Stage Discussion Round #3: Castle Siege

[Tero.]

It's been quite a few days and it seems like discussions on Yoshi's Island and Llyat Cruise are dead, so I guess we should move on to the next stage, which would be:

Castle Siege discussion go.​

 

[Gmoney_]

I think that this is an obvious CP. So ill w8 with for others to post first

 

[Greward]

I would say CP because it gives big advantages to some characters. Anyways its not a bad stage.
The first transformation is ok for starter if alone.
The walk-offs on the second transformation are not a big issue since they dont last too much time. This transformation would be banned if it was alone.
The third stage is a final destination that tilts like lylat cruise(well, a little more). On my opinion it could be a starter if alone.
Oh, when the stage changes sometimes u can get traped down the "floor" (obviously is a bug) or going to grab someone when the stage finishs the change, then u have him grabbed on the air and u SD or one die because he's link. The stage changing can give some bugs. This is another reason to make it CP.

 

[Marcbri]

Obvius CP, it has walk-offs that are one of the criterias I have for banning stages, but since they are temporal the stage shouldn't be banned because of them. other things like irregular floor and the statues are really minor, so that's it: Cp mainly because of the temporal walk-offs.

 

[Staco]

You shouldnt forget that this stage gets walkoff edges for ~ 40% of the time.
But I think it should still stay CP since you can avoid getting chained out of the screen (platforms at the 2nd transformation are a safe place) and since there are CPs which have more gay things than this stage.

 

[Greward]

We had more participation on a private forum than on a public one rofl

 

[xDD-Master]

CP...

That's all I can say to it. Reasons have been already mentioned.

 

[Laem]

It doesnt seem like any1's gonna argue that this should be banned/neutral, not very suprising. So yeah, the only thing thats gay about this map is when dedede's in, causing the other chaingrabable character to flee for what, 33% of the time(i presume each stage lasts as long as the others?) But yeah, this kinda makes it a CP, not ban viable imo iyo.
One more thing: Staco, change ur sig, not all europeans are stupid XD (*** grano salis )

 

[xDD-Master]

33% of the time(i presume each stage lasts as long as the others?)

Dont forget the time between the stages

 

[Smasher89]

I´ve yet to see a character dominate on this stage, I would usually lean at CP for a transforming stage like this though.