The Ultimate Brawl Character Selection

[Phantom7]

This should be the Brawl character selection.

Chars. from melee you start with:

Mario
DK
Link
Samus (Final Smash turns into Zero Suit Samus)
Yoshi
Kirby
Fox
Pikachu
Peach
Bowser
Ice Climbers
Zelda (Down B turns into Sheik)
Ness
Captain Falcon
Luigi
Jigglypuff
Mewtwo

Chars. from melee you unlock:

Ganondorf (Different moveset)
Young Link (Different Moveset)
Falco (Different moveset)
Roy
Mr. Game & Watch

Newcomers you start out with:

Wario
Pit
Meta Knight
Snake
Diddy Kong
Ike (Replace Marth)
King Boo (Replace Dr. Mario)

Newcomers you unlock:

Pokemon Trainer (Replace Pichu)
Waluigi (Mario)
Bowser Jr. (Mario)
Sonic (Sonic)
Wolf O'Donnell (Star Fox)
Zant (The Legend of Zelda)
Ridley (Metroid)
Charade (Soul Calibur)
King Dedede (Kirby)
Deathborn (F-Zero)
Mega Man (Mega Man)

This will equal 40 characters. You will start with 24 and unlock 16.

 

[Noshiee]

I swear ive seen a thread about this, lots of them, did you searched right?
and for the record, I think is more possible for roy to be remplaced instead for marth, also I doubt Dr. Mario is coming back, just my opinion

 

[OmegaXXII]

there's already a thread about this:

 

[skullkidd]

Yeah, there are a bunch of these.
And your's is probably the worst...nothing personal.
Roy over Marth??

 

[Phantom7]

there's already a thread about this:

Yeah, there are a bunch of these.
And your's is probably the worst...nothing personal.
Roy over Marth??

i wanna see you come up with something better. and uh.. yeah roy over marth. theyre like almost the same and roys been in more games than marth. and hes newer. plus the fire sword is a heck of alot cooler than the dolphin sword

 

[Phantom7]

I swear ive seen a thread about this, lots of them, did you searched right?
and for the record, I think is more possible for roy to be remplaced instead for marth, also I doubt Dr. Mario is coming back, just my opinion

uh... it doesn't say Dr. Mario's returning. u might wanna check again.

 

[Shuma]

Uhh... you have Roy.. Waluigi... and Zant... and Darkrai? who the **** is Darkrai? isn't that a Pokemon?

Also, King Boo? WTF?

 

[Kirby knight]

Eww Waluigi...that alone makes your whole list pathetic.

Roy over Marth? Please...don't tell me you think that just because they both have blue hair= same sword fighting style.

 

[Noshiee]

o srry I got confused with the king boo thing..o yeah, king boo? WTF? lol

 

[ness4life]

mods, please close this pitifull excuse for a thread. please.

 

[SantaClaus]

you guys are very closed minded and bitter. jesus.

 

[Bassoonist]

Can't say that's the "ultimate" character list.

I would be disappointed, especially with Waluigi. Meh.

 

[pokemega32]

i wanna see you come up with something better. and uh.. yeah roy over marth. theyre like almost the same and roys been in more games than marth. and hes newer. plus the fire sword is a heck of alot cooler than the dolphin sword

What games have you been playing?

Marth's been in two games, Roy's been in one...

 

[RyuDragonKing]

At least he has Riiiidddllleeeeeeyyyy....

 

[IllidR]

Horrible character list. Young Link, Roy, Waluigi, King Boo? bah...

 

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

Young Link < WWLink
Darkrai < Giovanni (Boss) Darkrai should be just a pokemon if anything else.
Black Knight or Lyn > Roy
zant and King Boo should be bosses or AT's.
Waluigi as an AT.

Besides that, I applaud your inclusion of Bowser Jr, Wolf O' Donnell, King Dedede, and Ridley.

 

[Phantom7]

Horrible character list. Young Link, Roy, Waluigi, King Boo? bah...

What's wrong with king boo? and waluigi? and i said y link could have a different moveset. i dont see what u have against roy. whats the difference from him and marth? if its the same fighting style why do u care? plus the fire sword is cooler than the dolphin sword. i mean cmon "dolphin" sword? just compare that 2 a "fire" sword. which sounds better? im pretty sure this is gonna b close 2 brawl anyway. and it sounds like ur focusing on all the characters u dont like. i mean what about zant ridley sonic theyd make awesome chars wouldnt they?

 

[Phantom7]

o srry I got confused with the king boo thing..o yeah, king boo? WTF? lol

dude u r so ********. i did say dr. mario but i changed 2 king boo! i cant believe u fell 4 that!

 

[Kirby knight]

What's wrong with king boo? and waluigi? and i said y link could have a different moveset. i dont see what u have against roy. whats the difference from him and marth? if its the same fighting style why do u care? plus the fire sword is cooler than the dolphin sword. i mean cmon "dolphin" sword? just compare that 2 a "fire" sword. which sounds better? im pretty sure this is gonna b close 2 brawl anyway. and it sounds like ur focusing on all the characters u dont like. i mean what about zant ridley sonic theyd make awesome chars wouldnt they?

Lol, Waluigi is the dumbest character suggestion. Tell me one game Waluigi hasn't appeared as a filler character.

 

[Phantom7]

you guys are very closed minded and bitter. jesus.

Thank you.

 

[IllidR]

What's wrong with king boo? and waluigi? and i said y link could have a different moveset. i dont see what u have against roy. whats the difference from him and marth? if its the same fighting style why do u care? plus the fire sword is cooler than the dolphin sword. i mean cmon "dolphin" sword? just compare that 2 a "fire" sword. which sounds better? im pretty sure this is gonna b close 2 brawl anyway. and it sounds like ur focusing on all the characters u dont like. i mean what about zant ridley sonic theyd make awesome chars wouldnt they?

King Boo- A not so important character in the Mario series, little appearances in the Mario sports games but he's not worth adding another character for and wasting a character slot.

Waluigi- Same as King Boo. The lamer of the brothers.

Roy- There is no difference between him and Marth, that's the problem. He's a blatant clone who I don't think can be fixed. He was only used to promote the new Fire Emblem game so his time has come to step aside and let Smashbros continue.

 

[Vali]

I think the thread creator needs to look up the definition of "Ultimate".

 

[Kirby knight]

I'd almost rather see Birdo playable than Waluigi -_-

 

[Deleted member]

Everyone has ideas of what would make a good game. Obviously, not all our suggestions will get in.

I personally hated PT when I saw him, but I'm warming up to him fast. Not least because we get 3-in-1.

 

[Willz]

Your list is okay in parts, but alot of it is flawed by stupid charcters.
King mofo'in Boo!!??
Roy over Marth!!??
WaLuigi!!?? (I actually like playing him in games like Mario Party and Mario Strikers but no way in hell does he suit the fighting formatt tbh)
Zant!!??

On another note you should keep characters that are usually unlockable (eg. Luigi & Jiggly),
UNLOCKABLE!!!

Fortunately, you but Sonic, Ridley, DeDeDe and others in.

Argh!! I rate this "Ultimate" List of Brawlers 5/10!

 

[McFox]

A character list that both includes Waluigi and does NOT include Geno automatically sucks.

Sorry.