Way to be a complete ****tard about what I just said. If it's so fail, then why in the flying **** after everything that I just weighed does it come out to being the exact same as the current tier list?
coincidence.
the ends does not justify the means
a correct conclusion doesn't imply correct reasoning to get there, hence why you have to show your work to get credit on most math tests.
Also, I'm pretty sure
Ken beat BombSoldier
M2K Beat DaShiz at ROM
M2K beat Dashiz at Fast
Ken beat PC at Anaheim
Ken beat PC at Dallas
OH YEAH!? WELL I'M PRETTY SURE... um... I don't really feel like looking up matches, but at the very least:
PC beat Ken at New York
PC beat Ken at OC3
point is that pointing to individual matches, while helpful to some extent, doesn't fully define a matchup. The only ones on your list that I'd say are two players of equal skill representing their characters are the 2 Ken vs. PC ones, which are nicely counter balanced by my 2 Ken vs. PC matches.
The match up is ARGUABLY even, but I think its definitely slightly in Marths favor.
as I said in my post, I consider it equivalent to the Fox vs. Marth matchup, which is to say that I consider it even and that's what I'm arguing, which you say is acceptable, so I'll move on.
Also in regards to Fox VS Falco:
Fox Vs Falco on FD=Fox (Chain Throw)
Pokey=Fox ***** the entire cast here
Mute City=Fox
Rainbow Cruise=Fox
Battlefield=EVEN
Yoshis Story=Falco?
Dreamland=Falco
Green Greens=Even?
Corneria=???
Fox takes 4 while Falco takes 2 with the chance of three. Fox is the best character for a reason.
I have so many things wrong with this section that I don't know where to start...
um, first off, you're just wrong on your judgments. Saying PS is in Fox's favor is because he ***** the entire cast there is foolish because so does Falco. It's a relatively even stage for the matchup. I could go on, but instead I'll transition to point 2, which is that matchups per stage, especially this one, are extremely player and style dependent. Depending on the Fox's playstyle, you may want either a large or small stage. Hell, you may want FD. It's not even close to hard set. The next issue I have is that you talk about hugely irrelevant counterpick stages and somehow missed a neutral (FoD). Quite literally, the only counterpick stages worth mentioning in this matchup are Corneria and Poke Floats, both of which give Fox an advantage. Next we have the glorious culmination where we add up our incorrect judgements on a random sampling of some neutrals and some counterpicks as the defining evidence that your Fox > Falco opinion is well founded and correct.
Note that all these problems are completely ignoring the fact that I don't think you're even slightly qualified to talk on the matchup due to your inexperience with regards to it.
Ok, let me recap: You said I'm wrong about me saying Fox has the advantage in the Fox VS Falco match up. Got it......
ok, cool, we've got reading comprehension for at least 1 sentence...
but then you said it's IN FOX'S FAVOR when the Fox is a better player which is generally true because more people use Fox.
****, close, but not quite. I said it's generally true because better players gravitate towards Fox, not because more players play Fox. Largely irrelevant I suppose, but w/e, I still don't see how this is supporting your claim that the matchup is in Fox's favor. If the top 10 players in the world all decide that Mewtwo is the bee's knees and they only want to play him from now on and win tournaments over inferior Fox players, that doesn't change the fact that Fox ***** mewtwo's face off. the only way you can seriously try to judge matchups is with players of relatively equal skill.
FINALLY WE AGREE ON SOMETHING!
I've seen so many people go Falco against Fox's in finals and Jman also hates fighting Falcos, right?
WRONG! JMan says that Falco is his 2nd favorite matchup after dittos and as of right now, I think he has the most refined style of Fox vs. Falco I've ever seen.
I feel like your whole paragraph was going for some sarcasm or something, but it's seriously lost on me.
However, I do agree with you when you say that Jigglypuff is better than Falcon and Peach. I think after Falco it goes
Jigglypuff
Falcon
Peach
I agree that this is what 5-7 should look like, but I believe Falco is 2nd, so I think after Falco it goes
Sheik
Marth
Jiggs
Falcon
Peach
When was the last time any of you saw an intense Peach match? I know I've seen plenty of intense or close to finals matches with Scar, SS, and Hax and I've slowly start to see just how crazy jigglypuff can be after watching mango and hungrybox. I don't care how amazing Peaches recovery game is her on stage performance is not as good as Falcons, and her off stage game is not as good as jigs.
Also, good **** CT for finally talking about good things.
Peach's on stage game is better than Jiggs' though and her off stage game is better than Falcon's, so it all evens out by that faulty analysis. As to the last good/intense Peach match, how about PC vs. Shiz? I'm sure there's some Pink Shinobi **** too, but I don't meddle in WC affairs.