Work In Progress SWF Community Voted Tier List - 3.0 COMPLETE

[A10theHero]

Wow, I feel like an idiot.
In that case, +1 Falcon, -1 Lucario, +1 Mario, +1 Luigi, Fox stays the same.

No worries! It's a fairly common mistake.
Oh, and welcome to Smashboards!

 

[sogeki]

Thank you so much!

 

[Smashoperatingbuddy123]

Orginal


Im going to go more apporate now

-1
+1
+0
+0
+1


Up to A tier


None downgraded to C




(Oh by the way Its spring 2015 as of tomorrow so can be released anyday at anytime. So we may need to start again when mewtwo is released.)

 

[A10theHero]

Orginal


Im going to go more apporate now

-1
+1
+1
+0
+2


Up to A tier


None downgraded to C

Umm, there is a problem with your selection.
-1 +1
This part is okay. It only means that they're switching positions.
+1
If Fox is getting a +1 as well, that means that he'll be passing Captain Falcon. So that's actually a -2 for him.
+0 +2
To have Mario get a +2, he'd have to pass both Luigi and Captain Falcon. That'd make Luigi have a -1 and Captain Falcon a -3. So your vote would look like this:

Since Captain Falcon moved more than 2 spaces, this doesn't follow the rules.

 

[Smashoperatingbuddy123]

Umm, there is a problem with your selection.
-1 +1
This part is okay. It only means that they're switching positions.
+1
If Fox is getting a +1 as well, that means that he'll be passing Captain Falcon. So that's actually a -2 for him.
+0 +2
To have Mario get a +2, he'd have to pass both Luigi and Captain Falcon. That'd make Luigi have a -1 and Captain Falcon a -3. So your vote would look like this:

Since Captain Falcon moved more than 2 spaces, this doesn't follow the rules.

You were saying?


(Edited post.)

 

[Tyranitarphantom]

Original:
New:

Lucario down a tier (really, he should drop further than C tier, but eh). Nobody rises.

 

[Equin0x]

I don't see a real difference, but alright.

New order:

 

[ミスティック Speed]

Orginal


Im going to go more apporate now

-1
+1
+0
+0
+1


Up to A tier


None downgraded to C




(Oh by the way Its spring 2015 as of tomorrow so can be released anyday at anytime. So we may need to start again when mewtwo is released.)

lol....Mewtwo is going to mess the WHOLE system up...
:3

 

[QuantumKiller]

No one up a tier
Lucario down a tier

 

[Sir Tundra]

No one up a tier
Lucario down a tier

You can't move lucario 3 spots bruh. You only have a maximum of 2 spot placements. I'd strongly advise you to change this if you want your vote to count

 

[Golden Rainbow]

Original:
Revised:

No one up or down.

 

[Planet God Venus]

yyo, is this your vote? because you can only do +2/-2s for a character, so falcon cant go -4 :/

Seriously I feel like a moderator at this point lol

does it have to be inaccurate because this is community voted...

 

[Mazdamaxsti]

does it have to be inaccurate because this is community voted...

Its community voted, and it will be inaccurate, but you can still only +2/-2, no +4s or -4s lol

 

[Capteon]

Original:
Revised:
Lucario and Luigi switch
No changes in tier

 

[CyberHyperPhoenix]

Original:
Revised:

Fox and Lucario switch.

Falcon move up a tier.

 

[Browny]

Updating... any posts after 10 minutes after this one are not counted so if you want to vote, get in quick!

Actually Im calling this early, this round is absolutely clear-cut on the placements With luigi getting a huge amount of +1 tier votes and the other characters all staying the same.

Next tier... S tier! Do we keep all 3 here, does diddy get his own tier?



There really is only 2 options in this vote, since Sonic is locked into this tier.

The question is, is diddy or sheik #1, and do they deserve their own spot in an S+ tier?

Vote by ordering those 3 characters, and also vote either yes, they stay in one tier or no, you want one of those characters to sit in an S+ tier. If a character gets more 'yes' votes to move up a tier than votes saying this tier should keep 3 in it, then they go up.

 

[Luigi#1]

No change at all.

 

[Alses]

Needs to get into an A+ tier by herself. She is not S tier like and due to how easy she is to punish when the person using her makes any mistake and Sheik is not good at taking punishment with how easy she is to launch.

So down, as down as it can go.
and are fine in S Tier. No changes there.

