Capcom VS All Stars Mafia - Miracles don't exist (Mafia wins)

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

I see some people voting for Natz.

Meanwhile, I see that she’s claiming Suicide Bomber, which would be a really dumb fake claim since, well, it’s a suicide bomber.

On top of that, she said she’d use it on Holder on this phase, so we can actually test that claim.

If she backs down, then she’s scared and likely scum.
If she doesn’t die by the end of the day, them she’s lying and definitely scum.
If both her and Holder die, then she was telling the truth.

Either way, we’ll know what she is at the end of the phase.

 

[Holder of the Heel]

Why am I being chosen to be blown up? O_O My character and role are at least moderately respectable and there has been accusations thrown all over the place and several roles that are similar.

 

[Pokechu]

Thread is dead :^(

I like how despite all of these pages no leads have been made :'^)

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Thread is dead :^(

I like how despite all of these pages no leads have been made :'^)

What are you talking about? We have reasons to suspect four people.

• White’s role has some shady stuff.
• Crusher voting for Swamp despite sending him a message.
• AEM having an ability to make a daytime PM.
• Opo being a character that was never playable in a crossover, which clashes with the flavor.

And I’m pretty sure I’m forgetting some people.

But rven if you don’t really count those as “leads”, they still give us a direction to go to.

 

[praline]

What are you talking about? We have reasons to suspect four people.

• White’s role has some shady stuff.
• Crusher voting for Swamp despite sending him a message.
• AEM having an ability to make a daytime PM.
• Opo being a character that was never playable in a crossover, which clashes with the flavor.

And I’m pretty sure I’m forgetting some people.

But rven if you don’t really count those as “leads”, they still give us a direction to go to.

@Natz~ Maybe choose one of the 4 listed here.

 

[Deleted member]

@Coricus
Does your desperado ability specify who it can kill? Is it just Mafia or can it kill any non-Town players(as in, a 3rd Party)?

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Nothing's happening...

Please entertain us with ****posts, fallen comrades.

 

[Swamp Sensei]

Nothing's happening...

Please entertain us with ****posts, fallen comrades.

This thread's got enough **** in it already.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

This thread's got enough **** in it already.

I meant funny ****, not confusing ****.

 

[The Stoopid Unikorn]

Well, gotta prepare myself to go back to work.

Might be able to pop in a few times because breaks, but other than that, I'm not gonna be able to really get myself involved much.

Let's hope we get a scum by the end of this phase.

 

[Wolfie557]

I asked coricus to check with Apollo exactly what happens, so she should know by now.

 

[praline]

Could you imagine if this game actually ended with all the mafia surviving?

 

[AEMehr]

Uni is still ignoring the request for the secondary role claim.

 

[praline]

Uni is still ignoring the request for the secondary role claim.

Let’s all vote for him while he can’t defend himself.

 

[Deleted member]

Uni is still ignoring the request for the secondary role claim.

What secondary role claim though? I've seen you ask for that for a while but you haven't elaborated on what it means.

 

[praline]

What secondary role claim though? I've seen you ask for that for a while but you haven't elaborated on what it means.

Doesn’t everyone have a second ability?

 

[AEMehr]

What secondary role claim though? I've seen you ask for that for a while but you haven't elaborated on what it means.

I mentioned his role has no immediate town benefit and that there has to be something else he has to offer.

You can claim it to be a bodyguard of sorts, but there was a lot of talk of someone already claiming that. It seems to put Uni in bad light, so I'm looking for a reason to not feel that way.

He's ignored the request I've posted several times, I've quoted and mentioned him so he must have seen it. There has to be some reason he's dodging.

 

[praline]

I mentioned his role has no immediate town benefit and that there has to be something else he has to offer.

You can claim it to be a bodyguard of sorts, but there was a lot of talk of someone already claiming that. It seems to put Uni in bad light, so I'm looking for a reason to not feel that way.

He's ignored the request I've posted several times, I've quoted and mentioned him so he must have seen it. There has to be some reason he's dodging.

I’m the town bodyguard.

 

[AEMehr]

I’m the town bodyguard.

This is my point.
So then why is he claiming a variation of the same thing? He doesn't seem to want us in on something.

 

[praline]

This is my point.
So then why is he claiming a variation of the same thing? He doesn't seem to want us in on something.

