EddyBearr
Smash Lord
Sadly, I feel like this might end up becoming just me. Wish I knew about this earlier.
Knuckles:
Uniqueness: 4. He'd basically be a Sonic clone, though slower. Even his "Special trait," his fists, is used extensively by Sonic anyways.
Appeal: 5. Sonic fans tend to be pretty obsessive, and as such there's a lot of folks asking not just for Sonic, but also knuckles, shadow, silver, and every other hedgehog clone that ever existed. It might make some folks extremely happy, but for anyone unbiased by fanaticism, it'd seem like a massively wasted slot.
Balance: 6. Sonic is all by himself, so an edgy "teammate" might ease his situation a bit, but nothing major.
Style: 5. The style of Sonic characters is massively different from that of Nintendo characters, but we're already a little used to it.
Still dunno what to "analyze."
Refusing to nominate.
Knuckles:
Uniqueness: 4. He'd basically be a Sonic clone, though slower. Even his "Special trait," his fists, is used extensively by Sonic anyways.
Appeal: 5. Sonic fans tend to be pretty obsessive, and as such there's a lot of folks asking not just for Sonic, but also knuckles, shadow, silver, and every other hedgehog clone that ever existed. It might make some folks extremely happy, but for anyone unbiased by fanaticism, it'd seem like a massively wasted slot.
Balance: 6. Sonic is all by himself, so an edgy "teammate" might ease his situation a bit, but nothing major.
Style: 5. The style of Sonic characters is massively different from that of Nintendo characters, but we're already a little used to it.
Still dunno what to "analyze."
Refusing to nominate.