Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
and lynching an active member just because you need a lynch isn't intelligent. Sure eventually you need a lynch but you need a day 1 to play out more. Theres not going to be a slip up by a mafia member, but you might realize something later on that happened, or notice a change in play style or an alliance formed that might connect to day one ramblings. As such I say don't just vote for the most obvious choice and get a quick lynch. That's my reasoning for not voting on him yet and instead checking other people out.
This simply isn't true, you're assuming way too much. There are a number of reasons a person could be inactive. It could be their playstyle or simply because they don't have much to say, you can't expect much from the majority of the players on day 1, not this early anyway. Though role has something to do with it, I'd imagine the vanillas would try to be more active because they don't know what's going on and are also the ones who try to find the most info to make a good vote. Mafia members already know who's on their side and who isn't (other than traitors), so it's more likely that they'd sit back and watch everyone kill themselves. That isn't always the case, of course, but that's more believable than thinking that inactives are vanilla townies.
You're asking us to punish the people who try to contribute and reward the people who don't? You could just tell your mafia members to stop posting while trying to get the more active members lynched. Not that the idea would ever work, but maybe that's what you're thinking. You're also assuming that all mafia members are active, when there's just as much a chance that some are active while others are sitting back. I really don't know what brought you to this conclusion.
2 townies for every mafia is a horrible balance, most games around here are 4 or 5 townies for every mafia member, so I don't know how you came to these numbers, care to explain? Also, asking the moderator how many players are on each side? Yeah, you need more sleep.
No lynching and lynching an inactive is a cop out, plain and simple.Waaaaaah said:
After all that math, you're going with your gut? Who are you, spam_master? Stephen Colbert?
You had mostly worthless stuff to say though
Marshigio continues to impress me, no joke.
I think by "surviving" the lynch he means he will die and come back. So when he gets lynched, we will get a confirmation of his role and alignment then he will come back. So that would prove he was town.
I'm sorry to be the one to say this, especially because you believe me, but you aren't some kind of human litmus test. In fact, I would venture to say that your gut feelings are barely ever right and you are a bit of a unpredictable (in the bad way), maverick player.
Can't you just post without accusing someone of being mafia? Also, don't expect the players to believe you if you just jump in later in the game with a list of suspicious people.
Leonidas only gave his role away when he was close to being lynched and attacked, he didn't tell the town ASAP like Tom has done, at least I don't remember it playing out like that. If Tom wanted to use his role the best he could, wouldn't he wait longer in the game when it becomes clearer who isn't on his side to kill?
Am I the only person who doesn't think it's weird to mention an SK? There's 14 people in the game, plenty of room for an independent. I really don't see the big deal in saying that there could very well be a serial killer in the game.
Im not comparing it directly between players, just the role (kind of...I guess). Leo did wait, while Tom did not. Leo told us everything about his role, Tom might have not. There is no way to tell until he is actually out of the game or the game ends. So yes, if he actually has that ability, it would indeed be smart to wait to pull out that card.
