Disney Pop Stars Mafia | GAME OVER I WONDER WHO WON IT REEKS OF PERFUME

[Cello_Marl]

Oh yeah.

I meant Chibo.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Yeah Chibo is mafia

 

[Cello_Marl]

Why is Nix MJ?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

No connections to anybody and no pushing for anything.

 

[Nix2100]

Cello is starting to make no sense to me....I was also thinking about how he was so sure that the MJ also tried abducting Kevin but considering there isn't any town PR roles, I can't see any reason why MJ wouldn't try abducting someone..so I suppose that is valid logic.

@Gheb - Not sure at the moment to be honest, I find it slightly interesting that Cello said for a couple posts that he was planning on going for Kevin today...but at the end said he would take his hand and vote for me today if Kevin voted for Tandora....although considering Kevin got killed last night I am not exactly sure if that somewhat clears Cello or not....

 

[SummonerAU]

So guys, are we still going Nix today or not? I'm cool with Gheb right now as well.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I'm town though

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Vote Nix

 

[Nix2100]

You know...I tried going through and re-reading to try and see if I can get any reads...but honestly I got nothing.

Kirby, Bungle, and Summoner - Either been absent or aren't posting all that much so I can't really get a read on them.

Mayling - I like...definitely town imo.

Cello - Opinion is kind of mixed however you seem to be town as well at the moment. However my gut is telling me that between you and Gheb, one of you is the MJ...and I am a bit inclined to believe it is Gheb.

....and yes..I think i just noticed how utterly useless I am....

Vote: Gheb_01

 

[Cello_Marl]

I'm tired of giving people free passes for not talking.

Maymay, make your Jungle case please. He should be back soon (or is, I don't even know) and that's something you wanted us to pay attention to since he's unlikely to explode like you thought.

Kirbyo, you agreed with my point on Tanny. What do you think about her flip, and what it means?

Nix, why are you lumping Summoner in there too? (just asking, don't think you're inactive)

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Chaco, Gheb, Mayling scumteam.

You are now officially safe from any and all harm.

What does this mean?

Kirby - Either been absent or aren't posting all that much so I can't really get a read on them.

I was V/LA through what was technically yesterday (Sunday, EST). It was posted in the V/LA thread, but I didn't have time to post it in any of my games.

Kirbyo, you agreed with my point on Tanny. What do you think about her flip, and what it means?

It means this...

Vote: Mayling

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Kirbyoshi, you realize that her being town heavily implies that I actually did doctor that screenshot, right? I didn't, but that's what it looks like.

Other than that, are you just relying on Tandora (and Delvro's) judgment? What about May is scummy to you? Why aren't you voting for me?

 

[Kirbyoshi]

I'm not relying in Tandora's judgment, but I do agree with it, now that the flip happened.

On a related note...

if junglebunglepandabear is at the risk of spontaneously exploding do i really have to spend 1-5 hours on a post against him?

Now that Fever will be active again, then take as long as you need to make a case on him, if you still think he's scummy, even if it does take 5 hours. Do it in several sittings. I just wanna see a content post from you.

 

[SummonerAU]

Why do you think this?

I don't see why we haven't wagoned Scumbagfever yet.
Unvote Vote Jungle

So Gheb, what was your motivation for wanting a Bungle wagon at this point?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Getting rid of a deadweight.

 

[Cello_Marl]

unvote vote Nix

 

[Nix2100]

Im still trying to understand the case against me..cause right now all I see is Gheb's accusation of me being MJ because I have no connections to anyone and I don't push for anyone's lynch....but honestly, I am like that Every Game. Every Single One.

@Cello - I put Summoner in there because while I do see the posts they make...they are kind of null-tells for me and I can't really get a read off of them.....Also I laugh at the thought of someone going through the trouble of doctoring a screenshot....that be kind of amazing tbh.

Coming to think of it...why don't we play a game then shall we? Everyone should post players they think have a connection with someone else! Let's see how many OTHER people have no connections whatsoever! And then we can see who hasn't really been pushing for a lynch...oh wait...that's like all the people that are inactive -_-

Gheb is totally MJ.

 

[Cello_Marl]

If Gheb is mafia and the mafia targets either MJ or MJ's target then we're fine, and if Gheb is MJ then why is he so sure that Chibo is scum but it's still lylo because it's 4v3.

I think it's SvS, but we should try to hit MJ now if we can. Who do you guys think he is? I'm more inclined towards Nix.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

I understand Cello's reasoning for going after MJ, and I also understand his reasoning for who it is.

Unvote Mayl, Vote: Nix2100

 

[Nix2100]

Would someone kindly fill me in on those reasons? Because I don't see them.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Idk how I'm supposed to be mafia. Kevin also earlier said he thinks I'm MJ.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

im borrowing a computer for today, mainly because i have to write a paper, will do that then reread everythign i missed.

sorry guys.

 

[SummonerAU]

Yeah I just saw that Jungle's inactive in all his games so wagoning him won't do much.

Unvote

Nix, who's the play?

Gheb, I thought you wanted to just get a reaction out of him with how you posted this. Why did you use 'wagoned' instead of 'lynched' if you wanted to get right of him? I thought people would use 'wagoned' in a way to force a reaction whereas they would use 'lynched' in a way that wants them dead. Am I wrong? (This question is to everyone)

Summing up, I have issues with Gheb, but I'm cool with Nix today if we'll look into it tomorrow. At least Gheb is saying things.

Should I wait until Bungle and Mayling have posted before voting? I'm thinking that I should, but if someone can give me a good reason not to, I won't wait.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Want to hear May-chans case on me, been waiting since D1, one really.

Disagree with Gheb on nix, getting the normal townix read. Fromt he 3 or 4 games ive played with him, he is pretty reliant on claims and actions for his scum hutning, but since there isnt any of that, he's playing like he does most D1's (even with information that we have).

