^^^ I still think Mega Man easily fits in the best. He just looks, feels, and plays like a truly classic Nintendo character.
I was ridiculously liberal with my choices, but here I go...[Collapse="My choices:"]-Every character that was playable in Brawl
-Paper Mario
-Kamek: Yes, this is something of a cult/nostalgia choice that I know has little to no shot at being playable!
-Cranky Kong: I think he'd make a great "WTF?" character. Plus he is the ORIGINAL Donkey Kong.
-Dixie Kong
-Lanky Kong: He is my "guilty pleasure" choice, because I absolutely loved him in Donkey Kong 64.
-Mewtwo: Both appearances are preferable (see: Wario for how to do this almost entirely correctly).
-Pichu: Now with a new moveset and epic playstyle (or so I hope!).
-Plusle and Minun: They both would make great "opposites" (ie: one has the forward smash as a kill move, the other has it as a damaging move).
-A 6th Generation Pokémon
-Ridley: My most wanted Nintendo-owned character.
-Samurai Goroh
-Roy: With a new moveset, some new rags, and maybe an Eliwood look-alike costume!
-Chrom
-Hector: DAT AXE IS BOSS!!!
-Paula: I would really want a totally magic-reliant character in smash, and Paula fits that billing as good or better than anyone else I can think of.
-The Balloon Fighter
-Isaac: Earth-based magic would be BOSS in smash bros!
-Little Mac: I love fight sports and cartoony-ness, and quite frankly, I could see Little Mac being a perfect marriage of the two.
-Mach Rider: A dude who could literally fight by riding on a bike with freaking guns. What is there not to love=???
-Mii's: I got a sweet spot for them. Plus, you could play as anyone if they are playable!!!
-Saki: Awesome weapon? Check. Stupid name? Check. Great potential? Definitely.
-Shulk: Along with/after a new-ish Pokémon, he is the most likely recently created character to be playable in smash bros.
-Starfy
-Sukapon: It would be a nice touch to see the original Nintendo fighter playable.
-Takamaru
-Banjo & Kazooie: This is not gonna happen unless Nintendo buys the rights to Banjo back from Rare and Microsoft, but still, a man can dream!
-Bomberman: I grew up with his games and I love them.
-Castlevania character: Specifically Simon Belmont, who would be awesome in anything as a playable character.
-Conker: He is in the same situation as Banjo sadly.
-Crono: Chrono Trigger = one of the best games of all-time, and Crono would fit right in with the best of the best.
-A Dragon Quest character: I don't know why, but the idea of a Dragon Quest character in Smash Bros. is pretty exciting.
-Mega Man: My #1 most wanted playable character in Smash who has yet to be playable, and my #1 most wanted character who wasn't in Brawl.
-Travis Touchdown: I just see him being too awesome potentially not to select him.
-Pac-Man: I see Miyamoto making a great character here.
-Rayman: I grew up with Rayman, so I got a sweet spot for him.
-Tales series character (specifically Lloyd Irving): Whether with one or two swords he would make a freaking fantastic playable character in any fighting game franchise, let alone smash bros.
-Super Mario RPG characters (specifically Mallow and Geno): Mallow would be an okay character with his variant attacks, but Geno would be an incredible magic-centered character in smash.
-A 2nd Sonic character (specifically Knuckles, Tails, and Dr. Eggman): Knuckles would be so freaking awesome in Smash. Tails IMO would be a nice new style for Smash, and Dr. Eggman could be a randomaniac in smash.
78 choices, technically 81 since I had multiple characters I wanted with my last two picks. That's a lot of characters I want! Embarrass[/Collapse][COLLAPSE="Stage choices"]-
-I'll just go ahead and say I picked every stage that's been in Smash thus far (because I think even the bad stages can be fixed, or they can be fun to play on and they are easy to port).
-Good Egg Galaxy
-Comet Observatory
-NEW Mushroom Kingdom
-Airship: I've wanted to play on this as a stage in smash bros FOREVER!!!
-Bowser's Castle: Ditto on the last point.
-Rainbow Road: Any version will do (although I was disappointed by the lack of Wario Stadium from Mario Kart 64).
-Castle Bleck
-Battle Stage (Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door): That would make such a fun setting!
-Rougeport: I freaking love this place and this game!
-The Glitz (Pit): Freaking awesome place. That part of that game was one of my favorite parts in any game ever.
