature would deal combat damage to Roy this turn, prevent that damage. Roy deals that amount of damage to that creature.

1/1

Or:

1RR

First Strike

0: Roy gets +3/+0 and loses First Strike until end of turn. Activate this ability only once each turn, before blockers are declared.

1/1

That one might be a little awkward, idk

or something involving him tapping to build up charge counters and then dealing that much damage to something. (Roy's neutral B)