My votes.
Top Tier - HMW, Lovage, Phil, Prog, Benteezy, Taj
Mid Tier - Wobbles, Bob$, Dogy
Bleeeh - KK
Unfortunately, the effectiveness of your commentators depends on your audience, because everyone has their own personal tastes. Some people like analytical commentating, some people like hype, some have their own personal mix. I like a hint of commentating with a lot of hype, that's my deal.
Waffles is just awesome, that amount of unadulterated hype is a spectacle to behold.
Lovage really connects himself with the match emotionally and mentally, I feel.
I'm going to agree with a YT comment I saw and say Phil just sounds like he's having the best day of his life.
Prog is just full on swag. He's intelligent, he's responsive to what he's watching, you get excited when he gets excited. He's just cool.
Benteezy is really smart and seems to give genuine advice whenever he gets on mic. He see's something and is like "I'm interested as to why Player A devoted so much to that edgeguard when Player B did this before etc. etc." And he's a cool chill dude. I also think he and Prog make an excellent duo.
Taj is fun as hell and you can tell he's emotionally invested in the match he's commentating on, and gives great commentary since you know he's played the game before on a very high level.
Wobbles is a wealth of information and gives you the play-by-play on everything happening on screen. But he doesn't give you room to breathe, and with all the words he pours out, it's hard to focus on what words are important. And I agree with the Wobbles-Taj dynamic duo, moreso because they're both from AZ.
Bob$ is just fantastic when he gets hype, it's frickin' hilarious. Although I feel like he suffers the same thing that Wobbles does, he doesn't give you room to breathe.
Dogy is pretty cool himself, he's good at interaction with other commentators and gives good play-by-play, but again, I feel distracted from the match when you talk about everything that's happening on screen. He and Dogy work pretty well together too.
KK... honestly, do I have to reference IMPULSE?