 

[ShortcutButton]

This is it, guys!



No change.

Also, is Mewtwo going in this list? I really think he shouldn't. I quote myself from A-Tier voting:

Putting Mewtwo in a tier list only after 2 weeks of it being playable is a really bad idea. We gave these characters 6 months for a community list, and yet some of them still havent found their place. If we vote on Mewtwo after just 2 weeks, we'll have about equal votes for every tier.

 

[Pud'N]

 

[Sir Tundra]

Original:

Vote: (no Change)

The S tier Should remain the same.

All three of these characters have more then proven why they're S tier. Diddy, Sheik, and Sonic have an extremely dangerous rushdown game, They can easily zone break alot of zoners with their mobility, can rack up damage quickly, barely have any weakness's, and all three characters have done extremely well in tournaments with all 3 of them getting top 5 in apex.

As of Diddy having his own tier? No he shouldn't, Diddy maybe the best character in the game but he's not broken like brawl metaknight. Sure he can easily control the stage and can rack up damage with his infamous HOO HAH that so many people just scream for a nerf. However Diddy can be easily gimped offstage, now against a really good diddy that maybe difficult to pull off, but it can be done if you know the diddy matchup.

 

[CyberHyperPhoenix]

Updating... any posts after 10 minutes after this one are not counted so if you want to vote, get in quick!

Actually Im calling this early, this round is absolutely clear-cut on the placements With luigi getting a huge amount of +1 tier votes and the other characters all staying the same.

Next tier... S tier! Do we keep all 3 here, does diddy get his own tier?



There really is only 2 options in this vote, since Sonic is locked into this tier.

The question is, is diddy or sheik #1, and do they deserve their own spot in an S+ tier?

Vote by ordering those 3 characters, and also vote either yes, they stay in one tier or no, you want one of those characters to sit in an S+ tier. If a character gets more 'yes' votes to move up a tier than votes saying this tier should keep 3 in it, then they go up.

I dunno.... I guess we should just leave it as it is tbh.

This is it, guys!



No change.

Also, is Mewtwo going in this list? I really think he shouldn't.

Mewtwo should be added to the list imo... especially if there are balance changes that come along with his update.

 

[Capteon]

No Change

 

[Hat N' Clogs]

No change. S is looking good.

 

[L9999]

S tier is fine as it is.

 

[Beef Tank]

No one up or down a tier.

 

[Drgoold]

My Vote:

 

[aquaticpineapples]

No S+ tier for Sheik, S is fine the way it is

Also, a suggestion: Next time, we should allow characters to move at least 3 or 4 positions within their tiers, as this time around with a maximum of just 2 positions, there werent many changes that were made

 

[Zerp]

No one up or down.

 

[A10theHero]

These guys are the strongest*, no doubt about it. And Diddy deserves the #1 spot. I feel that he's pretty powerful right now, and his Hoo Haas are annoying, but he's not deserving of his own tier. His playstyle made him rise to the top quickly because advanced play with him is easier to pick up than for most other characters. So there's a chance that he'll be dethroned, once everyone starts mastering their own characters. The meta is still young, and I believe that we'll eventually find a way to beat him.

Spoiler

* = Yes, they are the strongest right now...until the one true warrior, , takes his rightful place in the #1 spot! He's so good, that he'll have Brawl Meta Knight status! This'll happen once we figure out how to dominate with him, of course.

 

[NeepKing]

Original:

Mine: No one up or down a tier.

 

[Smashoperatingbuddy123]

Original



Now


(Sonic is 2+)


So easy

 

[Mazdamaxsti]

My vote:


Sheik to go down to A+, overrated.

S:
A+: (and the rest)

 

[Sir Tundra]

My vote:


I vote Diddy to go into his own tier, and Sheik to go down to A+.

S+:
S:
A+: (and the rest)

Is that allowed? :/

yes its allowed

 

[XinShot]

original:
vote:

def

 

[Tyranitarphantom]

Nobody needs to rise or fall a tier.

 

[Deleted member]

S
A+

I feel as if Sheik has to work a bit harder for the KO despite the pros Sheik has compared to Sonic and Diddy currently. Both Sonic and Diddy are pretty good, with Diddy being better imo.

 

[MapleWooD]

All good B O Y Z

 

[Wintermelon43]

Sheik in A+ Tier

 

[Diddy Kong]

If possible, lower Sonic a tier.