Well, great job outing the bulletproof. I'll post more later. -_-
Don't blame me for your gullibility. What good was there in revealing that you were bulletproof? You believed my daykill, and even went so far as to come up with an excuse as to why you "survived" it. Not my fault that you defended yourself when no one was even questioning you.
This makes it a lot easier for a protective role to be placed on the cop. What if the doc doesnt pic up the hints and doesnt protect the cop? Welll the cop will probably die.
Yes, cops always run the risk of being nightkilled, but it's worth it. What if the doc dies? More likely, what if the cop doesn't find any mafia? What if the cop investigates a bunch of people who die during the night?
When cops reveal, the town "huddles" around them way too often, and just expect everything to go fine until the doc dies, or the cop has disappointing results. However, it seems that people often forget about everything that could go wrong. A pro-town roleblocker may not believe the cop claim and target the "cop" at night, and a mafia roleblocker definitely would.
Besides, I think the cops are relied on way too much in these small games. Every townie is capable of finding mafia by themselves. Not to say that they shouldn't be used, but not all hope is lost if they die or are useless.
Marshigo: I'm inclined to lynch you just for that whole daykill bit. A general rule of thumb is that townspeople shouldn't lie. Ever. There's no reason for it, even if it did get the ball rolling.
I'm aware of the lynch all liars mentality, and I think it's silly. Does anyone actually believe that I would get away with that? It'd be impossible, so I see no problem. It has helped activity, something this game needed, and still does from players that haven't posted too much. Yeah, I probably could've come up with a "safer" way of doing it, but this still worked, and was fun.
Once I played a game where someone claimed plain old townie. I cast the final vote because I thought the odds were better for town with her lynch (Actually, I was scum, but that's beside the point). When the death scene came up, it showed her as the doc. Naturally, I and everyone else were surprised at this. My only reservation is that I'm kind of suspicious of Mccloud.
I know where you're coming from, but you're writing me off too quick. I don't plan on using fake day actions to generate discussion, since it won't work after the first time.
Just to screw with the entire town eh? You have to understand how flimsy that argument is
Pythag, why else would I do it?
There's a difference between lurking and stating that Day 1s starts are generally useless.
So either you don't post because "Day 1s are useless", or you post saying that? Neither are helpful. Someone being active isn't a reason to keep them around, if that's what you're getting at.
And for all my clamor, it seems that someone noticed. After all, we didn't start on a Day 1. So I must have some form of merit, or Tom's just humoring me cause he's a good friend of mine. Or both. Regardless, This game didn't start on Day 1, which is significant, I feel.
What? A moderator starting a game on Day 1 proves that you're right about Day 1s being useless? It doesn't matter how many games are started on Day 1 or Night 1, neither prove the other side wrong. The whole argument is boring though, whether you like it or not, there's going to be a Day 1, so you might as well help.
Whoever's cop can investigate me tonight if they are so inclined.
Did you read Red Alloy's post? Mafia godfathers often appear innocent during cop investigations. It wouldn't do any good.
So not only does McCloud do anything until mid/late game so no one can touch him, he claims to be a bodyguard so no one gets at him during night. Depending on what other people have to say about this, I might vote him to find out if he's lying or not.
Anyway, everyone saying that the lynch is going to come down to me or McCloud is crap. There are a good number people that haven't posted about this, which they should so we can get on with this.
