As an important addendum: What happens in the months and years after sometimes plays a major role and indeed shapes how characters are remembered. This not only includes people thinking
and "HIYAA!" when hearing about Fox or
and "BEHOLD MY POWER!" - incidentally cementing Meta Knight's reputation as a badass.
is a good example of this too, since it was long considered a joke no matter the skill level... until
returned with a vengeance in Ultimate. To the point Sakurai considered it neccessary to nerf Pichu.
Or how Falcon's so heavily associated with catchphrases and the series in general.
It's kinda why I highlight players that are characters' flagbearers: they contribute to a character's legacy, even if it's not always large. But they push the characters and continue to place a spotlight on them, indirectly influencing not just other players but also developers and even characters. Sure, even if players like the "20GX" Melee trio (S2J / Wizzrobe / n0ne) or Fatality - the most well known Ultimate Falcon - are not the primary reason Falcon has the image of a hype machine with catchphrases, they've helped to reinforce that.
I know that when the Byleth retrospective comes around I'm gonna mention MKLeo kinda by neccessity. And he started using Byleth not just because the character clicked with how he plays - but also since he really enjoyed 3H. In a way,
it illustrates how people connect with characters.
I'd be really interested - I have never had a clue who Red Arcueid actually is (only know her from my time spent tinkering with MUGEN).
So I gotta ask anyone who knows: who is this character and why is she so hardcore that it looks like she could punch through a series of brick walls?