Some clarifications.
There are two scum teams. For hypothetical, let's look at this situation as if I was scum. How could I coordinate with the other team to ensure that Tom took the hit, without exposing myself? Even if I was scum, there's no way to "make the worst case scenario happen."
Your second statement makes no sense. You're saying that if it was the optimal play... me pointing it out is scummy? Again, there's no way to make the worst case happen, even as scum.
1. that's why I said
try to make the worst case happen.
2. you seem to be equating logic with being town. The issue is that we can't take that at face value,
because mafia is hunting mafia during the day as well
Well yeah, it wasn't guaranteed. I saw no reason to take the bet that the incapped players were automatically town. I don't even think the chance was actually 10% when you consider the fact that there are two scum teams, but I don't really want to do the math here. Point is, it wasn't guaranteed and there was no reason to call it guaranteed that early.
how on earth will you function in a game with no cop if you're looking for a guarantee? Currently you have no issue pushing a vote on nabe, despite there being no guarantee. I also said in my early posts it wasn't a guarantee, but I don't mind taking the chances on D1 that they are clear, and then having further discussion in the oncoming days.
not to mention you're arguing for a guarantee, which I believe in my very first post about it, I said "it's not a guarantee they're clear, but maybe clearER"
I'm not sure what you mean about the scum hunt during the day bit being demonstrated by flips.
You argued that scum desire to scum hunt (implication being scum will scum hunt at night)
The death of tom proves that incorrect.
Pokechu is far from exonerated due to his lack of activity, but I'm not sure how much of that is just me being against inactives. He miiiiight be ok.
this was more of a joke, wherein you dislike high percentages of success, but will spring for high risk of failure.
e.g. since I'm 0% chance of being mafia, I'm expecting you to vote for me.
Now some actual stuff :
Ok, great. I'm glad you like the spreadsheet. Whether I live or die today, priority 1 is making sure that sheet gets out there. I 100% believe that there is scum in that pool.
I think this is a non-statement, that might also be an dramatic play :
ex : Lady : "I'll fall on my sword for the greater good of this spreadsheet getting out"
The problem is that there are 10 people left (including me) (9 people if you want to play it like that)
4 of those are mafia. You almost have an equal chance of grabbing town as you do grabbing mafia in any group of 4 or 5.
Another thing that is sticking in my brain, is that Tom voted on you before switching to vote on Zeke.
Now Tom has been killed.
Maybe a better question to ask is :
why do you think Tom was targeted at all, much less by both scum teams?
@Nabe and @Lady
I think that those that hold the keys that Wright is referring to are the last few people to hammer Zeke. Re : Lady's list.
I could be wrong though