-Cloud World
-Emerald Island
-Virtual Boy Wario Land
-Sunset Shores
-Gangplank Galleon: I've freaking wanted this stage in Smash since like 2000.
-Jungle Hi-jinx: As tired as I am of Jungle DKC stages, I would love to see this one.
-Bramble Scramble
-Frantic Factory: This stage had so many awesome things to it IMO. I also think this would be a great "mine level" stage.
-Creepy Castle: IMO it is a perfect setting for a stage, and it really has a unique atmosphere.
-Angry Aztec: Probably my favorite DK 64 area, so this is a given. Those cool temple areas ranged from wicked cool to SCARY as a kid!!! (nostalgia overload!!!)
-Skyloft
-Hyrule Castle - Interior: Because that area in Twilight Princess and especially A Link to the Past was AWESOME!!! With ALTTP 2 coming out soon, the stars are finally aligning on this stage!
-Dragon Roost Island: With all the cool things here, how could this be a bad stage=???
-The Temple of Time: It's just too nostalgic for me not to pick.
-Ganon's Tower: Ditto, especially since we got many awesome versions of this location.
-Koroki Village: That sea of trees, those eternal kids, and those two memorable songs... THE NOSTALGIA!!!
-Clock Tower: This stage would be amazing.
-Death Mountain: Whether the ALTTP, Ocarina of Time, or Twilight Princess version, I would love it. Something about being on top of the world is special.
-Kakiroki Village: Whether the ALTTP or Ocarina of Time version, this place is awesome.
-Skytown Elysia
-Phendra Drifts
-Tallon IV
-Crateria
-Cookie Country: I just love this place and its' songs!
-Mt. Dedede: Just so awesome and nostalgic.
-Luminose City: It just gives off such a cool feel.
-Battle Subway: Something about Subway fights sounds awesome.
-Castelia City: I love huge city Pokémon stage ideas, especially after how awesome Saffron City was.
-Dragonspiral Tower
-Unova Victory Road: It and the area around it are so fun to visit!
-Pokémon Stadium 3: Imagine it as the biggest soccer/football stadiums in the world, in full HD!!! IT WOULD BE GLORIOUS!!!
-Pokémon Colosseum: Ditto as the last point, but with a more distinct GameCube-era Pokémon feel.
-Meteor Falls: This area could just look so good in HD! It makes me sad we never got a 3rd Generation Pokémon remake or even a revisit to Hoenn!
-Tin Tower: I just love this area, so I couldn't resist. I'd prefer the Burnt Tower personally, but having Ho-oh is a huge plus IMO.
-Pallet Town: There's just too much nostalgia here!!!
-The S.S. Anne: Because "FIGHTING GAMES ON CRUISE LINERS!!!" should be the next "CARD GAMES ON MOTORCYCLES!!!"
-Macbeth: I've wanted this as a stage since like 1999.
-Zoness: I love the battle here and the level design so sure, why not=???
-Area 6: Such a fun level in Star Fox 64.
-Sand Ocean
-Fire Field
-Mount Prism: It looks cool.
-The Arena
-Dragon's Gate
-Fields (Fire Emblem 7): NOSTALGIA!!!
-Crimea Caste Yard
-Saturn Valley: An awesome and unique place with a freaking killer tune!
-Magicent: An awesome area in the original MOTHER that's freaking cool as cool can be.
-Threed: The city has freaking zombies! ZOMBIES!!! IT'S AWESOME!!! It also has cool caves and awesome buildings.
-Tazmily Village: Just a cool area and it would be a nice place for a battle.
-The Underworld (Kid Icarus): Such a cool area that would be awesome to play on!
-Bulbax Kingdom: Freaking so much potential for greatness.
-A new Smashville: Because more of an awesome idea is never a bad thing!
-Game and Watch Gallery: It would be much better than Flat Zone.
-WuHu Island
-Guar Plains: In full 1080p this area would look like a freaking masterpiece.
-Warzone (Advance Wars): Because this franchise is freaking awesome.
-Punch Out Ring: Because nothing beats the spectacle of a ring surrounds by screaming fans (other than a cage of some sorts).
-Murasame Castle: It has lots of cool areas.
-Apollo Sanctum: Not my first choice for a Golden Sun stage area, but it would be pretty sweet.
-Venus Lighthouse: The ideal Golden Sun stage.
-Urban Ruins (Sin & Punishment: Star Successor): Because it is a ruins stage, and I like those ideas.
-Puffpuff Palace
-Orange Star Headquarters: THE NOSTALGIA!!!
