Brawl vs Galaxy vs MK Wii

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 22, 2007

JUMPING_YOSHI said:
I totally agree with you!

But the thing I am sure to love in Brawl is...the story.
Awesome cut-scenes,even without dialog(maybe Sonic and Snake's story will have some,you never know),plot twists(you never know what could happen in here) and the choice(choose which princess do you want to save).That's all I can say!

MK has a lot of replay value too.

The Director · Dec 22, 2007

I believe that the new Ratchet and Clank used spherical worlds, and that technically came out before Galaxy, but Miyamoto has been working with and perfecting the idea since the Mario 128 demo.

Chi's Finest · Dec 22, 2007

The Director said:
LOLOLOL

I think it's funny how they keep saying Mario Kart is going to come out in the second half of 2008...yeah right, folks. This game has holiday 2008 material written all over it.

And once again, does anybody have the Melty Molten music? Or do you know where I can find it?

Isn't Holiday 2008, i the 2nd half of 2008?

I'm guessing Septemberish.

The Director · Dec 22, 2007

You're right, holiday 08 is the second half...but Nintendo keeps claiming a 2nd quarter/March release...personally, I don't think that's gonna happen.

And yes, MK will have a ton of replay value, especially with the online. I think that'll give Brawl a run for it's money a lot more than Galaxy, even tho MK and Brawl won't get scores anywhere near as close as Galaxy.

Shock the Hedgehog · Dec 23, 2007

-A whole new gravity feature that has never been successfully programmed into a 3-D game do some more reserch with you"gaming history book" if its even in there. itsbeen done several times succefully, jus not as the main point, they actually chose somethig to be the main point otherthan a mechanic.
-Graphics that can be compared to that of a 360's um no it can't actually, only if you count bad ones. SHINY doesn't =GOOD
-A much-needed updgrade to the declining Platformer genre if your going to say that than what was your purpose in posting this
-Creative Controls let me put something straight to you fanboys out there. wii not= creative controlls.
-A new twist on the "Princess gets Kidnapped" story its no longer "your princess is in another castle", but in another galaxy
-Some major fan service like....

-Examples or you're a lier
-They aren't just shiny, these are the smoothest and most detailed graphics of any Mario game to date, Sunshine had shiny graphics, but because they were clunky in places, I don't think they're good.
-Well, since SM64, most 3-D platformers have tried to imitate it's greatness, but most imitations aren't great
-So I'm a fanboy for thinking that the Wii's controls are creative? I don't see anyone else doing something like Wii is. (DO NOT EVEN START ON PS3! Nintendo basically did it first, and PS3's "motion controls" are more like gyroscopic controls)
-So? It introduces new characters and it's different
-Great characters new and old, tons of music remixes, the return of some enemies to a main Mario consle game, and Luigi in a playable spot in a main Mario consle game for the first time since Super Mario World

Maben · Dec 23, 2007

These are possibly the only games I will own. Well, I'm gonna say about 3/5 of the games i will own :laugh:

. They are all great, who cares which one is the best *COUGH* BRAWL *COUGH*.

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 26, 2007

I finally got Galaxy for X-mas. It's beast

Mario & Sonic Guy · Dec 26, 2007

Super Mario Galaxy is at the top so far. Things will change once Brawl is released though.

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 26, 2007

And let's not forget MK Wii.

volbound1700 · Dec 26, 2007

Actually Madden 2008 is killing... I went today and all the games where on the shelf except Madden and Tiger Woods 2008. They are killing on the Wii. Hopefully this will get EA to wise up and put March Madness and NCAA Football on Wii.

I see people comparing Brawl with Galaxy, Halo, and Mario Kart but what about Madden and Tiger Woods? EA sports games on Playstation are what made Playstation the top selling unit.

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 26, 2007

volbound1700 said:
Actually Madden 2008 is killing... I went today and all the games where on the shelf except Madden and Tiger Woods 2008. They are killing on the Wii. Hopefully this will get EA to wise up and put March Madness and NCAA Football on Wii.

