I already bought one example to the table being that Ryker has also been out here making connections to past games. And apparently because Joey likes Rykers slot he’s ok with that.
Ryker is the only example of significantly doing this and the thing here is that his post "making a connection to past games" doesn't mean much of anything in terms of his read. He was sold on Soup scum/policy lynch before that point. He doesn't go in really hard on how Nabe had the biggest AtE blow up in 2015 where he ruined DGames forever and then reference mafiascum as a source of players doing AtE. With Laundry, you literally made a comparison to a past game where Nabe was godfather and you had him pinned against the wall, and then referenced popular players in Nzone, but literally none of that applies here. The general idea of Soup's AtE being a scum tactic in games as a whole is a universal, understood concept.
Also note that on re-reading Day 3 maybe 2-3 times, I couldn't find the post where he was voting Soup on connections to past games. Correct me if it's the case because reading through that Soup AtE scenario is a struggle, but the fact that there isn't a grand push on Soup for this and Ryker had a LOT of other reasons to vote Soup while your horrible reference to a past game is a selling point for you on Laundry makes them completely different scenarios by itself.
Then he’s complaining about my read and vote changes. We literally had people switching votes to different people and different reads all over the place yesterday.
Did I ever say specifically you voting other people is suspect? Pretty sure I'm targeting the reasoning here, not you actually swapping votes.
Lastly hes just finding nitpicks that could easily be made for other people. Like my pokechu post for example where I say he wasn’t scum. That’s somehow overlooked because I voted pokechu even though I explained my reasoning numerous times. He just doesn’t like it to not like it.
In terms of your reasoning, literally no one should feel like they have their backs against a wall and make a full on scum post for Pokechu when they're not even in the pool. What reason does a townie have for going "I think scum is here, but I'm going to vote Pokechu with a full post saying I don't like his play because town is going to lynch him anyways. I don't think he's actually scum though"? Your reasoning by itself gives me no reason to believe it since it completely contradicts your actual posts at the time of Pokechu's vote.
As a whole, providing your reasoning after a flip with your lack of understanding retrospect just means I have no reason to believe it.
Then there’s the other parts. He seemingly takes no isssue with nabe’s posts until he is grilled on nabe being scum.
I've had Nabe as null. No one has had genuine reason to grill Nabe scum before today aside from the fact that he didn't have posts. I don't remember much of anyone pointing to Nabe's posts and saying "Yeah let's lynch here", it was the idea that he wasn't here. I'm not going to go for a null slot if I have actual scum reads.
He also refuses to believe and find Laundry’s post looking a little bad after his soup fight. Which honestly if you can’t see those two things as at least possibilities, how are you town?
No one has convinced me that Laundry is scum. Why are Laundry's posts looking bad? Laundry talked a LOT to soup, and being done with that after the AtE blow up just doesn't make Laundry scummy. If anything it's null, but nothing that happened Day 3 is enough to throw Laundry from a town read to a scum read since Soup kind of did it to himself with his blow up and the aftermath.
Joey is proving he isn’t open to discussion on some of the bigger plays no matter how hard it wants it to seem he is.
I was suspect of Soup, I'm still suspect of Ryu and now Disfunk, and Day 2 was "everyone is town" scenario. Just because I'm not voting there when your slot exists doesn't mean I'm not open to those lynches happening. There are other scummy people and if other people go that way I'll discuss it with them and have my thoughts out there. Just because I'm not entertaining the idea of "let's vote the completely inactive guy" when your slot exists doesn't mean I'm not open to discussion about other options.
He’s been fixated on me from the start even when others read me as town st the start. It’s pretty clear he wants to j my see a picture where I’m scum and he hasn’t hard stayed on any other scum choices really.
WIFOM. Why do I have to read you town just because other players meta read you as town?
This vote has most of the same stuff I went over in my wall. Gives me absolutely no reason to change my vote.
Note that due to multiple lynches happening if we don't hammer, I will hammer Ryu if needed though. I should be here until deadline.
