the only character who is like, definitely better than bayonetta is sheik. cloud, zero suit, and rosaluma are pretty close to her.
imo she's like #4, but it's still tentative because the character is so new and the other top tiers are close in terms of quality. the only character i have confidence in saying their spot in terms of top tiers is sheik.
no, it's really not that easy
it's like metaknight where you can di but it only works so well, bayonetta can react to di and her players will continue to get better at covering options. (b reverse witch twist is life)
That's not what the top level players have been experiencing and I haven't felt that either.
I mean sure, she can cover the DI sometimes, like other characters can, but that's situational, it depends on what moves have already been used. If she's already used her jumps and Up-B/Side-B's, she hasn't got a hope of covering DI, she's in the same boat as pretty much any other character there. She also isn't fast enough to still be able to chase people even after landing after a combo.
The general consensus is that with most of her moves, DI'ing down and away gets you out of most of what she can do, as most characters. That gets you out of range of Bayonetta's Side B, both the upward and downward version, even if she still has it, which is her main tool for covering DI. And Witch Twist goes straight up so that's no good at that point. She might be able to still cover it if she has a second jump but even then, the opponent can still air dodge whatever she has left most of the time.
That DI problem and the fact she's easy to punish, and the fact she hasn't got any reliable single move KO options unless she can get Witch Time in, is what ultimately balances her out and prevents her from being a stupidly over powered and brain dead character like a lot of people think she is.
Oh, and her roll is easily one of the worst in the game too. Doesn't mean as much in high level play but in intermediate level at least, that really hurts her. Bat Within SOMEWHAT helps but she would have been better off with a flat out better dodge since she still takes damage from Bat Within.