I see people comparing Brawl with Galaxy, Halo, and Mario Kart but what about Madden and Tiger Woods? EA sports games on Playstation are what made Playstation the top selling unit.

Sure, but not many really hears about those games. These 3 games in this topic, are the biggest on the Wii, or will be atleast, and we're just discussing them in a sorta comparison.

volbound1700 · Dec 26, 2007

Meta_Sonic64 said:
Sure, but not many really hears about those games. These 3 games in this topic, are the biggest on the Wii, or will be atleast, and we're just discussing them in a sorta comparison.

Ugh, more people know about Madden then Mario Galaxy.

Sports Illustrated and ESPN both advertise the game and do specials about it. Every male who watches football or likes football in the United States knows about Madden and College Football (which is about 80-90% of males in the United States).

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 26, 2007

volbound1700 said:
Ugh, more people know about Madden then Mario Galaxy.

Sports Illustrated and ESPN both advertise the game and do specials about it. Every male who watches football or likes football in the United States knows about Madden and College Football (which is about 80-90% of males in the United States).

Where's your proof for this? Do you hear more about Madden than Galaxy nowadays, b/c I know I don't. Do you expect to hear about Madden when Brawl and MK releases? No, not unless it's Madden 09, but you'll hear more people talking about MK and Brawl. Not that I have anything against sports, but these are the top 3 titles for the Wii, atleast in my mind and I'm sure others will agree with me.

volbound1700 · Dec 26, 2007

Meta_Sonic64 said:
Where's your proof for this? Do you hear more about Madden than Galaxy nowadays, b/c I know I don't. Do you expect to hear about Madden when Brawl and MK releases? No, not unless it's Madden 09, but you'll hear more people talking about MK and Brawl. Not that I have anything against sports, but these are the top 3 titles for the Wii, atleast in my mind and I'm sure others will agree with me.

There are more football fans and athletic minded people in this country then video game nerds. I not trying to insult I am just saying. Also go to wikipedia and check the sales.

Only reason Madden games don't get top sales is because they have a different one each year while there is only one Mario game every 5 years or one smash ever 5-6 years. Already been two Madden games for Wii.

More people also read Sports Illustrated then Nintendo Power and more people watch ESPN then watch GTV (which mostly shows Xbox and PS2 games anyways).

ESPN.com was recently ranked in the top 5 most frequently visited websites on the internet. ESPN has whole articles sometimes about Madden/NCAA/NBA, etc.

Ridley FTB!!! · Dec 26, 2007

people who are saying galaxy is underated?i dont think so
ill try and proove some points k?

1.The games does what it is meant to do, be a platformer.It isnt a hybrid game trying to combine two genres together. Thats what lets Sonic down.Platformer and Racing(high speed etc).The game pyshics only allows the game to explore new depts within platformer genre.As we all know Nintendo need to change their game but not tomuch ofa twist.Other (proper) Mario games are simple platformer.Ground,oh look block then jump. SMG forces you to do things that arn't acheivable in normal platformers.
2.Graphics?Graphics?Graphics don't include how a game looks, they also benifit the game quality(smoothness,frames) It is visualy stunning compared to other Wii titles(except MP3) and to many 360 games and few ps3 game . But we have all played games that run slow,or very 'clunky'.Mario at nopoint is degraded by this graphic.Super mario Galaxy throughout the whole game is smooth with perfect frames.
3. the wii remote has and will remain most creative idea that WORKS!.Nintendo have been the first to come up with a gaming system that doesnt required the A,B,R,L,trianlge,shiny button to be pressed.We have dominated the market because of this new system.We are outselling the 360 and by far the Ps3. This new system appeals to many because of its unique play system,so yes this is creative as shown by millions of people who have bought a Wii.
4.In this day and age ,Mario Galaxy brings us a new joy. Ps3 and Xbox 360 seems to persist on making F/TPS games. SMG brings us gaming experiance that hasnt been seen in a while as platformers where mainly stopped. I bet your thinking (if your a Ps3 or Xbox360 fan) HA! thats a lie we have many games that are different from F/TPS then your up yourself because if your saying that ,why do you persist on calling nintendo childish.Most games that arnt Shooting games are childish.Either you say SMG isn't childish or your stuck with F/TPS for the rest of your life mate, cause its a pretty dumb thing to say I ain't playing SMG because its childish when you have a copy of Loco Roco or Viva Pinyata beside you.
5.Yes nintendo need to step away from the same story over and over again but isn't it good to be classic.No you say(probably a PS3 or360 fan) well then if classic games arn't to be made lets not make another Grand theft Auto 4 IN LIBIRTY CITY!!!! I mean its been what 5 times or so.Lets forget about MGS4 and the production of a Halo 4.Lets say normal gaming using a Pad is out because its classic.Oh wait a sec Ps3 and 360 don't exsist anymore and the Wiii does? That is because we have made the playing system of the centuary!(reference to point No.3)So either being classic is good or mabye we should just get rid of it forever...(You choose).Mario galaxy is Classic but it has acuallty improoved on classic which is hard to do when you remeber Super mario 64.
6.What else makes a good game?The atmosphere...Mario games are nothing without the music and tension of the 'beeping' noise when you have low health.SMG does this well because when playing Galaxy for the first time you ain't gonna know whats behind that corner.Mario is great for this unlike a F/TPS.'theres a corner..hmm..no doubt a guy with a gun will be behind it....'See classic gameplay/story that we enjoy still.(reference to No.5)On SMG the world is sphere so you cant see whats over it untill you run into it!So the story is classic not the gameplay!

