I love Sonic, and God knows (am i allowed to say God on the forums?) that i will still love him even when i am 6 feet under (a tad exaggerated, but still~). Sonic was my second video game character, mario being first, but sonic appealed to me more.
I agree he hasn't been doing well lately, and the reason why haters hate is probably because they have a valid reason to hate him (declining game value).
but this is coming from a man who actually liked sonic heroes, and didn't mind playing sonic riders.
But there are a couple of things i'll never accept as a fan:
the archie comics/other sonic comic (forgot the brand)
anime or cartoons, and the crappy american games (spinball and meanbean machine...i could be wrong)
oh, also the fact that deem bristow (rip) is no more, and that he was replaced by a sub par substitute.
But i believe, sonic will return toglory, he will... just give him time.
i agree that sega used to make fantastic games, they still do (to me, anyway)
like puyo pop fever and stuff.
i don't mind the level designs of the sonic games though, i like them, the lay out, the themes, the styles (pumpkin hill woot)
i even don't mind that all the characters in sonic heroes are little chatter boxes!
the only things i wish they'd fix, is the darn camera in the 3d games, and the crappy (as of shadow the hedgehog) controls.
And please speed it up! the only fast parts in the 2006 game were the mach zones, i swear sonic was moving backwards all the time, thats how slow he was.
and bring back the chaos!!!!!! >_< the limitless replay value!!!!
Sonic is good, haters just need to give him a chance.
if they hate cause they say they hate, then they know nothing but hate.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Smile :) :)"
) just wanted to toss in my few cents~