One thing that bugs me with the typical anti-Incineroar crowd is condemning the Pokemon cause he ended up on two feet and not four. Is the trend of Fire Starters going that route over done? Arguably yes. BUT that doesn't give a free pass to hate Incineroar. If it is, then every single Fire Starter should be hated for that reason as the order of release shouldn't matter more than the designs. Typholsion is pretty boring when it's flames are down, Emboar is probably one of the least liked starters, Blaziken loss most of it's homage to Torchic, and Delphox isn't a huge hit even for being a humanoid fox (big with furries) showcases how lackluster it's design was. Obviously people's opinions on the final evolution will vary, but when the most common complaint is 2 feet and not four which is shared among every fire starter but used only against some... it loses it's point fast.
It also spawns some awesome fanart.
View attachment 162601
As someone who has done teams and played through the story with all Ghost teams (Dusknoir, Froslass, Gengar, Mismagius, Banette, Drifblim and/or Rotom) back in Gen 4... I can say Decidueye stands out like a sore thumb and had Ghost tacked onto him more than anything else. Grass/Flying would of made more sense.
The Ghost type has always been more focused on the spooky ghouls you find in the dark that are playful but dangerous. Decidueye is more edgy robin owl in the forest. Hoothoot and Noctowl even fit better as Ghosts.
View attachment 162602