info regarding latest tier list
criticism, questions, ideas, are all welcome. I do post the tier lists, but its not entirely my call. I take what i currently have, make my own changes and then see what other players think. Lee, Taylor, Eet, etc give their comments, and 90% the time i see their logic and then agree to their changes. This latest update however has NOT been shared w/ other people for advice, so this is why i post it HERE for EVERYONE to give their ideas.
for the sake of debate and boredom, i'll defend some of the reasonings behind the recent changes.
Tier 1: Lee, Cyphus, John
Tier 2: Ricky, Taylor, Ray, Eet
Tier 3: Blaise, Flarefox, Mary, RSIA, Nicknyte
basically, i figured 3 tiers is best, cuz any more and it just becomes a big mess and less accurate and easily argued on tiny place movements and confusion as to where to draw a whole new tier.
Its NOT so much that Taylor has gotten worse, but moreso Ricky, Ray, and John have deffinately improved- Ricky (mario and fox) and Ray(sheik and half the low tiers), are deffinately to the skill level of Taylor, and John going even w/ Lee's Fox and my Falco has stepped up as well (while lee's sheik and my Doc usually win though, it prolly would be in his favor if we played on stages other than FD)
Starting in Tier 3, Blaise and Flarefox have both consistently placed high in tournaments and both taken rounds against players in Tier 2 and even 1. Flarefox's current affiliation w/ smash isn't entirely known, but assuming his skill was at least where he left off i think most would agree on his position.
i'm not sure if Mary has already retired or not, but from my experience against him, i found him really good. In the ****ty tournament we had at his apartment he brought me to my last stock a round. He has good tech, mindgames, and most importantly- his game is consistent, he doesn't seem to make horrible goofs..and when he did, he just moved on and didn't let it effect the rest of the match.
RSIA on the otherhand is very inconsistent, since sometimes he gets pwned and other times goes even with tier 2. Problem though is, how good is he now since he's been out of the game for a long time. One can only imagine he may have lagged behind, which is why i put Mary right above him, cuz at his best, i'd assume him a notch or 2 above.
Nicknyte, no matter what u say, is good now. He's improved alot and become alot smarter and more patient playing marth alot like John now. From me and lee's own last experience w/ him, we had many close matches w/ him, a few he won that i blame underestimation. NEVERTHELESS, that ****ing counts for something in my book! ;P
---
NOW as far as people left out that people think should be in Tier 3, i ask what have they done to equal the other Tier 3 players? I mean, i'm not an enlightened smash-oni, but i'm not stupid... i can tell when someone really threatens me in a match, and i can tell when i easily control the flow of battle and just sandbag til the win.
Dustin, Setsuma, Sudai, Sars, Audi, Everpower, etc, etc, etc are all good players but i think tier 3 has done something to at least separate them a tiny bit. The tier list doesn't say that Tier 4 can't beat tier 3.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm sure ANYONE in tier 4 can beat anyone in tier 3 in the right match, but they're consistency is simply put- not as good. And its w/out that consistency and "i don't know how to fight this character, i hate this level, zomg i messed up!!11" that Tier 3 seems to have a little more under control.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Setsuma, u deffinately donnot always perfrom so hot, amirite? look at the last tournament. I believe most people would know what i'm talking about when i say that you say "oh my god, i can't *insert smash term*!" pretty commonly in matches.
Using Nicknyte as in example: if he can get the job done w/ a character that has no technical difficulty, than all the more power to him. but i think good players can deffinately feel a difference off their oponents control and carelessness- and thats usually a safe judgement. and if those mistakes only happen when they're nervous/etc, than...well...that sounds like a pretty bad weakness that shouldn't be excused, u know?
AGAIN. The tier list is NEVER finalized. It aims to be improved and updated, so critism, ideas, comments, questions, insults, buttsex are all welcome!