Mafia Royal Sleepover - The Party has been Crashed! Mafia Wins!

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Works well for me

 

[Overswarm]

Mass claim should occur on D3, but no sooner.

Lynch Gheb toDay.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

What's wrong with AtE as long as I provide logic beside it? Answer this, DH or else you're only parroting a case that's already weak enough as it is.

Also, the timing of your post is curious to say the least. Surely, you couldn't have missed Zen proposing a mass claim, correct? How is that not worth any attention from you? We have a claimed mason and likely another investigator next to you ... and we have a dead doc. I find it hard to believe that you're willing to let that slide without comment but instead draw attention to a minor issue.

You haven't done **** this game, DH. You've cruised through Day 1 almost exclusively attacking your attackers. You've done nothing but ride your claim while providing no results whatsoever. And when it come down to it you of all people were the one to accuse kuz of riding his claim.

Zen, the only thing making ******** suggestions like that does is to muck up everything. Your justification is BS at its finest...you say it's going to help deciding who is scum between Gova and Nabe yet your preferred lynching order is J -> me. My accusation towards you playing this game with the intention to look like a guru for your own sake more than to help the town still stands. This doesn't make you "hard to read" or helpful to the town, it makes you deadweight.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Wow, why are you all so horrible at this game.

 

[CT Chia]

Vote: Zen

His absolute dire need for claims today and yesterday make him either scum or a bad asset for town. Town should not be playing like this, so it makes sense that he's mafia, and hopefully not a wow really bad townie.

 

[Overswarm]

Chibo, be less bad. Vote for Gheb.

 

[Xivii]

Zen, you will never learn to become a good player as long as you continue to rely on claims, or you will never cease to be scum.

I don't care about being a good player. I only care about winning.

 

[Xivii]

Why haven't we lynched J yet? OS you should really vote for J and save Gheb for tomorrow.

 

[X1-12]

Has OS compared Chibo to Nicholas1024 yet?

 

[Xivii]

What's wrong with AtE as long as I provide logic beside it? Answer this, DH or else you're only parroting a case that's already weak enough as it is.

Also, the timing of your post is curious to say the least. Surely, you couldn't have missed Zen proposing a mass claim, correct? How is that not worth any attention from you? We have a claimed mason and likely another investigator next to you ... and we have a dead doc. I find it hard to believe that you're willing to let that slide without comment but instead draw attention to a minor issue.

You haven't done **** this game, DH. You've cruised through Day 1 almost exclusively attacking your attackers. You've done nothing but ride your claim while providing no results whatsoever. And when it come down to it you of all people were the one to accuse kuz of riding his claim.

Zen, the only thing making ******** suggestions like that does is to muck up everything. Your justification is BS at its finest...you say it's going to help deciding who is scum between Gova and Nabe yet your preferred lynching order is J -> me. My accusation towards you playing this game with the intention to look like a guru for your own sake more than to help the town still stands. This doesn't make you "hard to read" or helpful to the town, it makes you deadweight.

Actually J ->Nabe -> You/Swiss/Someone. Which is why I'm voting J.

 

[Overswarm]

Why haven't we lynched J yet? OS you should really vote for J and save Gheb for tomorrow.

While J has been scummy, he hasn't been any scummier than Chibo (who, by the way, is only not on my radar for his statements because I imagine him being near sighted whenever I read his posts), who has managed to stand up and say one of three canned responses:

"ATTENTION EVERYONE! I don't know what's going on."

"ATTENTION EVERYONE! We should move in this new direction."

or, my personal favorite

"Hey guys, how 'bout that weather? Sports team and cold coffee! Long days and short vacations. Am I right? Generic out of context wisdom."

Which basically means Chibo is still off in his ooooooown little world.

Which leads to two obvious conclusions:

1) Chibo is town and isn't paying much attention to what is going on and/or doesn't know what's going on

2) Chibo is scum and his actions are meant to circumvent pro-town play

Flips and further evaluation could let you figure out Chibo later.


But why don't we lynch Zen?

Zen wants J lynched. Gheb wants J lynched.

Hell, EVERYONE wants J lynched, amirite?

Oh riiiiiiiiiight. Thar beh scum in dis hear gayme.

When a silver platter appears, you do not take a silver platter unless it is your last possible choice.

J's actions have been, and always will be, telling of something. Whether what those actions tell you lead to him being scum or town depend on information we do not have at this point in time, but can have soon.