Did NOT like Cello's ******** meta on tanny and can't believe he somehow made that the focus of D2. Need to go back and reread the whole game, but this is what i got from what i missed

sorry again guys.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Summoner, I would've been fine with either (lynch or wagon).

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Unvote
FoS Kirbyoshi

 

[Cello_Marl]

Did NOT like Cello's ******** meta on tanny and can't believe he somehow made that the focus of D2.

Why? Everything that I said, and showed, was completely solid. Seriously, other than the fact that she was town, how was my case anything but completely foolproof? She LIED to us. I can't help it that she dug her own grave.

Gheb's #335 made it perfectly clear to me that he, Kirbyoshi and Chibo are the mafia. That just leaves me, Jungle, Nix, May and Summoner. Who's MJ if it isn't Nix? I don't think it's May or Summoner, and it's certainly not me.

I understand Cello's reasoning for going after MJ, and I also understand his reasoning for who it is.

Please explain this for the rest of them, in your own words.

Idk how I'm supposed to be mafia. Kevin also earlier said he thinks I'm MJ.

And this exonerates you as mafia because...?

2. ChiboSempai - I'm just going to assume that you are scum.

**** straight.

 

[SummonerAU]

Wait Cello, why are we hunting MJ specifically today?

I'll assume Chibo is scum for this

5 town, 2 mafia, 1 MJ

Let's say we hit scum today

5 town, 1 mafia, 1 MJ

night phase
1 townie dies, 1 townie is abducted: 3 town, 1 mafia, 1 MJ with 1 town and 1 scum on MJ
1 townie dies, 1 scum is abducted: 4 town, 1 MJ with 2 scum on MJ
1 town is abducted, MJ is targeted for NK: 4 town, 1 mafia, 1 MJ with 1 town and 1 scum
1 scum is abducted: 4 town, 1 MJ with 2 scum in MJ

whereas if we hit MJ

nightphase
1 townie dies: 4 town, 3 scum (LYLO, right?)

...and if we hit town

4 town, 2 scum, 1 MJ with 1 scum in MJ
night phase

all sorts of bad for us

Isn't hitting scum better? The way I see it is that you're trying to get MJ lynched and you aren't sure if it's Jungle or Nix. Wouldn't you be better off going with scum?
...I think my numbers are right

What do you think Mayling?

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Basically, as long as both MJ and at least one Mafia member is alive, we will lose 2 players per Night. Now although the abducted player does not necessarily have to be Town, simple probability states it is likely. So...
If we mislynch, we likely lose 3 townies toDay/toNight.
If we lynch a Mafiosa, we still likely lose 2 townies toNight.
If we hit MJ toDay, we will only lose 1 townie toNight.
The third is the most favorable circumstance. This is why we hunt for MJ toDay.

The main reason Nix is suspect to be MJ is that he has played very isolationist. He doesn't really throw alot of suspicion around, likes to stay (relatively) quiet, and when he does post, it is very forgettable, under-the-radar stuff, not really contributing to scumhunting or relevant to the issue at hand. Very shadowy.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Unfos (lawl)

Yeah that's what I also think about Nix. He can def. die but I want to hear what Jungle thinks about him because he seems to be against it.

 

[Kirbyoshi]

Gheb, you can be so weird sometimes

*Waits for Fever*

 

[Mayling]

kirbyoshi, why did you vote me? you never explained it. once called out on it, you said something about tanny's flip, but never gave other reasons.

so like, i think it's kirbyoshi, summoner, jungle

i'll make a case later

 

[~ Gheb ~]

No, Chibo is def. scum

 

[Nix2100]

So...I am being targeted because I am playing like how I play in every game? *blink* Yea, that makes sense...sure.

@Kirby - I already said I don't know how to scum-hunt, and I feel somewhat insulted that you think my posts don't deal with issues at hand considering that most of my posts are in response to something that was recently posted.

I am also with Gheb...chances are that Chibo is scum....or at the least we can only hope so..otherwise its 4 v 3 v 1...in that case we would have to hope we lynch scum...and actually it just puts us in a really bad spot regardless of what we do.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

It's not that I don't agree with you on how Nix is playing, it's just how Nix ALWAYS plays. He never really says anything unless he's prodded to do so by other players, doesn't really bring much new, etc. I'm only hesitant because if Kirbyo math is right, we're pretty much doomed.

 

[Cello_Marl]

I should have realized this earlier, but ignore the abductions in terms of losses. They neither help nor hurt us.

Think about it. Night actions are usually simultaneous, and unless there is some specific reason why Summoner knows otherwise, it should be safe to assume that the last mafia getting nabbed won't stop his or her night kill from going through. Similarly, lynching MJ is a Day occurrence, so the mafia will get their NK even if he or she's nabbed them all. And since we can't rely on the mafia to NK MJ for us, we must lynch him, so anyone he or she's kidnapped will come back into play, whether town or mafia.

I want to hear May's case on Jungle, but the way I'm seeing things, we aren't screwed yet, even if it's likely.

Wait, I just noticed something, but I won't say it because.

Right now I'm thinking we need to hit hot jailbait *** toDay.

So, vote Kirbyoshi because he's not town.

 

[SummonerAU]

No idea how the night actions work with each other. Simultaneous sounds good.

Kirbyoshi then Gheb?

 

[Cello_Marl]

I won't say "then Gheb", but Kirbyoshi sounds good.

 

[SummonerAU]

I'd like to see posts from Mayling, Nix, Gheb and Jungle about Kirbyoshi before this day finishes

Hell, I'd like to see posts from Mayling and Jungle about something

 

[SummonerAU]

I forgot to mention Kirbyoshi on everyone.