This stuff prooves Mario Galaxy is good along with most of the Wii!!!So yeah...
Ridley and Dark Samus For Brawl!

maxieman · Dec 26, 2007

I have a bunch of friends who say that the wii is too "kiddy" and that it sucks because "nintendo is all fantasy". When I try to explain their stupidity they just start shouting about how Madden owns Smash bros. and every other game. I think It's funny they call themselves gamers when all they play is Madden, WWII shooters, and a random assortment of driving sims... They think Mario, Sonic, and the like are too childish... WHAT DO I SAY TO THESE PEOPLE!?

(Sorry when you started talkin about Madden I had to ask this)

Ridley FTB!!! · Dec 26, 2007

Ridley FTB!!! said:
people who are saying galaxy is underated?i dont think so
ill try and proove some points k?

1.The games does what it is meant to do, be a platformer.It isnt a hybrid game trying to combine two genres together. Thats what lets Sonic down.Platformer and Racing(high speed etc).The game pyshics only allows the game to explore new depts within platformer genre.As we all know Nintendo need to change their game but not tomuch ofa twist.Other (proper) Mario games are simple platformer.Ground,oh look block then jump. SMG forces you to do things that arn't acheivable in normal platformers.
2.Graphics?Graphics?Graphics don't include how a game looks, they also benifit the game quality(smoothness,frames) It is visualy stunning compared to other Wii titles(except MP3) and to many 360 games and few ps3 game . But we have all played games that run slow,or very 'clunky'.Mario at nopoint is degraded by this graphic.Super mario Galaxy throughout the whole game is smooth with perfect frames.
3. the wii remote has and will remain most creative idea that WORKS!.Nintendo have been the first to come up with a gaming system that doesnt required the A,B,R,L,trianlge,shiny button to be pressed.We have dominated the market because of this new system.We are outselling the 360 and by far the Ps3. This new system appeals to many because of its unique play system,so yes this is creative as shown by millions of people who have bought a Wii.
4.In this day and age ,Mario Galaxy brings us a new joy. Ps3 and Xbox 360 seems to persist on making F/TPS games. SMG brings us gaming experiance that hasnt been seen in a while as platformers where mainly stopped. I bet your thinking (if your a Ps3 or Xbox360 fan) HA! thats a lie we have many games that are different from F/TPS then your up yourself because if your saying that ,why do you persist on calling nintendo childish.Most games that arnt Shooting games are childish.Either you say SMG isn't childish or your stuck with F/TPS for the rest of your life mate, cause its a pretty dumb thing to say I ain't playing SMG because its childish when you have a copy of Loco Roco or Viva Pinyata beside you.
5.Yes nintendo need to step away from the same story over and over again but isn't it good to be classic.No you say(probably a PS3 or360 fan) well then if classic games arn't to be made lets not make another Grand theft Auto 4 IN LIBIRTY CITY!!!! I mean its been what 5 times or so.Lets forget about MGS4 and the production of a Halo 4.Lets say normal gaming using a Pad is out because its classic.Oh wait a sec Ps3 and 360 don't exsist anymore and the Wiii does? That is because we have made the playing system of the centuary!(reference to point No.3)So either being classic is good or mabye we should just get rid of it forever...(You choose).Mario galaxy is Classic but it has acuallty improoved on classic which is hard to do when you remeber Super mario 64.
6.What else makes a good game?The atmosphere...Mario games are nothing without the music and tension of the 'beeping' noise when you have low health.SMG does this well because when playing Galaxy for the first time you ain't gonna know whats behind that corner.Mario is great for this unlike a F/TPS.'theres a corner..hmm..no doubt a guy with a gun will be behind it....'See classic gameplay/story that we enjoy still.(reference to No.5)On SMG the world is sphere so you cant see whats over it untill you run into it!So the story is classic not the gameplay!

