Pwnz0rz Man
Smash Lord
I think you misunderstood the intent of the thread. He's adding effects to preexisting attacks, not creating new attacks, and not changing how the characters play. They're purely visual alterations. Consider your requests by these definitions and you might have more luck.Don't know if it makes sense for his attacks:
We know the old fire Version of Yoshi
and another fire Version from Mario Galaxy 2 when Yoshi eats a red dash papper
I'd love to see something new for Yoshi, but in terms of the GFX that King Puff is working with, I don't see anything canonically that makes sense.
One thing that might be neat though, would be changing the effects of Mewtwo's Shadow Claw (Side-B) depending on it's color. I could imagine the Red Mewtwo using it with a fire effect. It would carry the same animation, but considering Mewtwo can also learn Fire Punch as well as the other elemental punches, it wouldn't be too much of a stretch. Blue Mewtwo could have ice effects for Ice Punch, and Green could have electric effects for Thunder Punch. It's just a thought though. I'm unaware if Shadow Claw would be subject to the "No changing articles" rule that probably haunts people who want Dr. Luigi throwing pills.
As for the animation not looking like a punch. Well you've got me there, but a little imagination goes a long way.