The Edmonton Melee Power Ranking (updated: March 2010)

[x After Dawn x]

but david thinks he's bad at the marth matchup, and the fact that you also play carl means you should know him inside out as well. =/

 

[victra♥]

i think you're forgetting the fact that its carl.

yeah david said he's bad at the marth match up i'll give him that. He *****, and you got a point.

i guess i'll just stick with 7th or whatever

 

[Alphicans]

It's not like Carl is smarter than you dude. Like he's technically superior than probably everyone, but I don't find him exceptional at figuring people out, he's just as good as he should be. He knows match-ups better than you probably, but the fact that you play him a lot should mean you can at least take him down to 1 stock.

 

[victra♥]

It's not like Carl is smarter than you dude.

i stopped reading at this point.

 

[Alphicans]

Lol if that's what you think then I guess you're gonna get wrecked by him forever.

 

[victra♥]

its k. i wreck him in school so its fair.

 

[Stevo]

skool MM!

 

[FalseFalco]

It's true victor owns me at school, but luke I think your point is invalid:

Spoiler

zero to death tipper combo

Also I 4 stocked david with falco, just sayin :3 but he's got a cooler fox than me so we'll call it even

 

[Solaris1110]

I think victor should be above me, only cause i'm mega inconsistent.

..but that three way money match works too lol.

 

[Alphicans]

What point is invalid? I made several...

 

[victra♥]

I think victor should be above me, only cause i'm mega inconsistent.

..but that three way money match works too lol.

strong fighting <3

I think it should be jarrett, me and david in that order.
but like

ya it would be sexy fun times

remember that one time Matt got off and we made him like, 4th? lol. That's kind of why i'm iffy about moving david so far up so abruptly.

 

[Alphicans]

This is an update right? Like Victor, do you not understand how this works?

 

[victra♥]

k so like

we just take the top results from beatdown

remove calgary

and make that our new pr.

so something like

1.carl
2.mike
3.david
4.luke
5.victor
6.matt
7.sid
8.jarret
9.vincent
10.tyler

looks pretty good imo. i like basing it off of one tourney. should do it more often

 

[T-block]

make me 9th then imo lol

 

[victra♥]

oh ya i forgot about you.

you tied with vincent and tyler and i ran out of room lol

should make it top 11 imo

 

[Alphicans]

K Victor, don't even try to troll me here. Dan's placings are really stable so regardless of his poor placing he should still stay 3rd. I've been pretty stable as well so I should stay 4th. You, Jarret and Dragonz are all pretty random, but Dragonz did exceptionally well this time. Basing it off of what you think is foolish.

 

[victra♥]

so top 11?

y/n

 

[x After Dawn x]

first and foremost, vincent being 9th = LOL

you being 5th = lol

dan not being on there = lol

and if you're basing it off one tourney, that's kind of dumb. and if you are, then idk if I should be on there because I played REALLY badly that day.

edit: okay I'm glad you weren't being serious

 

[victra♥]

i was just trolling Luke Tyler.

For an actual legit list,
01. - FalseFalco
02. - MikeMonkey
03. - SuPeRbOoMfAn
04. - Alphicans
05. - Dragonz
06. - Solaris
07. - Victra
08. - Lemonlau
09. - Halcyon.Days
10. - Afterdawn

luke's list is the strongest imo. But yeah, like he said, its just about where david, jarrett and i should be placed in respect with each other

 

[x After Dawn x]

okay good thing you're not being serious lol

um your real list looks good to me. I think the hardest decision is dan over mike or mike over dan

 

[victra♥]

i'm pretty sure its mike over dan.

but it's pretty close

 

[x After Dawn x]

post da list already then? you're the dictator, victor!

 

[victra♥]

nah bro not yet.

carrrrrrrrrrrrrrl i wanna hear what you have to say

 

[SuPeRbOoM]

have you looked at mike and I's past tournament performances against each other? Let's take a look at september/november(I don't remember when it was) tournament. I lose to mike in winners then in losers finals I took the set to vs carl in finals.

december tournament: mike beats me in winners again, then I proceed to win a set off him in grand finals and take second set as well for the tournament(carl wasn't there).

This last tournament: I only vsed mike once this time in losers so I got le boot from tournament earlier than expected.

So do you guys see a pattern here?

 

[victra♥]

ya

i dunno.

could go either way.

what do you think dan? I can't tell if you're implying that you want to be above mike or not.

 

[Stevo]

E D I T

 

[Dragonz7]

Uhm, I agree with those saying I shouldn't be moved up so high. I personally don't think I'm anywhere near 5th. Maybe around 9th or 10th.

Last tournament was an absolute fluke. If I met victor, matt, Tyson, Levi or Luke in the brackets I would've placed way lower. I beat solaris because I straight out camped him. I can't win any other way. And like Carl said I got 4 stocked by his falco, then he went marth and did random f-smashes and gave me free grabs. If he stayed falco it would've been 3 straight 4 stocks probably lol. Oh and Victor definitely ***** me hands down.

But it's your call

 

[victra♥]

david is pretty modest and he *****.

your match vs jarrett was pretty funny lol.

 

[Alphicans]

Camping doesn't make your win unlegit, that's the match-up. Spacies **** eachother, **** happens, I am sure you could've made it a lot closer between his falco in other matches.

 

[victra♥]

luke's right david.

camping is pretty hard to do well in melee. If you mess up get wrecked

lol tyler.

you need to camp my falcon more david btw, especially when you were falco. i only get off when you don't camp.

 

[Dragonz7]

Lol I really don't want to resort to camping during matches. Play to win but I also want to play and have fun >.>. I guess my "aggresive" playstyle severely lacks good spacing and shield pressure for it to win any matches.

Yea my falco in general isn't too great, I'm filtering through a bunch of secondaries (shiek in December) but they aren't working out too well.

Also I really wanted another match against carls falco, I don't know why you switched. It really felt like you were taking it easy on me.

I'll just keep practicing, thanks for the advice on and off the tournament
/end rant

 

[FalseFalco]

I really like the marth fox matchup and don't like playing falco that much so I wanted to try it out. The only reason I stayed falco in the first place is because he was still hot from barely beating Dan. Besides I can't have you catching on to my falco can I . You played 5x better second match so to your credit I'd say you really bounced back from match 1.

Also I don't take it easy on anyone I just choke during seriouslies and **** during friendlies.

As for the Jarrett set, It seemed like he thought he could keep up with the fox camping with missles and such but fd is sooooo bad for samus in my opinion. Just ban that map Jarrett! Stage control is too hard to get back without platforms, samus is too slow to chase fox, blah blah blah

Luke's list looks good to me unless Dan has some input? I can't quite tell what you mean either Dan...

 

[SuPeRbOoM]

lol I'm saying mike and I are tied >_>

 

[victra♥]

someone needs to be above the other brother

 

[Alphicans]

Just make a decision. I wanna see an update lol.

 

[victra♥]

01. - FalseFalco
02. - MikeMonkey
03. - SuPeRbOoMfAn
04. - Alphicans
05. - Solaris
06. - Victra
07. - Dragonz
08. - Lemonlau
09. - Halcyon.Days
10. - Afterdawn
imoooooooooooooooooooooooo

 

[Alphicans]

:\\\\\\. Dragonz should at least be 6th then.

 

[victra♥]

kage beat mango twice in brackets

probs like 4th best in the world imo

 

[Alphicans]

Bring up the other results and lets see how much better you did than Dragonz.

 

[victra♥]

i can't.
i've only been to one other tourney with david.



lol