So while it may be tempting to lap up a free lynch as it gives the illusion of progress, I'm not so fast to lynch an open book when we have ample other targets that are infinitely more mysterious, as well as Gheb which seems clear as day to anyone who looks closely at him.

So no, J is not the play for toDay. Gheb is the play for toDay, and tomorrow's play will be the result of the Night actions. I'm unfamiliar with Gova's play, but his responses have fit those of a cautious scum mate that has recently found his (or her?) footing. I haven't checked prior activity or games yet and don't recall playing with Gova, but Gova's play in this game so far have been clearly indicative that he is not a leader. It is infinitely unlikely that Gova is the "head" of any scum team, and this coupled with the reactionary and cautious nature of Gova's posts of toDay in addition to the connections from D1 lead me to believe Gova is someone to be looked at closely tomorrow depending on Gheb's flip.

Again, Gheb will be the play for toDay.

I'd also like to remind you Gheb that no, you are not KevinM, nor will you get away with what KevinM does. You post too much for that to be possible. So I'd drop the consistent AtE's and insults.

You could read my games and see my posts, I generally use that strategy a lot as both alignments. You might learn something.


:B




Swiss, X1, Zen, all vote Gheb.

J is a possibility for toMorrow.

 

[Overswarm]

Oh, in addition to voting?

Could everyone answer this nonsense question for me:

What style do you view the forum in (revolution, smash blue, etc.)?

 

[Swiss]

V Just finished post. Literally no content in here FYI. Terrible post.


OK. So here I am. Ready for a bounty of useful content? As ever, notes as I go.

Cool.

Gheb if we lynch J and he flips town - will you accept yourself as the lynch toMorrow?

Gova, talk about me.

Usually you can read me well though (aimmafia albeit) this is our first forum game together disregarding your first newbie game.

Lol scum. Has anyone else quoted this post?

Cool Zen. Zen is town. Did I say that already?

Accidentally reading D1. Skipping. Keeping in what I wrote already. Pro gaming.

Lol'd at OS' case. So canned.

J what's your stance on Gheb? Do you ever call him Ghebby Cakes?

Gova what's your stance on OS? He dat obv town?

I wanna think Gheb is town. Effort. Too much? Let's read and find out kids.

Gonna slip this in here so Chibo doesn't see it. ToMorrow, if Chibo/his mason hasn't died, I want his partner to claim.

Nabe, do you think Gheb's #1001 was legit or a joke?

Is Mentos is in this game?

I'm okay with being lynched,

Just let me say some things first if I can.

Still agree to this?

F the notes.

OS town. Zen town. J scum. Chibo provisional town, want proofies. Gova lurker. Gheb idk. Nabe idk.

OS - If Gheb flipped town, why would this be different to the Roxy lynch in Community?

What strange personalities in this game. Should I develop an annoying quirk while we're at it?

J playing like Bear and Fish and I'd be comfortable with a lynch in that direction.

He was town.

....



Getting bored.

Chibo you a lover or a mason? Someone tell Chibo to read this bit. He'll have skimmed it.

X1 you mind getting copped toNight? Is there any reason that would be a bad idea?

Mentos, what's your stance on Gheb?

J - You're willing to get let lycnhed instead of pushing Gheb? Weren't you doing this earlier?

DH and Swiss, you guys have been quiet this game. Don't know about DH but very unusual for Swiss - I thought your laptop issues have been fixed? Please get posting asap.

You know how we talk on AIM a fair bit when I have a laptop. You know how this requires me to be online, and have AIM? Yeah. Why did you think it was fixed? What lead you to this belief?



Way too much for me to be bothered reading properly. Would lynch any of those indicated. Would hammer Gheb if wagonned s'pose.

Vote J


Chibo, how do you feel about your partner toMorrow? How would this affect town?

Would lynch J, X1 or maybe Gheb depending on how nice OS is. I'm aware of the fact that I just added in X1 and have not mentioned him at all in my post. Have no stance on Gova.


Take those last stances as golden. I probably contradicted myself from earlier.

 

[X1-12]

Classic blue

 

[X1-12]

I don't know how I'm meant to answer the question about copping me


there's better targets but cop me if you have trouble reading me or something..? idk/idc really.

 

[Swiss]

That's your scum answer.

 

[X1-12]

yes dear


cop me


oh wait thats my godfather answer



don't cop me


oh wait thats my scum answer

 

[Swiss]

For a guy with Muhatama Ghandi as his avvy, you sure do get mad easy.