Yeah he didn’t give me much during the night phase.

 

[Deleted member]

I mentioned his role has no immediate town benefit and that there has to be something else he has to offer.

You can claim it to be a bodyguard of sorts, but there was a lot of talk of someone already claiming that. It seems to put Uni in bad light, so I'm looking for a reason to not feel that way.

He's ignored the request I've posted several times, I've quoted and mentioned him so he must have seen it. There has to be some reason he's dodging.

Didn't he claim self-redirector though? I had one back in my own game as a Town role.

Still, he isn't going to be here for a while so it's pointless to keep pushing it for now, but if you want, I can check his role toNight, I was going to do it on one of you two anyways. Gotta figure out who's hiding stuff.

 

[praline]

We still gotta figure out who is definitely mafia in 4 hours. We can’t afford to have another townie die.

 

[AEMehr]

Didn't he claim self-redirector though? I had one back in my own game as a Town role.

Still, he isn't going to be here for a while so it's pointless to keep pushing it for now, but if you want, I can check his role toNight, I was going to do it on one of you two anyways. Gotta figure out who's hiding stuff.

A self-redirector is definitely comparable to a bodyguard in terms of functionality. I don't see why both would be of the same faction.

With White's role, being an inventory of sorts, if he continuously targeted him he'd have a bunch of cards to play with. I see some malicious utility with the power, and want to know what the other thing he's capable of to see if I'm merely looking too far into a theory.

 

[AEMehr]

Err, Inventor. Not Inventory. My point still stands, I see more harm coming for the power than anything else.

 

[Deleted member]

A self-redirector is definitely comparable to a bodyguard in terms of functionality. I don't see why both would be of the same faction.

With White's role, being an inventory of sorts, if he continuously targeted him he'd have a bunch of cards to play with. I see some malicious utility with the power, and want to know what the other thing he's capable of to see if I'm merely looking too far into a theory.

Self-redirector makes no sense as a Mafia ability though, its main use is to take the kill when you know where it's coming from.
Think of it like the Tracker to Bodyguard's Watcher.
Tracker has to figure out who is going to act to check them, while Watcher has to figure out who is going to GET TARGETTED to check them.
Self-redirector figures out who is going to kill and Bodyguard figures out who is going to get killed.

That said, there are other uses, like making them get roleblocked instead of someone or redirect a Mafia buff to themselves. Of coursez that assumes optimal play but its intended use is for the Town and a Mafia redirector is doing nothing but risk themselves.

 

[CrusherMania1592]

We still gotta figure out who is definitely mafia in 4 hours. We can’t afford to have another townie die.

We lost like what 4 townie so far?

 

[praline]

We lost like what 4 townie so far?

Yeah and of the 13 people left there’s still 4 mafia. We’re losing 3 people this phase. If they are all townie then it’s 6 town(I’m including potential third party) and 4 mafia.

Mafia could potentially win at the end of the next night phase without losing anyone.

 

[Wolfie557]

do we really have to lose 3 people then...

 

[praline]

do we really have to lose 3 people then...

No but they want to prove Natz is town and she’s probably not gonna be back to change her mind.

Is this gonna be another mafia game where the L is effectively my fault?

 

[CrusherMania1592]

Holy **** 3?!? Thought it was going to be 2 but seems like this place got crazy

 

[AEMehr]

Hm... Fair enough. That only brings us back to square one though.

Unvote: Unikorn

We've lost 4 town players already. We do need to try to make something happen. Have we not gotten any claims from anyone yet?

 

[praline]

Holy **** 3?!? Thought it was going to be 2 but seems like this place got crazy

Natz is allegedly a suicide bomber.

 

[praline]

Unvote pokechu

Idk who to vote for... errgh.

 

[Deleted member]

So, should Cori and Natz hold off their kills or should at least one of them shoot?

 

[AEMehr]

When in doubt, get the Ninny.
Vote: Holder

 

[CrusherMania1592]

unvote Pokechu
Vote Holder


Idk wtf I'm doing anymore

 

[Wolfie557]

this seems pretty random.

 

[AEMehr]

That's because it IS pretty random.

 

[Deleted member]

I say we give people a chance to defend themselves first

Holder of the Heel
Dunno why they're voting you for but get in here.

 

[praline]

Trying to find the mafia like: