mariokart64n, I'm gonna TRY to be swift because these long posts we've all been making have been sorta taking up the thread. Let's try to wind this conversation down, and only bring up points if they're new.
Sony doesn't own their employees. They couldn't threaten him with a lawsuit for doing something in his free time. Anyway, Square Enix owns Chrono Trigger, not Nintendo or Sony.
Go to my last page and go to my link for legal help. If you think you know more about what a copyright covers than a lawyer, fine. Just know that courts go by what's actually written in law, not what you think *should* be law.
If you based a new model off Roy from Melee but it was DIFFERENT, you'd own the copyright to that work. Don't be ridiculous about two people by chance making identical models, the only way to do that would be to purposely copy the work. Copying by hand and copying automatically are still both copying. The courts wouldn't side with you, that's for sure. You can distribute anything about any character as long as the work is not copyrighted, just can't make money off it if you don't also own the intellectual properties.
SmashBoards would get in trouble because they're owned by the MLG. If the MLG ever hosts a tournament with a modded copy of Brawl, they'd be making money off illegally distributed copyrighted work. So yes, if you distribute it on your own message board, SmashBoards is unlikely to get in trouble now. But if the MLG hosts a tournament with a modded Brawl, they could get in trouble then. And if any tournament with a modded Brawl is advertised on SmashBoards, the same is true. Don't you want to see Roy in a national tournament? Isn't that a big part of what you're doing? Don't you want to see the best players do the most amazing things with your character?
Even if you lock the model and the only key is found on a Melee disc, you're still distributing it. It'd probably make Nintendo less likely to go after you, though.
Anyway the thing I don't understand is why people are going to all this trouble arguing with what IS THE LAW just to be lazy. Wouldn't you rather have a higher-quality model in your game anyway? And wouldn't you rather feel safe about it? And be able to see your work in tournaments?
Yes, that's why you can rip them and do whatever you want personally. You did not buy the right to redistribute the models, though.
Yes, precisely. As long as existing models are edited enough to not be similar.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Smile :) :)"
Very nice model there.