Here is some sets of Cosmo a Melee Roy player which is extraordinarily rare nowadays so it's good to see even some Melee players support the the character.
Great fundamentals and his Roy has a lot of potential. He seems to know the Marth MU pretty well. That foundation can definitely be built on, though, and he can certainly improve on his punish game and a large portion of his movement, he has some blindspots and weaknesses that really need to be ironed out. He does a lot of absolutely important things right that almost no Roys out there get, like fair/uair juggle/bair use, fair to fsmash, beating cc'ing early on with DED and grabs, recovery, Roy's tech chases, Roy's grab while the other character is landing, lightshield on platforms to be safe and near the edge vs. Marth for the Marthslayer, edgeguarding Marth, and he's proving some of my theories to be correct from more than one standpoint.
That being said, the Marth picked some of the absolute worst options (especially with DI) in the Roy MU and could have played around the Roy's blindspots and weaknesses better, especially if he did more with some of his punishes and repeated his more successful punishes.
Looks like Roy is coming soon... I'm excited about how he will arrived to Smash 4... moveset, voice, Smash Final... Everything that can change or put in Roy.
Well... That makes me wonder ... After Roy with the "Fighter Ballot"... they will put another character from Fire Emblem? How likely is this to happen? And if possible ... What are considered possible candidates?
It seems like Lyndis, Micaiah, Tiki, and Anna are the most supported characters besides Roy and the only likely picks. I'd say Chrom but we already have two Awakening characters and he was given a disconfirmation interview, but Sakurai says a lot of stuff and he could be made unique if they really wanted to make him DLC. Plus he is requested a ton and there was a huge following for him pre-release, similar to Roy dropping from just below Mewtwo to top 5 in Japan. Some people say Hector and Ephraim but they're very overrated characters by a small niche of western fans, they aren't very popular in Japan, they have backseat roles to Eliwood, Lyndis, and Eirika who aren't playable in Smash, and I've never seen organized Smash support posts or threads for them anywhere, just people saying "why aren't they in smash when we have too many swordsmen?" or "why want Roy when you could want one of these unique guys?" or such. I've seen some Black Knight and Zephiel support, but it's very little and I think there's much better and more significant villain candidates for the roster like K. Rool and Wolf, and I'm not too keen on Fire Emblem villains joining Smash. I've seen Joshua, but no, just no, he isn't a very significant character, he's from a game I never saw as important or a large impact to Fire Emblem, and I'd rather have Lyndis use some of whatever a myrmidon-esque character would have. Just my two cents.
Keep in mind this does not reflect who I would pick for Smash, just likely candidates:
1: Micaiah (light magic is heavily unexplored and could make an entirely unique movest, but I'm not sure how popular or supported she actually is)
2: Tiki (not a lord, manakate stuff may impose 3DS hardware issues and limit ideas and creativity for her)
3: Lyndis (already has an assist trophy)
4: Anna (never has been a unique fighter even in Fire Emblem, she just takes a generic class when she finally does fight in Awakening, Robin already uses a Levin Sword, I don't see why people really want/like her or see her as a significant character besides appearing in a lot of Fire Emblems as a merchant which doesn't mean much. At least I did my research on Roy to justify why people would want him and why he's a great character. I don't recall any quotes or necessarily anything important from Anna that made her stand out much to me as a character, but she does have a unique personality)
5: Someone from Jugdral (IS hates Jugdral as evidenced by Sigurd being left out for FE:A DLC and a complete abscence of Jugdral characters in the SMT x FE trailer) or Chrom (disconfirmed and we have two Awakening reps but he has been and is still widely requested)
Never happening: Ephraim, Hector, Joshua from The Sacred Stones which I've seen asked about a few times.
My wants are Eliwood, Leif, and Levin, but I have no hope in them happening and I don't think they'd be good or smart picks for Smash. I do however support the idea of Micaiah, Tiki, and Lyndis, but they have a fair amount of obstacles at first glance and I'm too focused on Roy to think much more about them. No matter who gets in as Fire Emblem DLC, though, I'll be hyped for them.