This stuff prooves Mario Galaxy is good along with most of the Wii!!!So yeah...
Ridley and Dark Samus For Brawl!

just doing this so people can still read my comments as it was at the end of the last page...

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 27, 2007

volbound1700 said:
There are more football fans and athletic minded people in this country then video game nerds. I not trying to insult I am just saying. Also go to wikipedia and check the sales.

Only reason Madden games don't get top sales is because they have a different one each year while there is only one Mario game every 5 years or one smash ever 5-6 years. Already been two Madden games for Wii.

More people also read Sports Illustrated then Nintendo Power and more people watch ESPN then watch GTV (which mostly shows Xbox and PS2 games anyways).

ESPN.com was recently ranked in the top 5 most frequently visited websites on the internet. ESPN has whole articles sometimes about Madden/NCAA/NBA, etc.

I understand, but do you think sports would really fit in with the comparison of these 3 games?

blazer787 · Dec 27, 2007

Ridley FTB!!! said:
people who are saying galaxy is underated?i dont think so
ill try and proove some points k?

1.The games does what it is meant to do, be a platformer.It isnt a hybrid game trying to combine two genres together. Thats what lets Sonic down.Platformer and Racing(high speed etc).The game pyshics only allows the game to explore new depts within platformer genre.As we all know Nintendo need to change their game but not tomuch ofa twist.Other (proper) Mario games are simple platformer.Ground,oh look block then jump. SMG forces you to do things that arn't acheivable in normal platformers.
2.Graphics?Graphics?Graphics don't include how a game looks, they also benifit the game quality(smoothness,frames) It is visualy stunning compared to other Wii titles(except MP3) and to many 360 games and few ps3 game . But we have all played games that run slow,or very 'clunky'.Mario at nopoint is degraded by this graphic.Super mario Galaxy throughout the whole game is smooth with perfect frames.
3. the wii remote has and will remain most creative idea that WORKS!.Nintendo have been the first to come up with a gaming system that doesnt required the A,B,R,L,trianlge,shiny button to be pressed.We have dominated the market because of this new system.We are outselling the 360 and by far the Ps3. This new system appeals to many because of its unique play system,so yes this is creative as shown by millions of people who have bought a Wii.
4.In this day and age ,Mario Galaxy brings us a new joy. Ps3 and Xbox 360 seems to persist on making F/TPS games. SMG brings us gaming experiance that hasnt been seen in a while as platformers where mainly stopped. I bet your thinking (if your a Ps3 or Xbox360 fan) HA! thats a lie we have many games that are different from F/TPS then your up yourself because if your saying that ,why do you persist on calling nintendo childish.Most games that arnt Shooting games are childish.Either you say SMG isn't childish or your stuck with F/TPS for the rest of your life mate, cause its a pretty dumb thing to say I ain't playing SMG because its childish when you have a copy of Loco Roco or Viva Pinyata beside you.
5.Yes nintendo need to step away from the same story over and over again but isn't it good to be classic.No you say(probably a PS3 or360 fan) well then if classic games arn't to be made lets not make another Grand theft Auto 4 IN LIBIRTY CITY!!!! I mean its been what 5 times or so.Lets forget about MGS4 and the production of a Halo 4.Lets say normal gaming using a Pad is out because its classic.Oh wait a sec Ps3 and 360 don't exsist anymore and the Wiii does? That is because we have made the playing system of the centuary!(reference to point No.3)So either being classic is good or mabye we should just get rid of it forever...(You choose).Mario galaxy is Classic but it has acuallty improoved on classic which is hard to do when you remeber Super mario 64.
6.What else makes a good game?The atmosphere...Mario games are nothing without the music and tension of the 'beeping' noise when you have low health.SMG does this well because when playing Galaxy for the first time you ain't gonna know whats behind that corner.Mario is great for this unlike a F/TPS.'theres a corner..hmm..no doubt a guy with a gun will be behind it....'See classic gameplay/story that we enjoy still.(reference to No.5)On SMG the world is sphere so you cant see whats over it untill you run into it!So the story is classic not the gameplay!

