The scummiest things I see is Swords and Soup going after each other. I don't think it's entirely unreasonable to think there's a scummer in there, but I wouldn't throw the possibility of TvT out the window either. I think there's something there, but I don't think it'll be useful until later in the game, when more than 2 things have happened.
This is actually really fence-sitty, and it's somethign that Joker's done a bit of in this game. He's saying it could be either svt, or tvt, or even svs! Backdoors are not things a townie should leave in his posts.
As far as my opinion on that strategy goes, I dislike the idea of exploiting the system, generally. But I certainly see the merits of it, and would begrudgingly go along. I just feel like these kinds of plans end up making people feel safer than they are.
"Let's not use this protown plan kuzi came up with, becausen i don't like exploiting the system in town's favor". Is this self explanatory enough?
Umm, I suppose it's possible that Nabe might be one of Kat's scummates, but I'm not willing to lynch Nabe based on a connection to Kat without seeing Kat's flip first.
does this still apply now? You've been pushing nabe most of toDay. What happened to that kat scumread btw?
sitting on kat all dayphase. Eww.
Marshy said:
pjb -> soup -> none -> kataefi -> nabe -> none -> hilt
PJB's vote log at the end of D1. rather contained, all in all, with just soup, then a long itme on kat, then a couple flips at deadline.
you're reading BarDulL as scum? Good job man, you managed to peg the dead guy who flipped scum as scum.
Antagonizing someone saying they were iso'ing a dead player for connections is pretty yuck.
Anyway, enough about night actions.
Nabe obviously needs to go, his claim is a lie. Townies shouldn't lie with their claims, because this is what happens. I don't even see a reason to believe he's a townie who lied to save his butt, why do that? What if Kuz came out of inactivity to counterclaim him? No, that's dumb, there's no way that was some townie's master plan. That's scum cleverly wiggling out of a lynch, and then getting exposed as a liar by night actions.
Wait, what happened to all that kat suspicion?
So as a town PR, you're saying you were willing to possibly get into a counterclaiming scenario with another town PR, leaving us to choose between 2 town PRs for the lynch? That's.. horrible.
I mean, it's not like Nabe was such a great slot, soup. He was gonna get lynched, and he's only still alive because of his claim. Now we know his claim is a lie, and he's making another bad claim to keep himself alive longer. Why do we need him again, when all he does is muddy the waters?
back to sitting on a scumpick!
PJB said:
Nabe is scum because he, also, is not doing anything. You think my play is lazy and half-*****, ok that's fair. Nabe is literally just as bad, if not much much worse (I'm of the opinion that it's much much worse, btw. Where are Nabe's pushes? Where has he led us?), and here's the kicker. He also made a terrible terrible, incriminating claim. But somehow, I'm the bad guy here. This is just a big fat ****ing pile of whatever. If you can't see why Nabe is scummy, then there's literally nothing I could say to you. He isn't scumhunting, and his town claim was a lie. What in the world more could you possibly want?
Bit of ad hominem here, saying that PJB's not scum because "well nabe's much scummier then I am!"
Ok, so is anyone else even looking at Nabe's terrible push against Kary? Can we just lynch this guy already? He can claim if he wants to, but if he keeps refusing then we really should just get rid of him.
This, plus what nabe highlighted in 1180, is rather contradictory.
Vote
JB
