DarkAuraful
should be getting you at least better results when it comes to the difficulties you mentioned compared to Lucina if you switch to a more patient playstyle (you're definitely forced to approach more with Lucina), zoning with neutral special and spacing with powerful long-range tippers (which I believe also help a great deal with Luma). Against really aggressive foes, that counter may have been nerfed a bit, but it's still a life saver, and even works great off-stage.
Still, if you want to try someone else,
is pretty great with the ground game bit, and I'd recommend you try working with him in particular since you seem to like sword users?
The Legendary DJXYZ
Cool, huh?
I'm still surprised by how few people know of these things. Kojii and some of the others have been trying to get more organized with our tech so that we have a central location for people to learn this stuff instead of everything being spread out, and it was also a help that the Beefy Smash Doods gave us a shout-out and explained a few rest set-ups as well. Still, not many are going to want to deal with all the downsides of using Jiggs to learn this stuff, and other Youtubers like Ace continually spread false information because they're apparently not interested enough to get the facts, so I don't think many more are going to work at the character for now. Most of us who still main Jiggs did so from day one...
@bubbyq12 You say you're not a technical player, yet... Most of those are pretty technical (especially if
's controversial combos get toned down). I'd suggest working more on
; most of the moveset is pretty straight-forward, and while there's definitely some technical stuff to learn/think about, it's not as much as you'd be facing with your other choices. Worry about getting bored with Corrin if/when you actually get to that point, because for the moment you have fun with them, so it shouldn't be a problem.
@FasdfGfaha Try playing around with
some more; I feel like he fits what you need, and since you (correct me if I'm wrong) like him as a character, that definitely helps!
could also be a good one to consider out of the character you tend to enjoy, but as
already has a lot of technical stuff involved with his moveset, Cloud may prove to be somewhat of a relief or needed break when you feel like you need one.
Nice_FZPSC.42
As DJXYZ already said, Bidou is best for those who are new to the game, because the set-up is sooooo completely different from what most of us know. And yeah, we could learn Bidou and change our muscle memory to be accustomed to the set-up, sure, but what if we wind up wanting to move on to the next Smash at some point, and Bidou is no longer an option? Or what if (I'm not saying this will happen, but just something for consideration...) the Smash team suddenly decided to somehow disable Bidou from being possible in the current game? That's an awful lot of work to go through for something that hasn't yet shown real results in tournament play and isn't guaranteed to last... I don't personally plan on bothering, but will just keep trying to improve the tech involved with a more traditional set-up.
To answer your second question: Personally, I'd say
and
would probably benefit the most from Bidou out of your choices.