This stuff prooves Mario Galaxy is good along with most of the Wii!!!So yeah...
Ridley and Dark Samus For Brawl!

so if we ignore all the good games out there, then galaxy is better?
there s a difference between clasic ond remake
nintendo is too scared to make a story because it might be more mature of nonchildish.
the wii doesn't sell more because its better, far from it, it sells because it is cheaper than the good ones.
one more thing.......SHUT THE ****ING HELL UP YOU ******* FANBOYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ridley FTB!!! · Dec 27, 2007

blazer787 said:
so if we ignore all the good games out there, then galaxy is better?
there s a difference between clasic ond remake
nintendo is too scared to make a story because it might be more mature of nonchildish.
the wii doesn't sell more because its better, far from it, it sells because it is cheaper than the good ones.
one more thing.......SHUT THE ****ING HELL UP YOU ******* FANBOYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

im not saying we should cut the other good game its that if you diss mario for being old then we can diss your games for playing old.
the gamecude was cheapest so why didnt it sell well?hmm...price isn't a matter.also Xbox and wii arn't far apart form price.same with psp and ds.

and no you shut the **** up.i am prooving points and you are defending.why should people who beileve different shut up?i dare you to walk up to chavs,emo,christians all that type of people and tell them to Shut the **** up..no?well screw you *****asspunkass****pussyfanwingpussy!(wtf?)

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 27, 2007

Is all this called for? Back on topic please.

Ridley FTB!!! · Dec 27, 2007

Meta_Sonic64 said:
Is all this called for? Back on topic please.

we may as well :D

i think MK isnt gonna get far compared to brawl and galaxy..unless it is somewhat really great :D

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 27, 2007

Ridley FTB!!! said:
we may as well :D

i think MK isnt gonna get far compared to brawl and galaxy..unless it is somewhat really great :D

I feel it will be great. It looks great and the new features will definitely be the factors of how it stands out.

Ridley FTB!!! · Dec 27, 2007

Meta_Sonic64 said:
I feel it will be great. It looks great and the new features will definitely be the factors of how it stands out.

then again yeah :D

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 27, 2007

Ridley FTB!!! said:
then again yeah :D

The new trick feature, new vehicles, possibly more characters(I hope for Geno), 12-racers online. It's lookin pretty good. We'll have to see what they can really do with it over the next few months though.

blazer787 · Dec 27, 2007

i meant that fanboy comments are so annoying.
the ps2 sold more becase the price difference was so small(10-$20)
brawl will deystroy galaxy
untill nintendo actually puts some vids or info on MK, i'm not going to give it the benifit of the doupt

The Director · Dec 27, 2007

LOLOLOLOL

This thread went way downhill.

Speed running through Galaxy right now with Luigi. 40 stars in and counting...

