Stage Tournament: Pokemon Stadium 2 Vs. PictoChat

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

Pokemon Stadium 2

Best: Wild Pokemon Battle! (Ruby / Sapphire)
Worst: Pokemon Gym / Evolution

 

[Raym]

Best: Wild Pokemon Battle! (Ruby / Sapphire)
Worst: Pokemon Gym / Evolution

 

[Shock the Hedgehog]

Best: Pokemon Center
Worst: Road to Viridian City

 

[KingK.Rool]

Best: Route 1/Viridian City (especially the Viridian City part)
- This song runs on pure nostalgia. Pokemon Red was pretty much one of the first video games I ever played.
Worst: Pokemon Center
- I just can't bring myself to like this remix. I know it's supposed to be fighting music, but still.

 

[Deleted member]

BEST: Wild Pokemon Battle! (Ruby/Sapphire)
WORST: Pokemon Gym/Evolution

 

[---]

Best: Wild Pokemon Battle! (Ruby/Sapphire)
Worst: Pokemon Gym/Evolution

I'd say the Pokemon Main Theme was the best, but compared to it in melee, it stinks.

 

[wWw Dazwa]

Best: Pokémon Main Theme
Worst: Pokémon Gym / Evolution

 

[ZMan]

Best: Pokemon Gym/Evolution
Worst: Main Theme (Melee's version is SO much better)

 

[Patinator]

Best: Wild Pokemon Battle! (Ruby and Sapphire).

It's a pretty good song, although I expected it to be more like it is in Pokemon Colosseum...

Worst: Pokemon Center/Route 1. Can't decide; they're both horrible picks.

 

[Brainiac_man]

Best: PKMN main theme
Worst: Road to Viridian City

 

[Linkplayer5678]

Best: Pokémon Gym / Evolution
Worst: Pokémon Main Theme

 

[distr0ia]

Best: Pokemon Main Theme
Worst: Road to Viridian City

 

[smashlink_aru]

Best: Pokémon Gym / Evolution
Worst: Road to Viridian City (From Pallet Town / Pewter City)

 

[Infamous Chimera]

Favorite: Road to Viridian City
Least Favorite: Pokemon Main Theme

 

[roy_owns]

You guys like to mix me up with these votes don't you?

Ok, Wild Pokemon Battle! (Ruby/Sapphire) has the most votes for best AND worst. So since their are more best votes for it...

Best... WILD POKEMON BATTLE (RUBY/SAPPHIRE)

But, for worst that would mean I would have to got to second worst because WPB. BUT THEIR WAS ANOTHER TIE!! Between Pokemon Gym/Evolution and Pokemon Center. First person to break the tie will decide.

 

[smashlink_aru]

I´ve already voted but I think pokemon center is worst

 

[Banjodorf]

I´ve already voted but I think pokemon center is worst

Man, how could anyone think Pokemon Center OR Gym/Evo to be the worst?

I voted, but the worst is totally Route 1, it's nice, but...doesnt fit a fighting scene in the least.

 

[smashlink_aru]

Man, how could anyone think Pokemon Center OR Gym/Evo to be the worst?

I voted, but the worst is totally Route 1, it's nice, but...doesnt fit a fighting scene in the least.

I know , I just chose between the two

 

[Banjodorf]

I know , I just chose between the two

Yeah, but in all seriousness, SOMEONE needs to break this tie so we can get on to Spear Pillar.. ALL GLORY TO VICTORY ROAD!!

 

[roy_owns]

Ok, it looks like I'm going to have to take smashlink_aru's vote so...

Worst... POKEMON CENTER

Today will be Spear Pillar. See first post for details.

 

[Banjodorf]

Right on.


Best: Victory Road. O.M.G.

Worst : Well, there is no worst here, so LEAST GOOD is Wild Pokemon Battle (Diamond and Pearl)

 

[MarthTrinity]

Best: Dialga/Palkia Battle

Worst: Route 209

 

[JNS]

best:victory road
worst: route 209

 

[smashlink_aru]

Best: Dialga / Palkia Battle at Spear Pillar! or Wild Pokémon Battle! (Diamond / Pearl) I really can´t decide
Worst: Route 209

 

[Ramgigon]

Yeah! I'm so glad Route 1 wasn't the best!
But Pokemon Center the worst? Rubbish!

Best: Dialga/Palkia Battle at Spear Pillar
Worst: Victory Road (Heard far too many times)

 

[half_silver28]

best - dialga/palkia battle
worst - diamond/pearl battle(doesn't stand out as much as the others)

although I like the song, I think route 209 is gonna lose because of the 'it doesn't fit' argument.

 

[Xebenkeck]

Best: Victory Road, best song in the game!!!!
Worst: Route 209

 

[OverlordCrono]

Best: Dialga/Palkia Battle at Spear Pillar!
Worst: Wild Pokémon Battle! (Diamond / Pearl)

 

[MetalMario75]

Best: Dialga/Palkia battle, fits the stage really well
Worst: Route 209, good music, but it doesnt go with the stage

 

[Demon Kirby]

best:victory road
worst: route 209

This is my vote, too.

 

[Browny]

What he said ^^

 

[Flatfeet]

Best: Dialga/Palkia Battle.

Worst: Route 209, sadly. It's great music, when I downloaded the soundtrack I loved it, I was seriously very surprised to find out that it played on Spear Pillar! Just doesn't fit at all, such a shame.

 

[Crystallion]

Dialga / Palkia Battle is the best, a close one is Team Galactic Battle.
The worst is IMO Wild Pokémon Battle, it just doesn't sound very good. I know that Route 209 doesn't fit, but at least it sounds good.

 

[thewiredknight]

Meh: Dialga Palkia battle for best I guess
Worst is Route 209

 

[Sockpuppet]

Best: Dialga/Palkia (my favourite song in the game!)
Worst: Wild Pokemon Battle (but it's still really good.)

 

[fortunArcanum]

BEST: Victory Road
WORST: Route 209

I love out of place songs but Route 209 is just so bland.

Anyway, this is directed to the topic creator, what method do you use to work out the overall best and worst? Is it merely a case of the songs with the most votes in either category or is it a scoring system? Personally, I would assign +1 point to every 'best' and -1 to every 'worst' and the song with the highest total wins but I am curious as to how you have done it.

 

[perpetual ownage]

Best: Route 209
Worst: Victory Road

 

[Andromeda]

Best: Dialga/Palkia Battle at Spear Pillar!
Worst: Route 209

 

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

Spear Pillar

Best: Victory Road
Worst: Route 209 (wrong stage for this BGM)

 

[Wtfwasthat]

Best: Team Galactic Battle

Worst: Victory Road