That more or less summarizes my feelings towards Awakening. Looking through the comments, Awakening is pretty much the Melee vs. Brawl of the series in more ways than one.
I hope Fates is an overall improvement, but it is still not a game that I want to directly support IS/Nintendo with my $ given what is currently known about it.
I don't think Awakening is a bad game per se
But rather a bad FE game
It's a good title for newcomers but
Some gameplay mechanics were either removed or simplified(mission objectives, no interactable map tiles outside of villages, etc), balancing is wonky(it really gave me the wrong impression about how strong magic really is), Light Magic is completely gone, classes lost some of their unique gimmicks(mounted units being able to move after using an item, Pegasus Knights not being able to triple attack, Thieves not being able to steal, etc) and the ****ing map design
As for the Story:
Too streamlined, Walhart's Arc is complete filler(though it's the best ganeplay wise ironically), most characters are too one-dimensional compared to previous ones(Gaius likes candy, that's it; Lon'qu is afraid of vaginas because of his Dark and Troubled Past, that's it; Sumia bakes pies and trips; Cordelia is perfect and not in the good way; Tharja is Trasha; Panne is a "Remember the new guy" because of her Taguel race; Chrom is basically Ike who was basically Hector but without the things that made him cool, etc), almost all the villains are the same and basically watered down versions of previous oness(Validar is evil for the evils like Nergal but without the simpathetic qualities he had, Aversa is Sonia but not hateable(in the good way) nor likeable, Walhart is probably based on a villain from a game I didn't play, Grima is Medeus and Gangrel is LITERALLY Ashnard)
Also, no characters but Chrom, Robin and Say'ri get special battle dialogue. Not even characters that just betrayed their commander
But it's not all bad though
The children characters are great and do not fall short like their parents
Inigo tries to act like a Chivarlous Pervert to hide his insecurities and someon who tries to motivate his friends so they don't fall into despair. This also fits as his mother is a Dancer who is basically a Bard if 7 is anything to go by.
Owain is a Stepford Smiler who, like Inigo, tries to motivate his friends by being always in a good mood
Severa has several issues that are a cause of her not thinking she would ever be able to live up to her perfect mother
Laurent is a perfectionist because he grewbup in a world where failing to notice the smallest details could mean death and had to spent about 5 years all alone in a desert village on a time he knew nothing about and that obviously didn't end good for his mental health
Female Morgan is probably the cutest thing to ever be created and I wanna protect her
The best maps are on the previously mentioned Walhart Arc
The Feroxi Port, BOAT MAPS, that tree with Tiki, the fort with the one single female boss not counting Aversa, A ****ING ERUPTING VOLCANO and its last map on Walhart's Castle are all well-designed in contrast to the rest of the game