-Villager was not top 5 lol. Tom Nook was way more popular in terms of an AC rep.
Villager was more requested than Tom Nook. Most reasonable people figured we'd get the Villager before Tom Nook, which had a big impact. Plus Villager is literally the playable character and central character, so it made more sense the Villager got in. After all, we got Mario before Peach, and Link before Zelda.
On top of that, a lot of supporters of one wanted the other and saw it as "one way or another" and were okay with this. I will say this to close, however: The Villager/Tom Nook fanbase largely being the same made it definitely an odd case, so I can see why anyone would disagree with my assessment on this. After all, the Tom Nook fanbase largely disappeared after the Villager was confirmed.
Top 5 was Mewtwo, Mega Man, Ridley, K. Rool and Little Mac. Chrom, Shulk, Issac, Roy and Palutena were somewhere behind those guys. No Villager seen there.
Listen, I love Isaac as much as anybody, and I've wanted Isaac in smash for over a decade, and he was my 5th most wanted potential newcomer (behind Mega Man, Ridley, K. Rool, and Little Mac in that order), but he wasn't top 5. Not even close. I think he was top 20, but not top 5 and almost definitely not top 10. He might be a top 5 requested newcomer now, though, with roughly half of the top 5 potential newcomers confirmed.
As for Mewtwo and Roy, I don't count veterans. If you see it otherwise, that's cool. I don't do this for the sake of avoiding us doing IMO odd comparisons like G&W vs. Shulk, and it just gets straight up weird. Plus veterans are easier to add than newcomers. The workload to add veterans is considerably less than newcomers, since you already have a set moveset made.
-Miis had pretty much everything. Extreme support, at the same time extreme hate, and extreme expectance (but not necessarily wanted). Thing is, he wasted 3 movesets.
Nope. They were clearly easy to design, borrowed a lot of moves from a lot of characters, and they function perfectly into the roster. I wouldn't be surprised if all 3 Mii Fighters combined took less time to craft than Palutena.
Besides if we didn't get them, I almost am certain it wouldn't mean more characters. Nah, it'd probably be like more trophies, which no one in their right might should honestly care too much about.
And its even sillier that you can't use them online. I want to use my characters online.
You can use them online. It's called "With Friends". You just can't use them "With Anyone", which is the less important online mode.
-Honestly it is probably just my bias against her, but as far as Mario reps go, Bowser Jr and Toad had bigger followings. SM3DW came out and THEN people got hyped for her.
Toad fans may be loud, but they are very, very small in number. Very small. Waluigi has more fans than Toad. However, to be fair, Waluigi's fan base is bigger than people think though. They are both a persistent bunch, which most of the time I find to be admirable.
-Robin was nowhere near as popular as Lucina or Chrom. You'd have to be on something to think otherwise. People absoutely loved Lucina and Chrom.
The SWF thread for Robin before his confirmation had more posts than any potential newcomer (or veteran) thread than any character not named Ridley or K. Rool (and it wasn't far behind K. Rool). It also had a longer list of supporters than the Chrom thread. Every site I visited in relations to Smash Bros. that I researched this on had the same results.
In general, many people expected Chrom, but few people wanted Chrom. Many people wanted Robin, but few people expected Robin. It sounds like the smash development team had a similar point of view before trying to craft Chrom, and then they largely got bored making Chrom, started some process on Robin, and fell in love with this.
I imagine the development team with Robin had something similar to what we have now with Robin in the smash fanbase. By that I mean Robin went from a pipe dream to constantly winning all these "beset newcomer" polls.