-Panel de Pon
-Dolphin Park: Because this area was freaking rad and this game was freaking rad.
-Wild West: Because it's an awesome setting for anything.
-Balloon Land: Because I love the stage layout(s) in the actual game and it would be awesome if we got an epic 8-bit stage like this.
-Highway (Mach Rider): Because I imagine Sakurai could make this into an inspired stage.
-Nintendo Land
-Sim City: Because I love this franchise.
-Swapnote: Just because it seems like a good idea.
-Nintendo 3DS: Because it's in... *gasp* THREE-DEEH!!!
-Tetris: If you don't want this stage, please, disappear.
-Casino Night Zone
-Sky Sanctuary: I've wanted this stage as a second Sonic stage forever.
-City Escape: It's just too perfect of an area.
-The Jungle (MGS3): I freaking love the whole setting of this place.
-Outer Haven: Two freaking giant warships in HD filled with Metal Gears? THAT'S AWESOME!!!
-Smithy Castle
-Forrest Maze: Because it's an awesome maze area with cool enemies.
-Dr. Wily's Fortress: Such a classic location.
-The Robot (Master) Museum): Just because of all the Mega Man history.
-Central Highway: Just a classic area.
-The Airship (Final Fantasy): NOSTALGIA! MY EMOTIONS!!!
-Alefgard: Because it's awesome.
-The End of Time (Chrono Trigger): Because it's only the beginning.
-Zenan Bridge: I freaking love everything about this place.
-Spiral Mountain: My childhood... but the current Rare and Microsoft destroyed IT!!! THE HURTS!!!
-Grunty Industries: Such an underrated level.
-Windy: Anything from Conker's Bad Fur Day in smash I approve of.
-China: Just because the setting is freaking awesome.
-Dracula's Castle: I'd prefer the Brawl mod Castle, but anything Castlevania I'll take.
-Bomb Area: So classic.
-Pac Land: You know you got that song in your head right now.
-Ancient Citadel (Soul Calibur): Such a great freaking level.[/COLLAPSE][COLLAPSE="Assist Trophy characters"]-Everything in Brawl (except the ones I chose to be playable)
-E. Gadd
-Hammer Bro
-Lakitu
-Rosalina
-Captain Syrup
-Animal Buddy (DKC): This would be the greatest thing ever.
-Funky Kong: I love this dude.
-Vatti: I just think it's a great role for him.
-Princess Fluff
-Pico
-Kumatora: Especially if she has her sass ready!
-Micaiah
-The Eggplant Wizard
-Magnus (Kid Icarus)
-Jenna (Golden Sun): She's one of my favorite Golden Sun character, and she'd make a great Assist Trophy character.
-Chib Robo
-Dillon
-Doshin the Giant
-Lip (Panel de Pon)
-Muddy Mole
-Nintendogs + Cats: I Know Nintendogs was an AT in Brawl, but I added this because of the Cats.
-T. Rex (Fossil Fighters)
-Raiden: Ninja Form please.
-Black Bomber
-The Grim Reaper (Castlevania): How is that not awesome=???
-Protoman: Such a BAMF.
-Roll: Could give you cool weapons and stuffs!
-Nemesis: Because he's a freaking psychopath BAMF!
-Mumbo Jumbo
-Pac-Man Ghosts
-Moogle[/COLLAPSE][COLLAPSE="Bosses"]-Every boss in Brawl that I didn't vote as a playable character (which is only Ridley)
-King Boo
-The Koopalings
-Wart
-The Shake King
-Phantom Ganon
-Zant
-Marx
-Nightmare
-Darkrai
-Kraid
-Andross: He'd be great as a boss as well as his previous Assist Trophy form.
-The Black Knight: If you oppose this (other than the Black Knight being playable) then you absolutely suck.
-Deathborn
-Fusion Dragon: Just an EPIC BOSS!!!
-King Hippo
-Medusa
-Metal Face
-Queen Bulbax
-Metal Gear REX: C'mon, this would be freaking incredible, especially if Liquid Snake/Ocelot drove it. This would also make a great Final Smash for Snake!
-M. Bison: YES YES!!!
-Dracula (Castlevania): Because Castlevania bosses are amazing!
-Smithy (Super Mario RPG): It was an epic boss fight, so I can't imagine it going wrong in Smash Bros.
-Gruntilda: Because that was freaking one of the coolest boss fights ever in Banjo-Kazooie!!![/COLLAPSE]