Ashley picks up the stuffed elephant. "This will do," she says.
Meanwhile, Baby Ashley is once again running away from her sitter, who is trying to change her diaper. Baby Ashley locks herself in the basement and hears the mysterious voice again. She starts running towards it, the voice taking her farther into the darkness than before. She emerges in an ominous yet whimsical forest and sees her stuffed bunny. "Hello, Ashley!" it says. "Here's your present, like I promised." It gestures to a human corpse, and Baby Ashley squats down and eats it, getting lots of blood all over herself. Once she's done, she turns to the bunny again.
"My, what an appetite! Go home now, sweet child. I shall show you more of this place at another time," the rabbit says. Baby Ashley the runs back through the darkness and into the basement. She sees her stuffed bunny sitting next to the stairs, in a place she had not left it, and picks it up happily. The sitter bangs on the basement door, calling for her, but Baby Ashley ignores her and plays with her bunny on the floor.