Anyway, explain why your two 'scum answers' are different.

 

[X1-12]

'yes dear' is not mad, its condescending and implying you are a child

I don't understand the question

 

[Swiss]

I don't understand the question

No surprise there.


This is your scum answer.

don't cop me


oh wait thats my scum answer

Yet this also is, and you did not contest the point

I don't know how I'm meant to answer the question about copping me


there's better targets but cop me if you have trouble reading me or something..? idk/idc really.

That's your scum answer.

So - why is it both of them?

 

[X1-12]

Whatever I said you could say "that's your scum answer" or something of the sort. I was pointing this out and implying its a dumb question to ask.

 

[Swiss]

So it wasn't your scum answer, yet you decided not to point that out, and bring in a logical fallacy instead?

 

[X1-12]

Yes I decided not to point that out

Did I bring in a logical fallacy?

 

[Swiss]

Why did you think it beneficial to not point it out?

 

[X1-12]

because I think that would start a pointless argument, just saying "NO U" over and over.


Are we seriously having this conversation

 

[Overswarm]

X1, vote for Gheb.

 

[X1-12]

Third time lucky eh OS?


no.

 

[Overswarm]

Why not?

 

[Rockin]

Mafia Royal Sleepover

J (4) - Gheb, X1-12, Zen, Swiss

Gheb (1) OS,

Nabe (1) - J

Gova (1) - Nabe

Zen (1) - Chibo

Not Voting - Mentos, DH, Gova,

Deadline is Feb 25th 2011. It takes 6/11 votes for a lynch

Mentos has been prodded

Sorry for the semi lack of update. I'm currently OoS, but there's a hotel computer, so I can prod/ update people in need instead of asking another mod to watch the game for me

 

[Xivii]

Swiss is voting J as well iir.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

Chibo, please don't think you can be useless just because you're a claimed mason.
Zen, Gova is scum. It's okay, he'll get his. What do you think of OS?
Swiss, 1001 is serious probably. Also chuckling re: J being town in B+F, that's almost the truth.

Dislike DH's 1159. DH is not scum with Ghebscum. Also it's way too informed and way too confident for a player who hasn't posted once toDay before then.

If X1 isn't scum then I would actually love to see DH go. Sadly if OS isn't scum then DH isn't likely to be either. Zen can be vigged after Gova as well. Gheb still town.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Actually J ->Nabe -> You/Swiss/Someone. Which is why I'm voting J.

Then why do you need a mass claim to determine who out of Nabe / Gova is scum if Nabe is your #2 scum pick but Gova is nowhere near that? Your explanation still doesn't work. I mean it's not a big deal to me if you just admit that it was a stupid suggestion. Much more than trying to cop out with half-answers.

Gheb if we lynch J and he flips town - will you accept yourself as the lynch toMorrow?

Why would I? A mislynch is never only one player's fault - it's everybody else's just as much. How is the guy who just jumped the bandwagon less suspect than the one who actually takes a clear stance towards it? Dumb question imo.

 

[Overswarm]

Chibo, please don't think you can be useless just because you're a claimed mason.
Zen, Gova is scum. It's okay, he'll get his. What do you think of OS?
Swiss, 1001 is serious probably. Also chuckling re: J being town in B+F, that's almost the truth.

Dislike DH's 1159. DH is not scum with Ghebscum. Also it's way too informed and way too confident for a player who hasn't posted once toDay before then.

If X1 isn't scum then I would actually love to see DH go. Sadly if OS isn't scum then DH isn't likely to be either. Zen can be vigged after Gova as well. Gheb still town.

Gheb isn't and this post makes no sense without reasoning.

Reasoning give.

Vote Gheb!

 

[Xivii]

Because I would lynch Nabe over Gova if they didn't claim.

 

[Xivii]

x1 or swiss is probably scum. Probably swiss.

@Nabe: Town mostly.

 

[Xivii]

nevermind I thought Gheb was Swiss haha.

 

[Xivii]

I don't know how I'm meant to answer the question about copping me


there's better targets but cop me if you have trouble reading me or something..? idk/idc really.

I agree. This is such a scum answer.

not sure why ur getting mad

 

[Xivii]

Will go through everything and try to show you why J is scum sometime this weekend hopefully.

 

[X1-12]

not sure how I'm coming across as mad at all.

 

[Overswarm]

Or we could kill Gheb instead.