God, this thread is gonna break my heart. Xillia 2 is my favorite. Why you gotta do my boy dirty like that
While I wasn't really a fan of Xillia 2 due to its unbalanced combat gimmicks and general disregard for the established morality of the existing characters and franchise, my not wanting Ludger in Smash has nothing to do with that. I also wasn't that into Graces, after all, and still actively included Pascal as a potential want.
No, I simply don't see a 4-moveset character who's a silent blank slate for your choose your own adventure decisions having the same level of coherent gameplay style and personality as a more standard Tales protagonist.
eek @ me hating Xillia 2. I LOVED the first Xillia.
In regards to the earlier discussion of side characters, I'd love to see either Genis/Raine in the mix. (Or Sheena... summoning someone like Corinne idk) . For Genis/Rayne, I'd love to see them summon prism stars, and have them fly all over the screen. Kinda like Beedrill from the first smash.
From other tales games, I'd love to see Cheria (Graces), Arche (Phantasia), Anise (The Abyss), Mila (Xillia).
First Xillia I loved, too. Possibly even as much as Symphonia and Vesperia. I don't know why I forgot to add Milla to my list. Perhaps I just saw her as a secondary main or something, I'm not sure.
In terms of half-casters, Anise and, to a lesser degree, Tear could work well but I kinda want to see Tokunaga as a standalone fighter, rather than a vehicle.
Genis and Raine are a bit less feasible, IMO, being full-casters with next to no melee and a heavy reliance on incantation times. Yet that might be a tad hypocritical of me, as the guy who made an Arche moveset. Either way, though, Genis with Prism Stars is a pipe dream. A spell that big would have to be a Final Smash and his would be almost guaranteed to be Indignation Judgement.
Cheria I straight up don't remember as a fighter but Sheena brings a lot to the table as either a trainer or an assist user. As a trainer, she'd play host to three summons like our pre-existing Kanto guy, with Celsius, Efreet and maybe Volt. All of which could represent their various incarnations across the series, rather than just ToS. But trainer Sheena would be a waste, IMO, when you could have Keele and Meredy both take it and represent their own worlds' spirits.
Assist user Sheena, however, gets to both slap people with cards and use them to backhand people with Efreet's Impact Hammer, while still having access to things like Grave, Freeze Lancer and Spark Wave or Cardinal Strike. She uses the summons to do many of her attacks for her, like how Zelda now uses her phantom armour.