Ridley FTB!!! · Dec 28, 2007

blazer787 said:
i meant that fanboy comments are so annoying.
the ps2 sold more becase the price difference was so small(10-$20)
brawl will deystroy galaxy
untill nintendo actually puts some vids or info on MK, i'm not going to give it the benifit of the doupt

dude we finsihed this conversation so shutup.
and how are we annoying?if so i got a question?(cause you know more about this subject than i do)

are Harcore nintendo fans the same as fanboys?and arn't you a fanboy/girl too cause you have strong views for brawl?

The Director · Dec 28, 2007

Started out with 33 stars yesterday...now I have 86...gonna complete it with Luigi tonight with 121...

Jumpinjahosafa · Dec 28, 2007

The Director said:
Started out with 33 stars yesterday...now I have 86...gonna complete it with Luigi tonight with 121...

I don't really care.

The Director · Dec 28, 2007

Jumpinjahosafa said:
I don't really care.

Apparently you care enough to post a reply. That's all the love I need.

Tobi- · Dec 28, 2007

How did a Galaxy + Mario kart Vs Smash bros turn into a daily update of how many stars or characters you have in galaxy?

This thread has nothing to do with spoiling galaxy for others. "Yea, and I have 121 stars and like 10 new galaxies and can play as rosalina when ur done with the uber secret quest".

ok is that really necessary? is that talking about galaxy vs brawl? No.

AllanT · Dec 28, 2007

will it be better than galaxy? heck yes!! galaxy was great but brawl will get 11/10!!

wouldnt be surprised if it sold a MILLION copies in the FIRST WEEK!!!!!!......maybe?

Jumpinjahosafa · Dec 28, 2007

The Director said:
Apparently you care enough to post a reply. That's all the love I need.

Me replying doesn't mean i care..

If someone told you some random fact, and you said "I don't care" That means you care, because you replied to them?

Yeah that makes sense.

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 28, 2007

Why is there so much tension

user_name · Dec 28, 2007

Blindman said:
E4All:
Brawl dominated the floor, SMG was there you know.
Super Smash Bros. (the original) was better than Super Mario 64 because of replayability. Melee was definitely better than Sunshine, but many games are better than Sunshine.

You have nothing to worry about, Brawl will be awesome considering Melee's production time was half Brawl's and we're still playing Melee! Brawl will last twice as long. That is (2 x 1/0[1/0 = infinity])... it will be a good game.

0/1 does not equal infinity. 0/1 is undefined. 0/1 * 2 = (0 *2) /1 = 0/1 = undefined. Undefined isn't infinity, as infinity is a real number, and undefined is imaginary.

I know that comment is from the first page, but I couldn't help myself, as it seemed nobody else picked up on this mistake.

The Director · Dec 28, 2007

Tobi- said:
ok is that really necessary? is that talking about galaxy vs brawl? No.

121 with both...

A lot of people posted Galaxy progress a couple pages back when the game first came out. I'm continuing their legacy.

LOLOLOLOLOL deal with it

Meta_Sonic64 · Dec 29, 2007

Yea, this thread went over board with game progress. lol

The Director · Dec 29, 2007

Meta_Sonic64 said:
Yea, this thread went over board with game progress. lol

Well since the game came out over a month ago there's been nothing to talk about except bicker about how Brawl's going to be so much better.

The Grand Finale Galaxy was nowhere near what it was cracked up to be.

tutter · Dec 29, 2007

Looks like I need to finish Galaxy in order to bicker with the others.

Brawl vs Galaxy vs MK Wii

Smash Master

Smash Lord

Smash Lord

Smash Lord

Smash Journeyman

Smash Journeyman

Smash Master

Old rivalries live on!

Smash Master

Smash Master

Smash Master

Smash Master

Smash Master

Smash Master

Smash Lord

Smash Ace

Smash Lord

Smash Master

Smash Journeyman

Smash Lord

Smash Master

Smash Lord

Smash Master

Smash Lord

Smash Master

Smash Journeyman

Smash Lord

Smash Lord

Smash Lord

Smash Ace

Smash Lord

Smash Ace

Smash Apprentice

Smash Ace

Smash Master

Smash Apprentice

Smash Lord

Smash Master

Smash Lord

Smash Apprentice

Information

Network